How can a good CD player be better than an expensive SACD or DVD-Audio player much less a turntable? - Teresa

Follow Ups Full Thread

Topic - Vinyl Vs CD - John-from Seattle 18:46:59 10/14/06 (65)

Re: Vinyl Vs CD - John Elison 13:46:51 10/15/06 (4)

That's funny John, My $629 Music Hall MMF-5 turntable creamed my $1,699 Xindak SCD-1 tubed SACD player. - Teresa 22:12:59 10/15/06 (2)

I don't doubt it. What you need is a good CD player. ;-) (nt) - John Elison 23:59:38 10/15/06 (1)

How can a good CD player be better than an expensive SACD or DVD-Audio player much less a turntable? - Teresa 02:47:03 10/16/06 (0)

Of course there's always the possibility you just didn't spend you $15k wisely. Perish the thought I'm sure! nt - bjh 22:02:15 10/15/06 (0)

CD is going the way of the Dodo , and fast ... which begs the question: - texanater 07:00:53 10/15/06 (9)

CD is going the way of the Dodo , and fast ... - Owen 11:55:42 10/15/06 (0)

Re: CD is going the way of the Dodo , and fast ... which begs the question: - John-from Seattle 08:25:12 10/15/06 (7)

Re: CD is going the way of the Dodo , and fast ... which begs the question: - Don T 09:32:23 10/15/06 (6)

Re: CD is going the way of the Dodo , and fast ... which begs the question: - kentaja@yahoo.com 11:20:59 10/15/06 (5)

Re: CD is going the way of the Dodo , and fast ... which begs the question: - John-from Seattle 14:38:27 10/15/06 (0)

nice! - Don T 11:58:56 10/15/06 (3)

Re: nice! - kentaja@yahoo.com 15:09:57 10/15/06 (0)

Re: nice! - SOUR MILK MOON 12:44:12 10/15/06 (1)

Things aren't so bad in Phoenix/Arizona. - Don T 16:39:06 10/15/06 (0)

Software is software, be it vinyl, cd, dvd, dvda, sacd.... - tubesforever 22:40:10 10/14/06 (2)

tubes you left out two of my favorites Reel to Reel and cassette. - Teresa 17:41:52 10/15/06 (0)

Re: Software is software, be it vinyl, cd, dvd, dvda, sacd.... - John-from Seattle 08:27:36 10/15/06 (0)

"Better" is a terribly relative term when it comes to vinyl (long) - beto 22:22:03 10/14/06 (2)

Re: "Better" is a terribly relative term when it comes to vinyl (long) - John-from Seattle 08:51:47 10/15/06 (0)

actually it is commercially available - tunenut 23:15:31 10/14/06 (0)

Anybody reasonably serious about collecting music has both formats, and more. End of story. (nt) - Tightwad 22:20:10 10/14/06 (7)

Re: Anybody reasonably serious about collecting music has both formats, and more. End of story. (nt) - Abel McCain 05:39:24 10/16/06 (0)

There are much more than just TWO formats, I collect music in 6 formats and crummy CD isn't one of them! - Teresa 22:26:48 10/15/06 (0)

YES! - Larry I 14:41:16 10/15/06 (1)

Re: YES! - Tightwad 17:37:28 10/15/06 (0)

Words of devine inspiration.... - tubesforever 09:01:31 10/15/06 (0)

Re: Anybody reasonably serious about collecting music has both formats, and more. End of story. (nt) - John-from Seattle 08:29:22 10/15/06 (0)

EXACTLY!! - Maniac 07:58:19 10/15/06 (0)

to this day, i still can't understand why these debates come up - sberger 21:28:46 10/14/06 (1)

Re: to this day, i still can't understand why these debates come up - John-from Seattle 21:48:36 10/14/06 (0)

Re: Vinyl Vs CD - mothra 21:11:41 10/14/06 (1)

Re: Vinyl Vs CD - John-from Seattle 21:55:28 10/14/06 (0)

Try SACD's - jnorv 19:36:12 10/14/06 (12)

Close - but no cigar! - JCS 01:35:48 10/15/06 (4)

But they don't have the tracking distortion.. - SnaggS 04:31:15 10/15/06 (3)

Re: But they don't have the tracking distortion.. - JCS 04:12:40 10/16/06 (2)

Well.. you can't hear it.. - SnaggS 06:40:35 10/16/06 (1)

Daniel a lot depends on turntable geometry. - Teresa 13:58:16 10/16/06 (0)

Re: Try SACD's - John-from Seattle 21:57:03 10/14/06 (0)

Agree. - HenryH 19:38:55 10/14/06 (5)

And if it were not for MP3 - jnorv 19:45:21 10/14/06 (4)

And we poke at Teresa - jnorv 19:54:05 10/14/06 (2)

Re: And we poke at Teresa - Bry 06:33:04 10/15/06 (0)

Not likely. /nt\ - HenryH 05:08:37 10/15/06 (0)

Yes . . . sigh. /nt\ - HenryH 19:47:22 10/14/06 (0)

Re: Vinyl Vs CD - Sherlock 19:26:38 10/14/06 (12)

Really? - Don T 20:51:10 10/14/06 (11)

Re: Really? - Teresa 22:22:53 10/14/06 (6)

My feelings exactly after 3 years back in to Vinyl - JDN 08:28:41 10/15/06 (1)

Re: My feelings exactly after 3 years back in to Vinyl - Teresa 17:36:51 10/15/06 (0)

Re: Really? - Don T 00:16:34 10/15/06 (3)

Get one of those new Classic Records HDADs with 192kHz PCM on one side & 96kHz PCM on the other plus the 44.1kHz CD and - Teresa 00:48:20 10/15/06 (2)

Why? - Don T 09:50:24 10/15/06 (1)

I think I know why do not experience pain with CD, you don't listen to Classical Music or massed strings. - Teresa 03:43:16 10/16/06 (0)

Re: Really? - John-from Seattle 22:03:37 10/14/06 (1)

I personally liked vinyl because I could actually here the bass player plucking the string - JDN 08:50:04 10/15/06 (0)

Re: Really? - Scottrt 21:01:26 10/14/06 (1)

Re: Really? - Don T 22:05:01 10/14/06 (0)

Re: Vinyl Vs CD - Scottrt 19:07:33 10/14/06 (4)

It depends. - cheap-Jack 19:43:51 10/14/06 (3)

Thats my point - Scottrt 19:57:22 10/14/06 (2)

Re: Thats my point - John-from Seattle 22:07:41 10/14/06 (0)

Re: Thats my point - blake 20:30:00 10/14/06 (0)

Re: Vinyl Vs CD, clarification - John-from Seattle 18:53:26 10/14/06 (0)

Follow Ups

How can a good CD player be better than an expensive SACD or DVD-Audio player much less a turntable? - Teresa 02:47:03 10/16/06 (0)