![]() ![]() |
Audio Asylum Thread Printer Get a view of an entire thread on one page |
For Sale Ads |
In Reply to: More complexity... posted by SE on May 11, 2002 at 12:05:15:
I did some listening of the Amazon samples as well.msk58 -- The recordings you have are EXACTLY the same ones I have in mono. It looks like the set was reissued with a different catalog # (69003) in 2000. I THINK the set I have is mono (it says that it is on the package AND the CDs. Do your actual CDs have "mono" or "stereo" printed on them? If they truly DID reissue these recordings in stereo, I'd be interested in replacing the set I have.
Please let me know!
TOOL -- The 10 Hungarian Rhapsodies you have on the new EMI Great Recordings single CD are unquestionably DIFFERENT from the recordings both msk58 and I have. I'm pretty sure they're stereo, since they sound much more recent (fuller, sweeter) than the 1957/58 recordings. I can tell you this, though. Even based solely on the Amazon samples, Cziffra doesn't sound like his fingers are working as well as they did in the earlier recordings.
These performances are special. There are very few recordings that I would call "totally unique" like these, so I may just spend a few extra dollars to sort out the "best of the best".
Other recordings I would place in this category?
Chaliapin's Mussorgsky
Furtwangler's Wartime Beethoven
Borodin Quartet's Shostakovich
Callas' Norma and Tosca
Follow Ups:
Hi SE, yes, the cover photo on the booklet is the same so it's probably just a re-release of the same content...except for maybe the stereo/mono issue! Both the discs say 'Stereo, ADD, Digital Remastering 1987 by EMI France, Made in Holland' but the package doesn't indicate either way. I'm listening to it now but would be hard pressed to say whether or not it actually is in stereo since I only have my Denon mini-system hooked up right now (actually I prefer to listen to many historic performances on it anyway-the limitations of the recording are not as pronounced as on a 'real' stereo!). It may in fact be exactly what you have and the stereo is a misprint... You've made me curious about Cziffra's Transcendental Etudes now...I've been on a bit of a Liszt kick the past few months and have been trying to acquire some interesting things. In some budget line they just re-released a concerto recording by Cziffra (Grieg & Schumann I think) but I haven't picked it up yet (it got a scathing review in Gramophone).
Here's what interested me...(1) For $6.98, Amazon has Cziffra doing the 2 Liszt Concertos plus the Totentanz. Good reviews, but I don't even care. I've GOT to hear Cziffra in these works!
(2) Liszt Hungarian Rhapsodies (Orchestrated). I've been looking for a truly great set of these things. The review at Amazon of these performances conducted by Hermann Scherchen sounds like they're "over the top" -- just like Cziffra.
(3) Even if you already own (and you should) Richter's fantastic studio recordings of the two Concertos w/Kondrashin, pick up this LIVE recording made at about the same time. Totally awesome...
(4) Other pianists I like in Liszt include Brendel (poetic/intellectual), Bolet (poetic), Krystian Zimerman (amazing Sonata in B) and Lazar Berman. If you feel like looking back into history, there is Arrau's EARLY Liszt and Emil von Sauer (a Liszt pupil!!!).
Thanks for the recommendations! I already own the live Richter disc & agree, quite impressive. Don't have Cziffra in the concerti though, so I'll have to put that on the list. Other Cziffra of the same period includes a disc entitled 'Paraphrases and Transcriptions' (1954-56) on Hungaroton HCD 31596 which is quite impressive. And then there's a disc entitled 'Message a Tous les Pianistes' which includes Cziffra's transcriptions of Brahms 4 hand piano Hungarian Dances for solo piano on EMI France 5661626 (recording dated '82-3). Have a lot of Bolet including a live Transcendental Etudes from '70 which is great, plus Richter (the performances on Praga are amazing!), and some interesting Arrau including a '71 live performance of the Sonata that's stunning. msk
I'd be AMAZED to find out that a recording made in Budapest, Studio Hungaroton in 1956 was anything other than mono.
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors: