Tweakers' Asylum: REVIEW: KYC111 Ladder Attenuator Passive Components by rhyno
Tweaks for systems, rooms and Do It Yourself (DIY) help. FAQ.
|For Sale Ads|
Model: Ladder Attenuator Category: Passive Components Suggested Retail Price: $55 for mono pair Description: 100k Ladder Attenuators, Dale Resistors, 24 step. Manufacturer URL: Not Available Manufacturer URL: Not Available
Review by rhyno ( D ) on December 07, 2004 at 15:11:05
IP Address: 184.108.40.206
Add Your Review
for the Ladder Attenuator
if you look on ebay for seller "KYC111" from taiwan, you'll find that he sells ridiculously cheap ladder attenuators. $50 for a mono pair is a bargain by all accounts.
the units seem well built; soldering work is nicely done, and the switch is make before break, so no annoying pops. not the stoutest switch, but it will do. also, do note that the shaft on the attenuators to connect you control knob to is quite short, so take care. in that vein, the overall dimensions are quite small, so no troubles fitting it in tight spaces. measurements show 1% matching between the mono units, but at full attenuation one of them has marginal output from my speakers--go figure.
onto the sound: no question this unit is a marked improvement against the volume pots i replaced (nobles). imaging, bass(!), dynamics, detail and noise-floor are all markedly improved.
tonality is another matter: i find that all components have a character. so does this part: its on the warmish side (i recall reading that such is the character of the dale resistors used, so it makes sense). while this is likely a god-send for SS-electronics, it may be too much warmth in a tube unit (which is where i placed it). while its still an upgrade over where i started, its not the end result i wanted. its not euphonic or mushy or anything like that...its just more a sense that music has lost its natural aggression (which SS gear overaccentuates IMO). so, component matching is important if you want the proper balance.
put it this way: i'd not hesitate for one minute to upgrade a SS preamp with these things, but there is no way i'd use this part as a passive attenuator in my SET amp. it'd be too much glow.
for the cost, its a screaming bargain. in the right component (read: solid state, bright, aggressive preamps or amps), its a wonderful upgrade. but misapplication of this part to a soft-ish tube component will likely send you too far into the warm camp.
Product Weakness: as above Product Strengths: as above
Associated Equipment for this Review: Amplifier: Wavac 572 SET Preamplifier (or None if Integrated): Terra Song Satori Mk4 (where part applied); G&D Custom (alternate) Sources (CDP/Turntable): G&D UTP1 Transport> Entec 3.0 DAC Speakers: Wilson WP6s Cables/Interconnects: TG Audio High Purity ICs & HSR Speaker Cables Music Used (Genre/Selections): all Room Size (LxWxH): 11 x 15 x 8 Room Comments/Treatments: Risch Bass Panels Time Period/Length of Audition: 1 week Other (Power Conditioner etc.): TG Audio Bybee-based power conditioner Type of Audition/Review: Product Owner
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Topic - REVIEW: KYC111 Ladder Attenuator Passive Components - rhyno 15:11:05 12/7/04 ( 2)
- I'll second - same positive experiance and... - mrfixit 12:04:47 12/13/04 ( 0)
KYC111 Ladder Attenuator Passive Components - badman 17:53:20 12/7/04 ( 0)