A link to his own (MF's) review of the Shelter line, not to Arthur Salvatore's funny farm. - bjh

Follow Ups Full Thread

Topic - Do you really pay attention to this guy? - analogcorner 10:12:59 05/01/06 (159)

No, but then I don't really listen to you, either - Pat D 19:03:07 05/04/06 (0)

Not much but he's more credible than that Fremer guy - Don T 07:29:25 05/04/06 (1)

Re: Not much but he's more credible than that Fremer guy - jackd201 08:18:57 05/04/06 (0)

For what it's worth (don't answer that), my take on this nonsense... - jamesgarvin 07:11:27 05/03/06 (31)

"Mr. Salvatore's comments are cloaked as expressions of fact." Quelle horreur! What perfidy next, amongst reviewers? nt - clarkjohnsen 12:06:37 05/03/06 (0)

Re: For what it's worth (don't answer that), my take on this nonsense... - Mel 09:27:47 05/03/06 (6)

Re: For what it's worth (don't answer that), my take on this nonsense... - jamesgarvin 13:02:12 05/03/06 (5)

Re: For what it's worth (don't answer that), my take on this nonsense... - Mel 14:52:00 05/03/06 (4)

Re: For what it's worth (don't answer that), my take on this nonsense... - jamesgarvin 10:03:00 05/04/06 (3)

Re: For what it's worth (don't answer that), my take on this nonsense... - Mel 13:16:37 05/04/06 (2)

Re: For what it's worth (don't answer that), my take on this nonsense... - jamesgarvin 16:06:46 05/05/06 (1)

Re: For what it's worth (don't answer that), my take on this nonsense... - Mel 07:29:27 05/06/06 (0)

A well reasoned post.... - Ivan303 07:27:05 05/03/06 (22)

Get the facts straight. - garth 11:04:26 05/03/06 (18)

Re: Get the facts straight. - Dave Kingsland 12:35:20 05/03/06 (5)

And so it was. Proves my point. Thanks for the info. - garth 12:43:16 05/03/06 (4)

No Garth, the Geo Prism and the Corolla are the SAME CAR!!!! - Ivan303 15:05:33 05/03/06 (3)

I have had the 501 and CJ to compare - garth 01:00:59 05/04/06 (2)

In May 2001 you said "... it is quite obvious the Crown Jewel (CJ) is the Shelter 501". - bjh 09:07:19 05/04/06 (1)

It was the 501 not the 901. - garth 09:18:49 05/04/06 (0)

But Garth, What about this? - Mel 11:12:14 05/03/06 (11)

You guys slay me! nt - clarkjohnsen 12:08:26 05/03/06 (2)

Beat me beat me! No beat me! credit-Monty Python (-: (wot) - garth 12:17:43 05/03/06 (1)

Beat me up, Scotty! Credit: Doctor Spock (NT) - Thergit 09:03:13 08/19/06 (0)

But Mel, what about THIS... - Neil49 12:01:10 05/03/06 (1)

Cute, I didn't see that. So YEAH what about it Mel???? (-: (wot) - garth 12:04:21 05/03/06 (0)

You missed a golden opportunity ... - bjh 11:35:47 05/03/06 (0)

Exactly. But you missed the point so here it is again. - garth 11:28:50 05/03/06 (4)

Re: Exactly. And the Geo Prisim and the Toyota Corrola were the same car.... - Ivan303 15:08:46 05/03/06 (1)

Pretty much right - Dave Kingsland 17:17:22 05/03/06 (0)

So, regarding the difference between the taste of Chicken and Crow what would you say ... 2%, 4% or 5%? ROTFL! nt - bjh 11:40:37 05/03/06 (1)

I have no idea. I've never eaten CROW. And you? So tell us ... - garth 11:45:17 05/03/06 (0)

Re: A well reasoned post.... - jamesgarvin 08:38:01 05/03/06 (2)

Re: A well reasoned post.... - Bruce from DC 13:21:36 05/03/06 (1)

