In Reply to: RE: The trouble with AES and ASA posted by geoffkait on August 7, 2013 at 12:01:26:
"I did not respond to the article, actually. What could I possibly say?"You could have refuted untrue statements, and clarified the rationale of your science. It was a perfect opportunity to speak to the professional community and earn credibility.
Geoff, really, if you don't have a leg to stand on, scientifically, just say so. But don't go around bad-mouthing other people who clearly know what they're doing - it makes you look silly and petty.
Edits: 08/07/13
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Follow Ups
- RE: The trouble with AES and ASA - Inmate51 12:11:36 08/07/13 (17)
- RE: The trouble with AES and ASA - geoffkait 12:22:29 08/07/13 (16)
- RE: The trouble with AES and ASA - Inmate51 10:10:39 08/13/13 (15)
- RE: The trouble with AES and ASA - geoffkait 12:57:56 08/13/13 (14)
- I have full acess to JASA, and I'd like to read that paper/letter, so... - KlausR. 12:11:03 09/09/13 (12)
- RE: I have full acess to JASA, and I'd like to read that paper/letter, so... - geoffkait 14:58:59 09/09/13 (11)
- RE: I have full acess to JASA, and I'd like to read that paper/letter, so... - KlausR. 10:42:21 09/10/13 (10)
- "Value" vs. "Physical effect" - Tony Lauck 16:55:12 09/16/13 (0)
- RE: I have full acess to JASA, and I'd like to read that paper/letter, so... - geoffkait 12:21:13 09/10/13 (8)
- RE: I have full acess to JASA, and I'd like to read that paper/letter, so... - KlausR. 00:35:41 09/13/13 (7)
- RE: I have full acess to JASA, and I'd like to read that paper/letter, so... - geoffkait 04:22:28 09/13/13 (6)
- RE: I have full acess to JASA, and I'd like to read that paper/letter, so... - Inmate51 07:11:27 09/13/13 (5)
- Hey! - geoffkait 09:42:44 09/13/13 (4)
- RE: Hey! - Inmate51 15:27:18 09/13/13 (3)
- Wow! - geoffkait 16:56:23 09/13/13 (2)
- A "nice cold shower" would make him all wet. - Dave Pogue 06:25:31 09/18/13 (1)
- RE: A "nice cold shower" would make him all wet. - geoffkait 10:59:09 09/18/13 (0)
- RE: The trouble with AES and ASA - Inmate51 09:04:25 08/14/13 (0)