Five out of six is not statistically significant

Follow Ups Full Thread

Topic - THE ANALOG/DIGITAL CHALLENGE - John Elison 17:57:23 06/27/07 (123)

I think it was courageous to be honest in your impression of the DarTZeel - jdaniel 15:51:25 06/29/07 (0)

Geez, the world went to hell in a handbasket in... - Hi-Fi Nut 15:37:39 06/29/07 (0)

darTZeel - Arlekino 17:44:04 06/28/07 (20)

The Rockport Sirius III is one class act.... - John Elison 19:05:34 06/28/07 (19)

Nicely written John... - EdAInWestOC 05:45:33 06/29/07 (0)

RE: The Rockport Sirius III is one class act.... - mikel 22:52:16 06/28/07 (16)

You're right.... - John Elison 06:53:49 06/29/07 (9)

i appreciate that John,.....and...... - mikel 07:05:19 06/29/07 (8)

The one-word answer is, "No!" - John Elison 07:48:43 06/29/07 (7)

RE: The one-word answer is, "No!" - mikel 08:33:59 06/29/07 (6)

RE: The one-word answer is, "No!" - John Elison 10:16:38 06/29/07 (5)

thanks....and one more question. - mikel 11:15:31 06/29/07 (4)

RE: thanks....and one more question. - John Elison 16:13:27 06/29/07 (3)

Cum Ba Ya....there's peace in the valley once more. - mikel 16:25:02 06/29/07 (2)

per Challenge terms---$250 to the audioasylum done. - mikel 11:28:57 07/05/07 (1)

RE: per Challenge terms---$250 to the audioasylum done. - John Elison 18:06:08 07/05/07 (0)

Could you please inform the connections used for playback? - bjh 04:34:37 06/29/07 (5)

RE: Could you please inform the connections used for playback? - mikel 06:44:43 06/29/07 (4)

Thanks. - bjh 07:56:05 06/29/07 (3)

ps. - bjh 08:55:46 06/29/07 (2)

RE: ps. - John Elison 09:33:22 06/29/07 (1)

I don't get it! - bjh 10:23:24 06/29/07 (0)

RE: The Rockport Sirius III is one class act.... - Arlekino 19:30:24 06/28/07 (0)

Blind Testing - BTW 17:41:38 06/28/07 (0)

So, um, guess from the looks of things there's no cordial joint statement in the offing ..?.... nt - J.D. 16:33:54 06/28/07 (2)

Don't count your chickens... - bjh 05:46:57 06/29/07 (0)

RE: So, um, guess from the looks of things there's no cordial joint statement in the offing ..?.... nt - Elmo 05:15:09 06/29/07 (0)

RE: THE ANALOG/DIGITAL CHALLENGE - B.K. 16:14:52 06/28/07 (4)

RE: THE ANALOG/DIGITAL CHALLENGE - bjh 16:23:33 06/28/07 (3)

I'll do my part . . .;8^) /nt\ - HenryH 04:18:13 06/29/07 (1)

I'll do my part . . part deux . . . .;8^) /nt\ - HenryH 04:19:16 06/29/07 (0)

i will help with that - OMalley 16:32:05 06/28/07 (0)

well - mothra 14:10:13 06/28/07 (0)

RE: puzzled by THE ANALOG/DIGITAL CHALLENGE - Bruce from DC 13:09:15 06/28/07 (6)

RE: puzzled by THE ANALOG/DIGITAL CHALLENGE - GGA 16:39:24 06/28/07 (0)

RE: puzzled by THE ANALOG/DIGITAL CHALLENGE - Tightwad 13:31:07 06/28/07 (4)

RE: puzzled by THE ANALOG/DIGITAL CHALLENGE - JBC 13:37:20 06/28/07 (3)

RE: puzzled by THE ANALOG/DIGITAL CHALLENGE - Tightwad 13:50:53 06/28/07 (2)

RE: puzzled by THE ANALOG/DIGITAL CHALLENGE - rich121 15:16:57 06/28/07 (0)

RE: puzzled by THE ANALOG/DIGITAL CHALLENGE - mothra 13:59:13 06/28/07 (0)

Admiration, congratulations, and thanks. - jsm 12:46:12 06/28/07 (0)

Hypotheses and Scientific method - JBC 12:28:16 06/28/07 (8)

Five out of six is not statistically significant - Tightwad 12:57:24 06/28/07 (7)

And, the others that did blind testing, got it reversed 100% of the time... (nt) - rich121 15:21:07 06/28/07 (0)