I own an ES-300 and there are quite a few differences from a Camry of the same year.... - Ivan303 15:19:25 05/03/06 (0)

Re: Do you really pay attention to this guy? - jlammotta 06:35:23 05/03/06 (0)

And once again my inocuous posts are erased....... - hexenboden 19:31:54 05/02/06 (3)

Re: And once again my inocuous posts are erased....... - Thergit 09:05:28 08/19/06 (0)

Re: And once again my inocuous posts are erased....... - bjh 19:57:37 05/02/06 (1)

2nd try: Why...so it is...oooooops!!!! (nt) - hexenboden 22:26:51 05/02/06 (0)

Re: Do you really pay attention to this guy? - Analog Scott 10:21:51 05/01/06 (2)

It's quite obvious... - ToshiroofKreplachastan 10:46:40 05/01/06 (1)

Re: It's quite obvious... - analogcorner 19:05:33 05/01/06 (0)

Now that you've thought about it, laugh about it and forget about it. - Bruce Kendall 10:33:25 05/01/06 (0)

Re: "an entire 3000 plus word column" - Ivan303 10:39:22 05/01/06 (1)

Re: "an entire 3000 plus word column" - analogcorner 19:08:20 05/01/06 (0)

Mikey Old Lad... - Mike Currie 10:58:45 05/01/06 (1)

Re: Mikey Old Lad... - analogcorner 19:09:37 05/01/06 (0)

Re: Do you really pay attention to this guy? - John Atkinson 11:02:49 05/01/06 (7)

Really? - Enophile 11:32:42 05/01/06 (4)

Re: Really? - John Atkinson 07:43:50 05/02/06 (3)

Give it another read, only holding a pint. - Enophile 08:32:14 05/02/06 (2)

Re: Give it another read, only holding a pint. - John Atkinson 09:51:29 05/02/06 (1)

Re: Give it another read, only holding a pint. - Jim Austin 12:21:41 05/02/06 (0)

I thought you were a Bass player? - Eldragon 13:01:56 05/01/06 (1)

Re: I thought you were a Bass player? - John Atkinson 14:07:44 05/01/06 (0)

OK, I tried imagining it... - Enophile 11:35:37 05/01/06 (1)

Re: OK, I tried imagining it... - analogcorner 19:11:37 05/01/06 (0)

You should be grateful. - cjfrbw 12:09:03 05/01/06 (2)

Grateful in the extreme to not be mainstream then. - Fred J 13:38:23 05/02/06 (1)

Re: Grateful in the extreme to not be mainstream then. - cjfrbw 18:43:53 05/02/06 (0)

Re: Do you really pay attention to this guy? - hexenboden 13:12:13 05/01/06 (5)

Re: Do you really pay attention to this guy? - TomLarson 14:10:40 05/01/06 (3)

Yeah, but why are measurements such a big deal? (nt) - hexenboden 16:23:05 05/01/06 (1)

Re: Yeah, but why are measurements such a big deal? (nt) - TomLarson 21:18:37 05/03/06 (0)

Re: Do you really pay attention to this guy? - analogcorner 19:13:53 05/01/06 (0)

Re: Do you really pay attention to this guy? - Fred J 13:24:49 05/02/06 (0)

Re: Do you really pay attention to this guy? - bjh 13:22:42 05/01/06 (4)

He did post the link (nt) - hexenboden 16:32:03 05/01/06 (1)

A link to his own (MF's) review of the Shelter line, not to Arthur Salvatore's funny farm. - bjh 17:46:50 05/01/06 (0)

Re: Do you really pay attention to this guy? - analogcorner 19:19:39 05/01/06 (1)

Entertaining? - Analog Scott 20:08:05 05/01/06 (0)

Salvatore, Aczel and even Hardesty... - mkuller 13:28:45 05/01/06 (18)

The tabloids have high circulation (nt) - hexenboden 13:30:57 05/01/06 (7)

But no credibility...(nt) - mkuller 14:21:09 05/01/06 (6)

