In Reply to: Stravinsky and Copland as a conductors posted by rbolaw on March 9, 2017 at 13:22:59:
"one of his earliest conducting efforts was his Octet (1923 in Paris), and he then made a recording of it, which I have, in 1932. A rather disorganized mess, I would say. But he recorded the Octet (with l'Histoire du soldat) again in 1955, and again in stereo in 1961, and both of those are superb."
But I wonder whether the improvements in '55 and '61 were due to having better players (freelancers and NY Phil members in '55, LA freelancers in '61) or more rehearsal time. Perhaps the octet works fine without a conductor--there are several current recordings that have none, e.g., Orpheus Chamber Orchestra.
I first heard the rite of spring in Stravinsky's 1940 recording with NY Phil. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pJQ-wAaU7cY
This is still a pretty good performance, from a time when major orchestras could not easily play it in their sleep. I think he knew what he was doing at the podium.
There is also the question of how much credit Stravinsky deserves for his later recordings when Robert Craft did the rehearsals (and conducted some performances that were misattributed for years to the composer).
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Topic - Turns out Itunes has Stravinsky conducting Symphony Of Psalms and it appears he might know what he's doing ;-} - kitch29 10:05:41 03/09/17 (3)Follow Ups
- RE: Stravinsky and Copland as a conductors - pbarach 14:44:54 03/09/17 (1)
- Good points - rbolaw 10:40:16 03/11/17 (0)