|
Critic's Corner Discuss a review. Provide constructive feedback. Talk to the industry. |
|
|
|
Critic's Corner Discuss a review. Provide constructive feedback. Talk to the industry. |
|
In Reply to: Not sure what you mean. posted by Rick W on February 6, 2018 at 09:23:48:
I, also, am not clear what jamesgarvin's point is.
Kinda funny, tho', that Salvatore's rebuttal appears not to have been seen by Hansen, Atkinson, et al. Hansen very much had a point that Salvatore's "digital shootout" was not remotely credible, reeking of quid pro quo. Crazy ironic that Salvatore is using Hansen's AA posts on his website!
What a fun time to be alive!
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Follow Ups Full ThreadTopic - Kudos to Stereophile - jtgarrison 08:31:39 01/30/18 (90)
- RE: Kudos to Stereophile - acres verde 12:04:58 02/05/18 (0)
- Read the link for a different view - Charlie8521 11:46:33 02/05/18 (47)
- OK - rather than just posting the link, tell us what you think... - John N 18:06:12 02/05/18 (3)
- FWIW agree - Sordidman 09:07:37 02/07/18 (2)
- RE: FWIW agree - Krav Maga 09:56:57 02/07/18 (1)
- RE: FWIW agree - Sordidman 08:57:21 02/14/18 (0)
- Stand corrected, it was Salvator - Charlie8521 16:52:28 02/05/18 (26)
- Life's too short ... - Dave Pogue 09:40:31 02/06/18 (25)
- Life's too short ...NOT TO KNOW THE TRUTH - Charlie8521 10:09:25 02/06/18 (24)
- RE: Life's too short ...NOT TO KNOW THE TRUTH - John Atkinson 12:04:59 02/06/18 (16)
- Response to JA - Charlie8521 15:21:05 02/06/18 (15)
- RE: Response to JA - John Atkinson 07:30:49 02/07/18 (13)
- Response to JA - Charlie8521 05:17:51 02/10/18 (12)
- RE: Response to JA - John Atkinson 06:54:33 02/10/18 (11)
- Not True JA, $5,000 Bet - Charlie8521 12:27:49 02/13/18 (10)
- RE: Not True JA, $5,000 Bet - John Atkinson 04:27:38 02/14/18 (0)
- Given that there is no reason to doubt the sincerity of either party - DAP 18:31:13 02/13/18 (8)
- The dialogue started privately with JA.... - Charlie8521 08:59:00 02/14/18 (7)
- I meant regarding whether the unit was returned/not returned - DAP 21:12:36 02/14/18 (5)
- RE: I meant regarding whether the unit was returned/not returned - Charlie8521 05:32:36 02/15/18 (4)
- RE: I meant regarding whether the unit was returned/not returned - John Atkinson 07:17:05 02/15/18 (3)
- OK JA, I'll accept that at face value,... - Charlie8521 14:13:02 02/15/18 (2)
- RE: OK JA, I'll accept that at face value,... - John Atkinson 15:48:07 02/15/18 (1)
- RE: OK JA, I'll accept that at face value,... - fantja 23:31:14 02/15/18 (0)
- RE: The dialogue started privately with JA.... - John Atkinson 11:00:49 02/14/18 (0)
- correction - Charlie8521 04:18:15 02/07/18 (0)
- HOW OLD ARE YOU? - Dave Pogue 10:16:14 02/06/18 (6)
- I'm a young pup to you. - Charlie8521 11:39:03 02/06/18 (1)
- Thank you (nt) - Dave Pogue 16:12:41 02/06/18 (0)
- 1930. Yowza! - Rick W 10:31:48 02/06/18 (3)
- Actually, May 1929 - Dave Pogue 10:53:30 02/06/18 (2)
- RE: Actually, May 1929 - SpotcheckBilly12345 07:39:50 02/07/18 (0)
- Hope I make it for another 18 years.............I think. - Rick W 11:14:33 02/06/18 (0)
- Salvatore? LOL! - mkuller 15:10:14 02/05/18 (0)
- This guy seriously needs to get a life - Bruce from DC 13:42:10 02/05/18 (14)
- Someone with the same hobby? - Ivan303 09:44:24 02/06/18 (0)
- Agreed :-) but - DAP 06:09:06 02/06/18 (0)
- Do you know who Charles Hansen was? - Charlie8521 14:16:44 02/05/18 (11)
- RE: Do you know who Charles Hansen was? - Bruce from DC 10:41:12 02/07/18 (0)
- Ummm. - jamesgarvin 14:53:27 02/05/18 (9)
- Not sure what you mean. - Rick W 09:23:48 02/06/18 (8)
- RE: Not sure what you mean. - jamesgarvin 11:12:37 02/07/18 (6)
- RE: Not sure what you mean. - Rick W 13:34:37 02/07/18 (2)
- RE: Not sure what you mean. - jamesgarvin 15:08:27 02/07/18 (1)
- RE: Not sure what you mean. - Mr_Steady 11:35:05 02/08/18 (0)
- You ignore/forget . . . - Beetlemania 13:22:44 02/07/18 (2)