The p-value for determining statistical significant is not set in stone. - bjh 14:56:04 06/28/07 (5)

I think he meant "at least 5 out of 6" - Mark Kelly 18:25:15 06/28/07 (4)

Possible. I was intrepreting the - bjh 18:33:23 06/28/07 (3)

RE: Possible. I was intrepreting the - Tightwad 08:51:56 06/29/07 (1)

I acknowledge my error. - bjh 08:59:48 06/29/07 (0)

My simple calc - Mark Kelly 18:43:29 06/28/07 (0)

John! You are awesome... - larryLR 11:35:47 06/28/07 (0)

"To be honest, I am still quite surprised that I won the challenge." - soulfood 10:07:19 06/28/07 (0)

Let me make sure I understand (and perhaps . . . - Tightwad 09:07:54 06/28/07 (1)

RE: Let me make sure I understand (and perhaps . . . - bjh 10:41:21 06/28/07 (0)

Help me out here John - E-Stat 08:21:13 06/28/07 (0)

ps. - bjh 07:49:39 06/28/07 (0)

RE: THE ANALOG/DIGITAL CHALLENGE - bjh 07:19:57 06/28/07 (0)

All that I'm sure of is... - EdAInWestOC 05:08:47 06/28/07 (1)

Make mine a double and next round on me .... ;) n/t - Brian_T 01:31:41 06/29/07 (0)

The challenge rules created the results.... - tubesforever 21:55:41 06/27/07 (14)

Really? What rule declares that a $100k system must be innacurate? - artemus 22:54:49 06/27/07 (6)

Its simply a matter of physics and material engineering....no flames here - tubesforever 10:07:48 06/28/07 (3)

It's amazing - Story 19:26:05 06/28/07 (0)

As usual ... - bjh 10:48:21 06/28/07 (1)

Or just chatting with an inmate friend..... - tubesforever 11:27:48 06/28/07 (0)

If I spent that much money on gear, I would want to see God! n/t - reuben 05:15:56 06/28/07 (1)

to each his own ..... - Elmo 06:42:39 06/28/07 (0)

RE: The challenge rules created the results.... - John Elison 22:27:54 06/27/07 (6)

RE: The challenge rules created the results.... - tubesforever 10:26:39 06/28/07 (0)

Many many variables.... - rich121 23:41:24 06/27/07 (4)

Rich I will be in the Northwest from 7/15 to 7/21 and would love to meet your group. - tubesforever 11:10:00 06/28/07 (0)

RE: Many many variables.... - mothra 04:06:32 06/28/07 (2)

I once tested a half dozen different color dyes to see if I could hear improvement.... - tubesforever 11:11:41 06/28/07 (1)

which ones tasted best? [nt] - OMalley 17:50:58 06/29/07 (0)

ya gotta be kidding.....you're laying it all at the feet of darTZeel. - mikel 21:32:19 06/27/07 (29)

I don't know why you'd be surprised. - Rick W 08:59:11 06/28/07 (0)

RE: ya gotta be kidding.....you're laying it all at the feet of darTZeel. - John Elison 22:18:14 06/27/07 (27)

Well... - mosin 22:33:56 06/27/07 (26)

as you know, vinyl is equally, if not more "screwed up" by the record companies as digital... - rich121 23:57:22 06/27/07 (24)

RE: as you know, vinyl is equally, if not more "screwed up" by the record companies as digital... - mosin 15:53:52 06/28/07 (1)

Message and pictures sent again.. - rich121 00:48:37 06/29/07 (0)

It's the commercial companies that "screw up" recordings in nearly every format. - Teresa 00:50:48 06/28/07 (21)

As usual... I disagree with how you post.. - rich121 01:06:42 06/28/07 (20)

ditto - blackwax@mac.com 22:22:41 06/28/07 (0)

I am sorry you do not understand but it is a know fact - Teresa 02:02:14 06/28/07 (18)

RE: I am sorry you do not understand but it is a know fact - rich121 05:30:21 06/28/07 (1)

It's the commercial companies that "screw up" recordings in nearly every format. Did you miss the word Nearly? - Teresa 14:59:05 06/28/07 (0)

RE: I am sorry you do not understand but it is a know fact - mothra 03:59:58 06/28/07 (15)

I make do with my commercial LPs until an audiophile version is issued. IT IS ABOUT MUSIC FIRST! - Teresa 15:15:45 06/28/07 (14)

