In Reply to: The trouble with AES and ASA posted by geoffkait on August 4, 2013 at 10:46:40:
I would hope that you, as a manufacturer, are a member of one or both organizations, and have voiced your concern to them, and that you learn from papers presented by researchers in applicable fields.In any case, isn't the "debate" among audiophiles regarding the audibility of polarity/phase reversal really about quantifying - measuring - its audibility, via a statistical analysis of results under controlled conditions, rather than through anecdotal stories or off-the-cuff "tests"?
I'm not sure why a manufacturer would pooh-pooh measurable science in favor of - what?
If you know of a professional organization which has better science presented in its publications, please tell me.
Edits: 08/04/13
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Follow Ups
- RE: The trouble with AES and ASA - Inmate51 11:52:40 08/04/13 (43)
- RE: The trouble with AES and ASA - geoffkait 15:50:36 08/04/13 (42)
- RE: The trouble with AES and ASA - Inmate51 18:34:52 08/04/13 (41)
- RE: The trouble with AES and ASA - geoffkait 18:58:34 08/04/13 (40)
- RE: The trouble with AES and ASA - tomservo 09:47:19 08/05/13 (39)
- RE: The trouble with AES and ASA - geoffkait 10:52:47 08/05/13 (38)
- RE: The trouble with AES and ASA - Inmate51 14:24:01 08/05/13 (37)
- RE: The trouble with AES and ASA - geoffkait 15:22:45 08/05/13 (36)
- RE: The trouble with AES and ASA - Inmate51 15:32:17 08/06/13 (35)
- RE: The trouble with AES and ASA - geoffkait 16:40:52 08/06/13 (34)
- RE: The trouble with AES and ASA - tomservo 07:46:31 08/07/13 (33)
- "things based on scientific reality generally withstand the examination when exposed to the light" ... - Cleantimestream 19:35:55 09/17/13 (0)
- RE: The trouble with AES and ASA - geoffkait 08:15:02 08/07/13 (31)
- quantum mechanic" differential equations sums that up. Competent math anyone?~nT - Cleantimestream 19:38:18 09/17/13 (2)
- RE: quantum mechanic" differential equations sums that up. Competent math anyone?~nT - Inmate51 21:15:26 09/17/13 (1)
- RE: quantum mechanic" differential equations sums that up. Competent math anyone?~nT - geoffkait 02:16:23 09/18/13 (0)
- RE: The trouble with AES and ASA - tomservo 09:03:11 08/07/13 (25)
- RE: The trouble with AES and ASA - Inmate51 11:19:56 08/07/13 (3)
- Dan Dugan has been implacable in promoting his belief that... - Poles Apart 08:35:44 08/21/13 (0)
- RE: The trouble with AES and ASA - tomservo 13:28:03 08/07/13 (1)
- RE: The trouble with AES and ASA - Inmate51 17:48:12 08/07/13 (0)
- RE: The trouble with AES and ASA - geoffkait 09:34:30 08/07/13 (20)
- RE: The trouble with AES and ASA - Inmate51 10:41:27 08/07/13 (19)
- RE: The trouble with AES and ASA - geoffkait 12:01:26 08/07/13 (18)
- RE: The trouble with AES and ASA - Inmate51 12:11:36 08/07/13 (17)
- RE: The trouble with AES and ASA - geoffkait 12:22:29 08/07/13 (16)
- RE: The trouble with AES and ASA - Inmate51 10:10:39 08/13/13 (15)
- RE: The trouble with AES and ASA - geoffkait 12:57:56 08/13/13 (14)
- I have full acess to JASA, and I'd like to read that paper/letter, so... - KlausR. 12:11:03 09/09/13 (12)
- RE: I have full acess to JASA, and I'd like to read that paper/letter, so... - geoffkait 14:58:59 09/09/13 (11)
- RE: I have full acess to JASA, and I'd like to read that paper/letter, so... - KlausR. 10:42:21 09/10/13 (10)
- "Value" vs. "Physical effect" - Tony Lauck 16:55:12 09/16/13 (0)
- RE: I have full acess to JASA, and I'd like to read that paper/letter, so... - geoffkait 12:21:13 09/10/13 (8)
- RE: I have full acess to JASA, and I'd like to read that paper/letter, so... - KlausR. 00:35:41 09/13/13 (7)
- RE: I have full acess to JASA, and I'd like to read that paper/letter, so... - geoffkait 04:22:28 09/13/13 (6)
- RE: I have full acess to JASA, and I'd like to read that paper/letter, so... - Inmate51 07:11:27 09/13/13 (5)
- Hey! - geoffkait 09:42:44 09/13/13 (4)
- RE: Hey! - Inmate51 15:27:18 09/13/13 (3)
- Wow! - geoffkait 16:56:23 09/13/13 (2)
- A "nice cold shower" would make him all wet. - Dave Pogue 06:25:31 09/18/13 (1)
- RE: A "nice cold shower" would make him all wet. - geoffkait 10:59:09 09/18/13 (0)
- RE: The trouble with AES and ASA - Inmate51 09:04:25 08/14/13 (0)
- RE: The trouble with AES and ASA - rick_m 08:33:49 08/07/13 (1)
- RE: The trouble with AES and ASA - geoffkait 09:25:56 08/07/13 (0)