In Reply to: Jeff, would you respond to this? posted by Russ57 on March 5, 2007 at 15:37:55:
Hi Russ,Sure I'll respond.
(1) Jeff Medwin IS NOT anymore just LOW DCR only !! Yes I started with low DCR, but midway last year I reported on Low C and Low HY too, with my friend's wrtings, posted under my moniker. Now, ( several weeks ago ) I was able to TRY all three together on Greg's 245 SEer, and I NOW have HEARD that my friend Dennis is correct, all three are sorely needed if ya wanna get an amp to truly boggie big time !!
(2) Look at the construction of a Damper diode versus a 5U4. The damper diode has a nice SLOW ramp up, due to its cathode, and it also has lowZ. But wait, the lowly 5U4 has NO cathode, its a filamentary rectifier, meaning it can do INSTANTANEOUS music events better than any cathode diode. Gee, don't some of us swear by filamentary triodes sounding better.... how about filamentary diodes over cathode diodes Russ??? No one ever mentions this up here.
When you get into Low DCR, Low HY, Low C power supplies, which have less storage time than everyone's conventional archaic supplies, the instantaneous respose of filamentary diodes become more of a factor, and is more easily appreciated. Conventional supplies, by comparison, do NOT serve the music, because they get it severly "out of time" and certainly "off-kilter", due to their slugishness, etc. from too high a DCR, HY and C in the design.
So Russ, buy two Triad C-40Xs from Allied Electronics, under 11 dollars each, and two 40 uF ASC oils from Mike Percy, under 13 dollars each, and LISTEN to that on your output stage. Assume VDC = 1.35 times VAC of your PT trannie, minus tube rectifier drop.
Want a lower impedance filamentary diode, how about a 5V3? For long term health and safety, avoid mercury vapor filamentaries of any type in your home.
Hope my response makes sense to you, Russ. Buy those parts I described, and keep final voltages similar !!
Jeff Medwin
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Follow Ups
- Re: Jeff, would you respond to this? - drlowmu 19:43:09 03/05/07 (12)
- By this logic - mikeyb 05:41:50 03/06/07 (1)
- Re: By this logic - drlowmu 08:29:17 03/06/07 (0)
- Thanks, nice to know someone else likes the 5u4 too(nt) - Russ57 05:38:12 03/06/07 (0)
- Completely false - Mark Kelly 20:10:52 03/05/07 (0)
- mecrury tubes - Janos 20:05:45 03/05/07 (7)
- Re: mecrury tubes - drlowmu 22:47:45 03/05/07 (6)
- hmm... - Dave Cigna 12:46:03 03/09/07 (0)
- Re: mecrury tubes - Janos 18:23:11 03/06/07 (0)
- Citing oneself as a reference is poor form... - Steve O 16:39:41 03/06/07 (3)
- Well, well, well.............. - drlowmu 22:22:16 03/06/07 (2)
- Re: Well, well, well..............Holy Unholy Juxtaposition Batman!!! - Steve O 11:16:49 03/07/07 (0)
- So you're comparing yourself you Einstein now? - arend-jan 05:06:22 03/07/07 (0)