- RE: You ignore/forget . . . - jamesgarvin 15:00:27 02/07/18 (1)
- RE: You ignore/forget . . . - Beetlemania 19:59:13 02/07/18 (0)
- RE: Not sure what you mean. - Beetlemania 09:38:43 02/06/18 (0)
- Well they still have Fremer, - bjh 09:15:01 02/03/18 (3)
- Whose recent "budget reference" is a $30K turntable - Brian H P 10:00:30 02/05/18 (0)
- Well they still have Fremer... - mkuller 20:05:17 02/04/18 (1)
- Same here----NT. - lancelot 06:39:46 02/05/18 (0)
- I'll support that - Bruce from DC 08:20:04 02/03/18 (2)
- Agree with your observation--NT - lancelot 16:37:49 02/03/18 (0)
- Just wish they reviewed more new music...(nt) - mkuller 12:23:47 02/03/18 (0)
- RE: Kudos to Stereophile - b.l.zeebub 13:55:22 02/02/18 (0)
- The only bone that I have to pick - Frihed89 23:48:43 01/30/18 (20)
- SET coverage may be slim - E-Stat 13:14:01 01/31/18 (0)
- RE: The only bone that I have to pick - rrsands 05:06:33 01/31/18 (1)
- RE: The only bone that I have to pick - Frihed89 16:36:57 02/01/18 (0)
- RE: The only bone that I have to pick - RGA 03:18:59 01/31/18 (16)
- Given that speakers need high efficiency - IE both high impedance and high sensitivity - Timbo in Oz 18:03:34 01/31/18 (15)
- RE: Given that speakers need high efficiency - IE both high impedance and high sensitivity - RGA 18:41:47 02/01/18 (14)
- RE: Given that speakers need high efficiency - IE both high impedance and high sensitivity - rebbi 10:18:37 02/08/18 (4)
- RE: Given that speakers need high efficiency - IE both high impedance and high sensitivity - RGA 20:48:31 02/11/18 (3)
- RE: Given that speakers need high efficiency - IE both high impedance and high sensitivity - rebbi 21:04:32 02/11/18 (2)
- RE: Given that speakers need high efficiency - IE both high impedance and high sensitivity - RGA 17:30:39 02/12/18 (1)
- RE: Given that speakers need high efficiency - IE both high impedance and high sensitivity - rebbi 17:48:43 02/12/18 (0)
- RE: Given that speakers need high efficiency - IE both high impedance and high sensitivity - stellavox 05:19:37 02/02/18 (0)
- I was referring to the measurable and audible variations in FR with many SE valve/spkr combinations. - Timbo in Oz 00:02:35 02/02/18 (7)
- RE: "Duke's swarm idea..." - b.l.zeebub 04:45:27 02/04/18 (5)
- RE: "Duke's swarm idea..." - Inmate51 06:37:19 02/04/18 (4)
- RE: Dr Earl Geddes... - b.l.zeebub 07:48:49 02/04/18 (3)
- People right and left have stolen his design with the writing rags giving no credit-nT - Cleantimestream 00:46:01 02/05/18 (2)
- Duke has collaborated with Geddes and gives credit where it's due - Dave_K 16:19:18 02/05/18 (0)
- RE: People right and left have stolen his design with the writing rags giving no credit-nT - b.l.zeebub 07:34:33 02/05/18 (0)
- RE: I was referring to the measurable and audible variations in FR with many SE valve/spkr combinations. - RGA 01:49:11 02/04/18 (0)
- binaural recording video reviews too good to miss - bullethead 13:06:36 01/30/18 (1)
- RE: binaural - hifitommy 21:46:25 02/01/18 (0)
- RE: Kudos to Stereophile - semuta 11:14:17 01/30/18 (6)
- RE: Kudos to Stereophile - jtgarrison 11:34:02 01/30/18 (2)
- RE: Kudos to Stereophile - John Atkinson 04:30:43 02/01/18 (1)
- RE: Kudos to Stereophile - fantja 04:03:38 02/15/18 (0)
- RE: Kudos to Stereophile - jtgarrison 11:24:26 01/30/18 (2)
- I was kind of ... - hifitommy 21:34:28 02/01/18 (0)
- RE: Kudos to Stereophile - Michael Lavorgna 12:34:29 01/30/18 (0)
- I am very much appreciating the component comparisons... - Ladok 09:03:17 01/30/18 (2)
- The best way to evaluate any new component - Brian H P 11:20:30 01/31/18 (0)
- RE: I am very much appreciating the component comparisons... - jtgarrison 09:43:46 01/30/18 (0)
Follow Ups
- RE: Not sure what you mean. - Beetlemania 09:38:43 02/06/18 (0)
Top of Page ]
[ Contact Us ]
[ Support/Wish List ]
[ Copyright © 2025, Audio Asylum, all rights reserved ]