RE: I make do with my commercial LPs until an audiophile version is issued. IT IS ABOUT MUSIC FIRST! - blackwax@mac.com 22:25:48 06/28/07 (1)

What could possibly be dumb about the musical truth? - Teresa 22:45:09 06/28/07 (0)

RE: I make do with my commercial LPs until an audiophile version is issued. IT IS ABOUT MUSIC FIRST! - mothra 17:37:20 06/28/07 (0)

Okie dokie, smokey - Fretless 16:27:15 06/28/07 (10)

If highly compromised commercial LPs sound good on your system you would not like a sound of a Master Tape! - Teresa 17:24:12 06/28/07 (9)

Amazing. How does doddering into second childhood feel anyway? ; )(nt) - Fretless 17:53:49 06/28/07 (5)

If you cannot hear the dramatic increase in resolution that Audiophile LPs offer that means: - Teresa 21:06:58 06/29/07 (0)

Fretless, she's a right nutter and best ignored ... ;) - Brian_T 01:21:56 06/29/07 (3)

It's not nice to call people names. The most important things I do to preserve my LPs. - Teresa 21:16:51 06/29/07 (0)

RE: Fretless, she's a right nutter and best ignored ... ;) - Fretless 08:46:04 06/29/07 (1)

I was just thinking the same thing about you. (nt) - Teresa 21:19:15 06/29/07 (0)

RE: If highly compromised commercial LPs sound good on your system you would not like a sound of a Master Tape! - mothra 17:43:13 06/28/07 (2)

A real audiophile recording as opposed to the major labels rip-off of the word "audiophile" means alot - Teresa 21:54:02 06/28/07 (1)

RE: A real audiophile recording as opposed to the major labels rip-off of the word "audiophile" means alot - mothra 00:37:24 06/29/07 (0)

RE: Well... - John Elison 22:41:21 06/27/07 (0)

Re: "...Mike's system is... at least 10 times bigger than life." Please clarify... - Abel McCain 21:27:48 06/27/07 (0)

who was the walrus ? - J.D. 20:57:24 06/27/07 (5)

RE: who was the walrus ? - J.D. 21:11:59 06/27/07 (4)

RE: who was the walrus ? - mosin 21:18:38 06/27/07 (3)

Is that you Gozer? - JTimothyA 21:44:26 06/27/07 (2)

RE: Is that you Gozer? - mosin 22:11:02 06/27/07 (1)

You may be big in Summaria, but careful, that door swings both way - JTimothyA 22:31:57 06/27/07 (0)

Oy...we are still not learning anything new :-) - Penguin 19:36:18 06/27/07 (3)

I hear a difference! - Muzikmike 19:43:47 06/27/07 (2)

I think I've been smellin' that mother for years! ;-) (nt) - John Elison 20:44:53 06/27/07 (0)

never mind the sound!!! - Penguin 19:49:45 06/27/07 (0)

It was great to meet you and to be of service... - Ted Smith 18:54:08 06/27/07 (1)

Thanks Ted, you were a godsend... - John Elison 19:02:15 06/27/07 (0)

RE: THE ANALOG/DIGITAL CHALLENGE - newyorkp7 18:09:32 06/27/07 (1)

You're Welcome! (nt) - John Elison 18:19:46 06/27/07 (0)

Jeezo, John... I just thought... - Muzikmike 18:03:54 06/27/07 (3)

Hey! I like barbecue! What can I say? ;-) - John Elison 19:35:05 06/27/07 (2)

wow, i haven't been here in a while, i sure missed a lot. - mattjk 02:01:18 07/23/07 (1)

Nevermind, I found the challenge post NT. - mattjk 02:14:14 07/23/07 (0)

Follow Ups

Five out of six is not statistically significant - Tightwad 12:57:24 06/28/07 (7)

And, the others that did blind testing, got it reversed 100% of the time... (nt) - rich121 15:21:07 06/28/07 (0)

The p-value for determining statistical significant is not set in stone. - bjh 14:56:04 06/28/07 (5)

I think he meant "at least 5 out of 6" - Mark Kelly 18:25:15 06/28/07 (4)

Possible. I was intrepreting the - bjh 18:33:23 06/28/07 (3)

RE: Possible. I was intrepreting the - Tightwad 08:51:56 06/29/07 (1)

I acknowledge my error. - bjh 08:59:48 06/29/07 (0)

My simple calc - Mark Kelly 18:43:29 06/28/07 (0)

Post a Message!