![]() ![]() |
Audio Asylum Thread Printer Get a view of an entire thread on one page |
For Sale Ads |
In Reply to: Re: Aperiodic enclosure for RS 40-1284 posted by diyJohn on February 06, 2003 at 05:03:53:
John,
You will get more bass without the vent damping, but it will have poor definition (loud, but without impact, pitch and definition). A somewhat simplified explanation is as follows: The driver is incapable of controlling the helmholtz resonance formed by the cabinet-enclosed air (acts as a spring) and the vent (acts as an air mass). Without the vent damping you get a double peak in the bass: one in the upper bass and one in the mid-bass. The driver and vent contribute to each peak (because this is realy a coupled resonant system with the driver/amplifier providing all the energy). The driver is the dominant contributor for the upper peak while the vent is dominant for the lower peak. Without vent damping, the driver provides nearly all the damping of both the cabinet resonance and its own (formed by the cone mass and suspension/spider compliance). The driver is too underdamped (Qt is too high) to control the cabinet resonance. Therefore damping is added to the vent to damp that resonant system. It also damps the upper peak by turning some of the drivers acoustic energy into heat. The interaction of the driver and cabinet are more complex than is portrayed above, and we are fortunate to have computer programs that do a pretty good job of modeling this.If you build one of these you can try it with a full range of conditions, from open vent, through increasing amounts of damping, to packed with damping material so tightly that it is sealed. You will find this project very instructive! Enjoy.
AstroSonic
![]()
Follow Ups:
Thanks, AstroSonic for a great explanation!I have a 0.63 cu ft enclosure which needs only a baffle board and plan to do a little experimenting. Would that be big enough? Could you make a suggestion for vent size? Would you use any cabinet stuffing?
John,
If you use a 0.63 cf box try tuning to 54 Hz (1.5 x 1.5 inches cutout, by 3/4 inches deep). You will get a little peaking (+ 1.5 db @ 52 Hz and + 3 db @ 115 Hz) but it should sound pretty good with an F3 of about 47 hz. For a small room this could be quite a nice set of speakers. However, in most rooms if you play loud music with a lot of bass they will run out of linear excursion (Xmax). Assuming an Xmax of 2.5 mm, they will take around 6 watts, for a nearfield sound level of around 90 db down to about 50 Hz. Note that they could be played more loudly in a smaller box with a higher F3. If you try it please let me know how it turns out. Good luck and enjoy.
AstroSonic
![]()
Thanks, I'll try it!
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors: