In Reply to: Others' opinions posted by Norm on June 28, 2011 at 17:34:27:
The reason my have been valid for the equipment that Daniel Weiss compared, but that was probably several generations ago. There were certainly some serious problems with USB 1.0.
If the interconnect (Firewire or USB) makes a difference in the sound of a DAC this indicates an interaction between the interconnect and the DAC, specifically input circuitry that is not providing adequate rejection. As I recall, Daniel Weiss has supported the idea that well designed DACs aren't sensitive to these factors. This seems contradictory to the statement he made that you referenced, assuming that he believes his DACs are well designed. Of course, sometimes manufacturers make statements that are deliberately misleading for commercial reasons. I have no idea if this is the case here.
I have no problem with people reporting what they hear. However, when they go on to generalize to an entire technology I don't pay much attention to these generalizations unless they come with some indication of a deep understanding of the technology or a wide range of experience with many implementations. These kind of generalizations are how "audiophile myths" get propagated. I would go no farther than to say that some Firewire implementations are better than some USB implementations.
BTW, I have not been a fan of USB. Indeed when I first learned of the proposal that Intel was pushing I thought it was a bad idea. Since those ancient days USB has improved and my initial concerns have been addressed. Like most computer technology both USB and Firewire have been over hyped.
Tony Lauck
"Diversity is the law of nature; no two entities in this universe are uniform." - P.R. Sarkar
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Follow Ups
- RE: Others' opinions - Tony Lauck 18:57:44 06/28/11 (10)
- RE: Others' opinions - Old Listener 13:41:06 07/02/11 (0)
- RE: "both USB and Firewire have been over hyped." - rick_m 10:17:55 07/02/11 (3)
- RE: "both USB and Firewire have been over hyped." - Old Listener 13:57:06 07/02/11 (0)
- RE: "both USB and Firewire have been over hyped." - Ryelands 13:32:09 07/02/11 (1)
- RE: "Men and Boys" - rick_m 15:34:00 07/02/11 (0)
- RE: Others' opinions - fmak 03:50:30 07/02/11 (2)
- The emperor's new clothes - Ryelands 04:21:17 07/02/11 (1)
- True audiophiles look for high quality replay systems regardless of setup - fmak 08:02:47 07/02/11 (0)
- The Weiss DAC202 offers all other links other than USB. - Norm 07:46:35 06/29/11 (1)
- RE: The Weiss DAC202 offers all other links other than USB. - Mercman 08:04:04 06/29/11 (0)