|
Audio Asylum Thread Printer Get a view of an entire thread on one page |
For Sale Ads |
71.210.119.242
In Reply to: I don't think TAS started... posted by mkuller on February 24, 2007 at 21:34:26:
So what? Those of us reading Stereophile in the early days learned plenty--plenty--that we never heard in the existing mags of the day AND that we never really saw discussions of in the AS when he did start it. No comparison.
Follow Ups:
At the time, I was also an avid reader of Stereo Review, High Fidelity and, occasionally, "Audio."By and large, the equipment reviewers for those magainzes focused exclusively on "the numbers." If "the numbers" were good, these guys said, "Wow! Terrific numbers! Sounds good, too." There was a tremendous reticence, a distrust really, by those reviewers to use their own ears. They used their ears, if at all, to validate the measurements. I think that's backwards.
JGH and the boys, of course, started out without any numbers at all; they just listened.
If you want a great illustration of what I'm talking about, compare JGH's review of the Bose 901 with Julian Hirsch's. (I've read both.) Here's a really unorthodox approach to speaker design but, frankly, Hirsch tells you very, very little about how it sounds say, in comparison to an AR-3A, a "conventional" speaker of good reputation at about the same price. And even he admits that his "numbers" don't mean much. JGH does a good job of describing the speaker's sound. (Yeah, I also heard the 901 in 1968 or 1969; although it was "ahead of its time" in that its aggressive equalization in the bass range required more drive than the amplifiers of the time could deliver.)
I do like the fact that Stereophile measures things. But I think they have their priority straight; listen first, then measure.
I'm really uninterested in whether HP first "discovered" Audio Research Corp., Magnepan, etc. BFD. For one thing, if TAS didn't start until 1973, I beat them to the punch on those brands. First time I knew about Magneplanars (driven by ARC electronics) was when I heard them in 1972, in Baltimore where I was a TA at Johns Hopkins. And yes, they were a "revelation."
nt
Usually one of the ways for grad students to earn money.
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors: