In Reply to: Am I more likely to find flat nearfield response in.... posted by ayokay on September 15, 2005 at 08:25:39:
Probably hard to say... My vote would be in the pro gear, especially if they are active, because the pro speaker manufacturer has chosen the right amp to achieve the flat response. They also have designed the speaker to be flat near-field (read without room reflections). The hi-fi manufacturer may have in mind room boundaries, and also may be more inclined to offer a more euphonic sound that the competitors. Anyhow, I have owned a lot of speakers (dynamic, electrostatics, and magnepan, from Bose 301 to Polk RT12, Definitive Tech BP8, BW 601s, lots of 2-way DIY and more recently B&W CDM-9NT, Aerius i, MMGs, MG12s...), and I recently picked up the Dynaudio pro BM5A monitors.
I believe the biggest thing that I have gained with the Dyns over similar speakers is optimal amplification (I have owned relatively cheap amps with the other passive speakers), which translates into deeper and more controlled bass, incredible dynamics and transients, superior detail and texture. Also, pro studio monitors usually offer a built-in EQ to adapt the speakers to the environment.
So depending on your budget (your goal obviously getting flat sound), the studio monitors may fit your bill...
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Follow Ups
- Re: Am I more likely to find flat nearfield response in.... - Chris 16:39:06 09/15/05 (10)
- Please excuse again - are you driving them with a balanced preamp - beppe61 08:12:58 09/19/05 (3)
- Re: Please excuse again - are you driving them with a balanced preamp - Chris 16:42:19 09/19/05 (0)
- Re: Please excuse again - are you driving them with a balanced preamp - Chris 14:41:16 09/19/05 (1)
- Re: Please excuse again - are you driving them with a balanced preamp - beppe61 10:50:07 09/20/05 (0)
- Dear Mr. Chris - what about image depth with the Dyna? - beppe61 08:01:39 09/19/05 (2)
- Re: Dear Mr. Chris - what about image depth with the Dyna? - Chris 14:24:32 09/19/05 (1)
- Re: Dear Mr. Chris - thank you so much for your kind and very valuable addition. - beppe61 10:45:38 09/20/05 (0)
- Re: Am I more likely to find flat nearfield response in.... - ayokay 21:22:53 09/15/05 (2)
- One thing I don't quite understand . - beppe61 08:17:57 09/19/05 (1)
- ok, here it is..................... - Norman Bates 00:12:02 11/04/05 (0)