Follow Ups Full Thread

Topic - Do you see music as a necessity or luxury in people's lives? - Guy 00:51:49 11/06/05 (32)

• Re: Thanks for contributers' answers. NT - Guy 06:38:40 11/18/05 (0)
• Are those the only two choices? - jfz 07:42:22 11/09/05 (1)
• You had in mind perhaps, a scourge? - Paul_A 18:03:29 11/09/05 (0)
• Depends on how you define "life." (nt) - Jazztrumpet 19:46:16 11/08/05 (0)
• Great question... - Arvind Kohli 09:35:43 11/08/05 (1)
• Re: Great question...thanks for thoughtful answer... - Guy 00:33:40 11/09/05 (0)
• Art is a prerequisite for today's civilized man. - soulfood 07:53:17 11/08/05 (3)
• Re: I'd have to compare music with other arts.... - Guy 00:37:08 11/09/05 (2)
• There are also complex distinctions between appreciating and consuming. (nt) - soulfood 10:26:28 11/09/05 (1)
• Re: good distinction. Point taken. - Guy 03:15:14 11/10/05 (0)
• Depends on what the meaning of "necessity" and "luxury" are. - Thornhill 15:31:13 11/06/05 (1)
• Re: Yes, but why music more so than art or literature.... - Guy 00:38:31 11/09/05 (0)
• Sans music a necessary part of life would be lost. A nice system to listen to it on is a luxury... N/T - musetap 12:36:45 11/06/05 (0)
• As the man said - Amphissa 11:57:11 11/06/05 (0)
• Re: Do you see Guy's trolls as a necessity or an annoyance on AA? - mkuller 11:34:08 11/06/05 (8)
• Past history would indicate troll. Now watch the fun!! - opinionated 12:42:23 11/06/05 (4)
• Re: Past history would indicate troll. Now watch the fun!! - Todd Krieger 14:24:21 11/06/05 (3)
• Re: Past history would indicate troll. Now watch the fun!! - opinionated 19:10:08 11/06/05 (2)
• Re: Can you read at all???! - Guy 21:15:50 11/06/05 (1)
• Re: Can you read at all???! proves the point..... - opinionated 06:12:13 11/07/05 (0)
• Neither.... - Todd Krieger 11:49:18 11/06/05 (2)
• Provocative? - mkuller 13:45:47 11/06/05 (1)
• Re: Provocative? Amen! [xoxo] - opinionated 19:11:24 11/06/05 (0)
• art (NT) - tunenut 11:28:24 11/06/05 (0)
• I Don't Know.... But...... - Todd Krieger 09:29:04 11/06/05 (0)
• necessity - hifitommy 08:21:02 11/06/05 (0)
• Re: Do you see music as a necessity or luxury in people's lives? - Amphissa 08:05:14 11/06/05 (1)
• Re:Life without Nietzsche is no mistake! - Guy 21:21:16 11/06/05 (0)
• I prefer listening to test tones (nt) - mhardy6647 07:49:19 11/06/05 (0)
• Confucius says: Necessity - John Marks 06:46:43 11/06/05 (0)
• Luxury. - Chris_F 06:25:35 11/06/05 (1)
• Re: Luxury. "It doesn't help put food on the table,... - Guy 00:40:38 11/09/05 (0)

Follow Ups

• Re: Yes, but why music more so than art or literature.... - Guy 00:38:31 11/09/05 (0)