In Reply to: RE: Bulk conversion of oversize FLAC's posted by Dave_K on March 19, 2018 at 09:37:02:
It's another thing entirely to claim that different identical copies sound different, and that sound quality gets worse in successive generations of copies.
True but your point strikes me as another thing entirely to what the authors are claiming. Their suggestion is that successive wav>flac>wav conversions create files that are NOT identical due to issues with the flac format. They further argue that, though the differences seem negligible, they matter.
Whether they're right is also another thing entirely but it's how I read the text. I stand to be corrected.
Though I admit to being perplexed by some aspects of the experiments' design (esp the claim that image height correlates with sound quality - it strikes me as a circular argument), I don't think the paper can be dismissed simply with a wave of the hand.
Dave
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Follow Ups
- RE: Bulk conversion of oversize FLAC's - Ryelands 10:18:30 03/19/18 (17)
- Conversion Tests Don't Support Compounded Generational Degregation Claims - emailtim 18:37:48 03/20/18 (1)
- More test results - emailtim 19:41:19 03/20/18 (0)
- RE: Bulk conversion of oversize FLAC's - Dave_K 14:32:55 03/19/18 (1)
- RE: Bulk conversion of oversize FLAC's - emailtim 15:13:18 03/19/18 (0)
- RE: Bulk conversion of oversize FLAC's - PAR 11:01:45 03/19/18 (12)
- RE: Bulk conversion of oversize FLAC's - Ryelands 11:44:31 03/19/18 (11)
- RE: Bulk conversion of oversize FLAC's - emailtim 14:14:00 03/19/18 (10)
- RE: Bulk conversion of oversize FLAC's - Ryelands 03:54:09 03/20/18 (9)
- RE: Bulk conversion of oversize FLAC's - emailtim 12:42:33 03/20/18 (6)
- No bit comparison checks - emailtim 13:51:06 03/20/18 (5)
- RE: No bit comparison checks - Ryelands 04:35:37 03/21/18 (4)
- Sloppiness, Really ??? - emailtim 12:20:32 03/21/18 (0)
- RE: No bit comparison checks - Dave_K 07:51:31 03/21/18 (2)
- Absolute BS - emailtim 12:27:22 03/21/18 (0)
- Watch my lips - Ryelands 09:42:34 03/21/18 (0)
- RE: Bulk conversion of oversize FLAC's - Dave_K 04:18:46 03/20/18 (1)
- RE: Bulk conversion of oversize FLAC's - Ryelands 05:35:12 03/20/18 (0)