My point is they are not really comparable (nt) - hexenboden 16:24:29 05/01/06 (5)

But they are. - Bruce Kendall 18:29:07 05/01/06 (4)

AND - hifitommy 19:12:39 05/01/06 (0)

No - hexenboden 21:18:44 05/01/06 (2)

Re: No - Mel 14:46:43 05/02/06 (1)

Well, he certainly has an audience after this (nt) - hexenboden 17:47:32 05/02/06 (0)

Re: Salvatore, Aczel and even Hardesty... - SalD 16:15:12 05/01/06 (6)

I have "inside sources" too -- does that break your heart? ;-) nt - clarkjohnsen 12:00:28 05/03/06 (3)

If they're indeed imaginary, then yes, I do. (nt) - SalD 15:14:50 05/03/06 (2)

Why do you assume they are imaginary? I know one - powermatic 12:15:11 05/04/06 (0)

"Do"... what?... - clarkjohnsen 08:26:37 05/04/06 (0)

Re: Salvatore, Aczel and even Hardesty... - analogcorner 19:21:31 05/01/06 (0)

Agreed. - SalD 11:00:54 05/02/06 (0)

Re: Salvatore, Aczel and even Hardesty... - Fred J 13:09:10 05/02/06 (2)

I didn't know that stuff. - srdavis2000 16:32:33 05/02/06 (1)

Re: I didn't know that stuff. - Fred J 17:54:56 05/02/06 (0)

Those statements by Salvatore are a year or two older than your review! - Atexanathome 16:33:27 05/01/06 (5)

Re: Those statements by Salvatore are a year or two older than your review! - analogcorner 19:03:57 05/01/06 (4)

Too late - hexenboden 21:06:07 05/01/06 (0)

So cry about it already... - 4yanx 09:40:59 05/02/06 (2)

Nicely put 4yanx! -nt - Raiderman 15:58:48 05/02/06 (0)

Re: So cry about it already... - analogcorner 17:37:13 05/02/06 (0)

I didn't answer your question the first time. Yes I do pay attention - Analog Scott 20:18:07 05/01/06 (3)

Re: I didn't answer your question the first time. Yes I do pay attention - analogcorner 17:38:23 05/02/06 (2)

Re: if he killed my dog - Analog Scott 19:42:17 05/02/06 (0)

I don't know you and don't read your writings, but - www.records 18:48:50 05/02/06 (0)

In Defense of Salvatore! - Mel 06:50:52 05/02/06 (21)

Re: In Defense of Salvatore! - John Atkinson 07:38:33 05/02/06 (17)

Re: In Defense of Salvatore! - Mel 08:06:47 05/02/06 (2)

Re: In Defense of Salvatore! - analogcorner 17:40:19 05/02/06 (1)

Re: In Defense of Salvatore! - Mel 09:05:01 05/03/06 (0)

Re: In Defense of Salvatore! - Arthur Salvatore 08:29:30 05/02/06 (3)

Re: In Defense of Salvatore! - Fred J 13:59:53 05/02/06 (1)

Re: In Defense of Salvatore! - analogcorner 17:42:28 05/02/06 (0)

Re: In Defense of Salvatore! - analogcorner 17:43:30 05/02/06 (0)

Re: In Defense of Salvatore! - John Atkinson 09:46:10 05/02/06 (9)

My comments were addressed to Mel, please note - John Atkinson 09:53:39 05/02/06 (0)

Re: In Defense of Salvatore! - Mel 10:57:44 05/02/06 (7)

Re: In Defense of Salvatore! - John Atkinson 13:22:27 05/02/06 (6)

The temptation to take the low road is always present. Stay high! nt - clarkjohnsen 11:57:18 05/03/06 (0)

"little innuendos" Wonder if he'll object to that? ... those nasty SOBs are just so picky! LOL - bjh 13:45:43 05/02/06 (0)

Re: In Defense of Salvatore! - Mel 14:30:42 05/02/06 (3)

"...closer to New York than to York..." Thas' funny, man! nt - clarkjohnsen 11:55:54 05/03/06 (0)

