In Reply to: Test of LRS on Audio Science Review website posted by triamp on September 25, 2020 at 03:52:42:
Agree completely -- the test methods were flawed -- and I and some others raised objections in that thread.
Davey pointed out that he measured the bass response *with the speakers lifted off the floor*, a fatal measurement error -- the bass response of a dipole will be seriousy screwed if you do that, owing to an acoustic short circuit around the bottom.
There are other egregious errors as well, not the least of which is that Amir did his listening tests with *one* speaker (sigh).
Fortunately, there was a lot of pushback from people who have actually *heard* Maggies! The negatives seemed to come mostly from people who hadn't, but felt themselves experts because they'd read the review.
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Follow Ups
- The review was absurd - josh358 06:03:17 09/28/20 (11)
- measurement technology on planars - DrChaos 19:09:59 09/30/20 (1)
- RE: measurement technology on planars - josh358 18:33:59 10/13/20 (0)
- RE: The review was absurd - timm 18:51:48 09/30/20 (2)
- RE: The review was absurd - shumi 09:48:08 10/02/20 (1)
- RE: The review was absurd - josh358 18:33:28 10/13/20 (0)
- RE: The review was absurd - sbrook 09:08:02 09/28/20 (3)
- RE: The review was absurd - josh358 18:38:00 10/13/20 (0)
- RE: The review was absurd - BDP24 12:17:32 10/01/20 (1)
- RE: The review was absurd - sbrook 12:47:16 10/01/20 (0)
- RE: The review was absurd - Davey 08:12:23 09/28/20 (1)
- +1 (NT) - josh358 18:40:11 10/13/20 (0)