In Reply to: RE: According to Arthur C Clark posted by May Belt on August 7, 2011 at 09:45:40:
"People seem to arguing around what WORDS are used to describe how the Stein Music device (or devices) work"
No May, they are simply calling them out on the carpet for their bullshit psuedo scientific explanations. That is utterly independent of what any reviewer is percieving. Psuedo science is psuedo science no matter what any reivewers' subjective experienes may be.
"and are ignoring the serious implications in the reviewers experiences."
There are no *serious* implications from subjective reviews. to many variables. If there were any substantial effects with "serious implications" then all we need is a varifiable waterfall graph showing differences before and after.
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Follow Ups
- um....no - Analog Scott 10:36:43 08/07/11 (54)
- RE: um....no - May Belt 10:39:27 08/08/11 (53)
- RE: um....no - Analog Scott 12:26:27 08/08/11 (52)
- RE: um....no - tomservo 12:39:54 08/08/11 (51)
- RE: um....no - Tony Lauck 07:19:54 08/09/11 (0)
- Hey, no fair piling on. One fake scientist at a time, please. nt - geoffkait 14:55:09 08/08/11 (49)
- Why Geoff - tomservo 16:10:37 08/08/11 (5)
- More philosophy - geoffkait 17:48:31 08/08/11 (4)
- RE: More - tomservo 19:23:30 08/08/11 (3)
- RE: Skepticism - geoffkait 02:58:51 08/09/11 (1)
- RE: Skepticism - tomservo 06:57:13 08/09/11 (0)
- Archaeoacoustics - Steyr 20:51:59 08/08/11 (0)
- Ironic given you are the first "fake scientist" to jump in. - Analog Scott 15:50:26 08/08/11 (42)
- No, what's ironic is that a hairdresser is pretending to be scientific. nt - geoffkait 16:08:28 08/08/11 (41)
- RE: No, what's ironic is that a hairdresser is pretending to be scientific. nt - tomservo 19:38:52 08/08/11 (39)
- RE: Using Science as a hook" - geoffkait 03:47:10 08/09/11 (38)
- RE: Using Science as a hook" - tomservo 07:03:42 08/09/11 (37)
- RE: Using Science as a hook" - geoffkait 08:31:50 08/09/11 (31)
- RE: Using Science as a hook" - tomservo 10:46:02 08/09/11 (28)
- RE: Using Science as a hook" - geoffkait 12:41:25 08/09/11 (27)
- RE: Using Science as a hook" - tomservo 18:09:01 08/09/11 (24)
- Not so long ago another offered a similar tweeter - Steyr 05:59:08 08/12/11 (1)
- What does that have to do with the price of spinach? - geoffkait 07:23:06 08/12/11 (0)
- RE: Using Science as a hook" - geoffkait 03:46:29 08/10/11 (21)
- RE: Using Science as a hook" - tomservo 07:10:26 08/10/11 (20)
- RE: Using Science as a hook" - Tony Lauck 09:20:49 08/10/11 (15)
- RE: Using Science as a hook" - geoffkait 10:42:58 08/10/11 (2)
- RE: Using Science as a hook" - Tony Lauck 11:31:31 08/10/11 (1)
- RE: Using Science as a hook" - geoffkait 12:03:08 08/10/11 (0)
- RE: Using Science as a hook" - tomservo 10:22:51 08/10/11 (11)
- RE: Using Science as a hook" - geoffkait 10:30:14 08/10/11 (10)
- Tom makes real products you market aquarium gravel - Steyr 06:05:58 08/12/11 (8)
- "stick to deluding the faithful." - Analog Scott 09:08:05 08/12/11 (0)
- You're a a little late to the party - geoffkait 06:46:58 08/12/11 (6)
- RE: You're a a little late to the party - tomservo 07:01:32 08/12/11 (5)
- RE: You're a a little late to the party - geoffkait 07:53:32 08/12/11 (4)
- RE: You're a a little late to the party - tomservo 14:42:20 08/12/11 (3)
- RE: You're a a little late to the party - geoffkait 15:26:37 08/12/11 (2)
- RE: You're a a little late to the party - tomservo 17:40:56 08/12/11 (1)
- RE: You're a a little late to the party - geoffkait 19:43:02 08/12/11 (0)
- RE: Using Science as a hook" - tomservo 11:12:56 08/10/11 (0)
- RE: Using Science as a hook" - geoffkait 08:29:13 08/10/11 (1)
- RE: Using Science as a hook" - tomservo 09:57:33 08/10/11 (0)
- Remember what I told you? - Analog Scott 07:53:44 08/10/11 (1)
- RE: Remember what I told you? - tomservo 10:16:15 08/10/11 (0)
- "operate quantum mechanically" - Analog Scott 12:55:53 08/09/11 (1)
- RE: "operate quantum mechanically" - geoffkait 15:52:21 08/09/11 (0)
- "Why pretend? Do you think I'm lying?" - Analog Scott 08:36:36 08/09/11 (1)
- RE: "Why pretend? Do you think I'm lying?" - geoffkait 10:24:26 08/09/11 (0)
- RE: Using Science as a hook" - Analog Scott 07:32:05 08/09/11 (4)
- RE: Using Science as a hook" - tomservo 11:11:23 08/09/11 (1)
- RE: Using Science as a hook" - Analog Scott 12:24:24 08/09/11 (0)
- Bad hairday? - geoffkait 10:40:19 08/09/11 (1)
- Hey! Where'd you find my family album? - kerr 11:07:28 08/09/11 (0)
- Yep, called that one. - Analog Scott 16:30:41 08/08/11 (0)