Re: In Defense of Salvatore! - John Atkinson 16:54:55 05/02/06 (1)

Re: "your inference that I put the interest of Stereophile's advertisers ahead of those of my readers. I do not." - Ivan303 17:18:44 05/02/06 (0)

Re: In Defense of Salvatore! - analogcorner 17:54:46 05/02/06 (2)

Re: In Defense of Salvatore! - Mel 20:10:25 05/02/06 (0)

saved - OMalley 18:36:13 05/02/06 (0)

He has both pluses and minuses... - morricab 08:05:22 05/02/06 (2)

Re: He has both pluses and minuses... - analogcorner 18:00:00 05/02/06 (1)

deja vu? - Don T 23:10:42 05/04/06 (0)

Re: Do you really pay attention to this guy? - Arthur Salvatore 08:22:28 05/02/06 (11)

You missed the real truth. - garth 04:43:40 05/03/06 (0)

DRONNNNNNNNNNNE.......... - hifitommy 20:48:21 05/02/06 (0)

Corrected Link - Arthur Salvatore 08:34:49 05/02/06 (0)

Re: Do you really pay attention to this guy: YES I DO - stark 16:50:43 05/02/06 (4)

Re: Do you really pay attention to this guy: YES I DO - analogcorner 18:05:36 05/02/06 (3)

saved for posterity - OMalley 18:32:14 05/02/06 (1)

Hey! That's *my* trick! nt - clarkjohnsen 11:47:57 05/03/06 (0)

I hope that... - 4yanx 18:46:28 05/02/06 (1)

Re: Do you really pay attention to this guy? - analogcorner 18:20:36 05/02/06 (2)

More Lies.... - Arthur Salvatore 08:18:56 05/03/06 (0)

Re: Do you really pay attention to this guy? - Dogface1956 21:56:42 05/02/06 (0)

man, you knew that stuff was out of date - OMalley 17:08:41 05/02/06 (9)

Re: man, you knew that stuff was out of date - analogcorner 17:48:21 05/02/06 (6)

grow up and get over it - OMalley 18:24:17 05/02/06 (1)

Re: grow up and get over it - analogcorner 19:13:42 05/02/06 (0)

No, you give US a break... - 4yanx 18:27:44 05/02/06 (3)

Re: No, you give US a break... - analogcorner 19:00:06 05/02/06 (2)

Re: No, you give US a break... - OMalley 19:05:20 05/02/06 (0)

You accuse me of... - 4yanx 19:05:56 05/02/06 (0)

Re: man, you knew that stuff was out of date - analogcorner 18:55:59 05/02/06 (1)

how you keep a job is beyond me - OMalley 19:02:58 05/02/06 (0)

Re: Do you really pay attention to this guy? - blake 17:36:21 05/02/06 (6)

Re: Do you really pay attention to this guy? - analogcorner 18:53:12 05/02/06 (5)

That was certainly a mature outburst. Don't ya think? Geesh. nt - www.records 18:59:32 05/02/06 (0)

There is no excuse... - 4yanx 19:00:20 05/02/06 (1)

Re: There is no excuse... - analogcorner 19:08:13 05/02/06 (0)

Nurse Pepper, Nurse Pepper! - OMalley 19:06:40 05/02/06 (0)

Re: Do you really pay attention to this guy? - blake 19:13:56 05/02/06 (0)

Simon Yorke no longer Recommended ... - hexenboden 17:43:18 05/02/06 (3)

Re: Simon Yorke no longer Recommended ... - analogcorner 18:46:29 05/02/06 (2)

JA: reinstate the Yorke please... 2 votes (nt) - hexenboden 22:28:05 05/02/06 (1)

Re: JA: reinstate the Yorke please... 2 votes (nt) - John Atkinson 08:33:46 05/05/06 (0)

Follow Ups

A link to his own (MF's) review of the Shelter line, not to Arthur Salvatore's funny farm. - bjh 17:46:50 05/01/06 (0)