In Reply to: Archimago: Can you do more spectral analysis of Mofi SACDs? posted by jeromelang on August 16, 2022 at 18:37:16:
I remember when the Norah Jones SACD first came out many audiophiles claimed that it was so much better than the CD. Those same audiophiles back peddled when they learned it was a DSD conversion from 16/44.1 PCM [CD]. All of a sudden these same audiophiles could magically hear no difference between the CD and SACD ;-)I always thought SACD and DSD were artificially smooth taking all edge off the music even if the artist intended for it to be there. Like a shard of glass smoothed over by ocean currents, it's still glass but no longer the same. Just my take.
Edits: 08/16/22 08/17/22
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Follow Ups
- Norah Jones SACD Scandal --- Slightly off-topic - AbeCollins 18:55:32 08/16/22 (8)
- My SACD Experience - 2-ears 13:27:09 08/17/22 (2)
- RE: My SACD Experience - Todd Krieger 09:07:55 09/22/22 (0)
- RE: My SACD Experience - AbeCollins 22:16:05 08/19/22 (0)
- They did eventually redo that SACD. (nt) - Jack G 04:17:22 08/17/22 (3)
- Who is "They"? - John Marks 19:58:48 08/17/22 (2)
- You answered your own question :-) - Jack G 09:33:08 08/18/22 (1)
- IIRC, Chad did it nt - John Marks 06:28:30 08/19/22 (0)
- The same thing happened on SA-CD.net some years ago. . . - Chris from Lafayette 01:00:24 08/17/22 (0)