|
Audio Asylum Thread Printer Get a view of an entire thread on one page |
For Sale Ads |
88.105.165.202
In Reply to: Which should I invest in-Shure V15III or IV? posted by lpspinner on September 15, 2006 at 22:32:12:
As far as Shure V15 cartridges are concerned, the V15 111HE is the best sounding among the other versions, with an open and neutral frequency balance, exemplary tracking ability, and good focus in stereo imaging. Its criticism is a thickening in the mid range.
The V15 VMR has a clear and detailed mid range. Its bass is powerful though a little plummy but its treble is muddled and the stereo imaging lacks depth.
The sound of the V15 1V is also neutral and open but the imaging is flat because the lack of depth is again evident. The surface noise of the 1V is more pronounced than the others.
The V15 111 is disappointing with some emphasis in the mid range and a fair imaging. Some hardness is noted as well.
The Shure M97 HE is in my opinion the better sounding and balanced cartridge than the V15 series and it is cheaper too. So I think you should siick with it.
Follow Ups:
of Shure cartriges is more realistic then most current cart. designs that give an unnatural exaggerated image (I have tried several in my system). I f you just honestly listen to a Shure you will find everything is there in a very realistic setting. I prefere the natural sound they give even from my V15 IV.which sounds great in my system. I have gone back to it after trying several much more expensive and highly rated cartridges. I guess it is all about personal preferences.
Having listened quite extensively to about every Shure on the planet I always go back to my best friend of the lot...the V15 III with a fresh GENUINE SHURE VN 35E wins out sonically over and over in my system. With it perfectly aligned and perfectly loaded....I hear absolutely NOTHING in the way of any hardness....Just Plain Musicality....a constant winner.
The findings were based upon the comparison with the other cartridges that I used such as the AT33 PTG, OC9 and the Denon 304 etc.which were much better in many respects than the Shure V15 cartridges. My system is of course not the best but transparent enough to reveal any minor deficiency of every component in the chain.The shortcomings of the V15s could be easily unveiled when compare to better cartridges like those that I compared above. I think the Technics 205 mk3, ADC XLM mk3 imp and the Goldring 1024 are all superior, not to mention the offerings from Grado. Even the Shure ML140HE is a better-balanced cartridge than the V15s.
I have nearly forgotten the V15XMR, which is considered by many as the best sounding mm cartridge that Shure has ever made and unfortunately I have not heard it so I make no comment. But I still stand for the remarks that I made for the other V15 variations.
Best regards
are better than any in your list. Just my opinion of course. Tecknics, Goldring better? Give me a break.
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors: