In Reply to: Re: Interesting article. Most of it is over my head but ... posted by Dan Banquer on March 9, 2007 at 04:27:45:
I don't suppose "dysfunctional illiterate subjectivists" need to be discredited. After all, they're disfunctional and illiterate.But, IMO, the only people this article discredits are the mystics, those who believe that things happen in audio that neither have nor require a physical explanation. That's a pretty small group I think.
As for the rest, it suggests that 1. yes, measurements probably CAN ultimately explain everything we really hear, and 2. Just because you can't measure it doesn't mean they don't hear it.
The cautious empiricists win this round. The losers are the mystics and the greedy reductionists.
BTW: Dick, thanks for posting. A nice article.
Cheers,
Jim
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Follow Ups
- This interpretation is much too simple - Jim Austin 06:29:42 03/09/07 (22)
- Re: This interpretation is much too simple - Dan Banquer 09:14:30 03/09/07 (13)
- ...and your point is? - Jim Austin 09:25:43 03/09/07 (12)
- Re: ...and your point is? - Dan Banquer 09:57:59 03/09/07 (11)
- Okay, I get it - Jim Austin 10:13:24 03/09/07 (10)
- Re: Okay, I get it - john curl 02:39:27 03/10/07 (7)
- I used Horowitz and Hill... - Jim Austin 03:41:36 03/10/07 (6)
- Re: I used Horowitz and Hill... - john curl 10:49:42 03/10/07 (5)
- This book looks interestin - Jim Austin 09:16:08 03/11/07 (1)
- Re: This book looks interestin - john curl 12:00:48 03/11/07 (0)
- Re: I used Horowitz and Hill... - Jim Austin 14:13:22 03/10/07 (2)
- Re: I used Horowitz and Hill... - john curl 17:10:23 03/10/07 (1)
- Re: I used Horowitz and Hill... - Jim Austin 18:16:43 03/10/07 (0)
- Re: Okay, I get it - Dan Banquer 10:23:18 03/09/07 (1)
- Maybe I shouldn't say this... - Jim Austin 10:33:23 03/09/07 (0)
- Re: This interpretation is much too simple - theaudiohobby 06:59:44 03/09/07 (7)
- Re: This interpretation is much too simple - morricab 09:48:38 03/09/07 (0)
- I don't totally disagree... - Jim Austin 07:06:59 03/09/07 (5)
- The problem with numbers... - morricab 09:57:32 03/09/07 (1)
- I would only add - Jim Austin 10:09:32 03/09/07 (0)
- Re: Well.. - theaudiohobby 07:53:14 03/09/07 (2)
- Re: Well.. - Jim Austin 08:05:29 03/09/07 (1)
- Re: Well.. - theaudiohobby 08:12:30 03/09/07 (0)