In Reply to: C'mon "theoretical physicist" posted by unclestu on May 18, 2011 at 12:13:28:
Any yutz in town can can up with some whacky theory. The trick is that it should make some sense. Unfortunately, your theory doesn't make any sense. The reasons it doesn't make sense are that ions are not electrons, ions and electrons are not interchangeable, any more than protons and electrons, and ions generated by the machine do not "make a pool of electrons available" for a circuit or anything else. All the negative ion generator does is make more negative ions available. Follow, now?
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Follow Ups
- RE: "I believe the ions are contributing to the "pool" of electrons available for an electrical circuit." - geoffkait 13:25:06 05/18/11 (31)
- F- for reading comprehension again - unclestu 14:37:28 05/18/11 (30)
- Methinks you're overly enamored with your own whacky theory. - geoffkait 14:54:03 05/18/11 (29)
- Well: Mr Wacky theory.......smirk, smirk...... - unclestu 15:56:52 05/18/11 (28)
- Looks like I struck a nerve. LOL nt - geoffkait 17:08:09 05/18/11 (27)
- Oh, yeah,..... - unclestu 17:14:45 05/18/11 (26)
- You may want to cut back just a skosh on your meds - geoffkait 17:44:50 05/18/11 (25)
- I may want to add some scotch to my meds? Alright! - QuadTodd 19:11:42 05/19/11 (0)
- really LOL! - unclestu 15:51:53 05/19/11 (1)
- RE: really LOL! - geoffkait 16:22:11 05/19/11 (0)
- Good to see you read - unclestu 15:34:45 05/19/11 (21)
- Haldane or Haldol? - geoffkait 16:37:43 05/19/11 (20)
- Hilarious..... - unclestu 12:54:14 05/20/11 (9)
- RE: "Then you make the stupendous leap and say I attribute everything to it" - geoffkait 14:38:51 05/20/11 (8)
- Don't worry - unclestu 15:09:15 05/20/11 (7)
- RE: Don't worry - edbk 01:25:48 05/21/11 (1)
- Quite so - geoffkait 14:15:51 05/21/11 (0)
- Uh, oh, not enough Haldol - geoffkait 15:32:55 05/20/11 (4)
- obviously not in the cave you live in - unclestu 16:24:28 05/20/11 (3)
- RE: "I attribute the effects on CD and LP to degaussing." - geoffkait 16:36:53 05/20/11 (2)
- My, my - unclestu 21:15:18 05/22/11 (1)
- That would be illogical, Captain - geoffkait 02:18:06 05/23/11 (0)
- Ahh woundn't the negative ions, allow more freely available electrons to be 'around' ?? - Elizabeth 23:20:39 05/19/11 (9)
- RE: Ahh woundn't the negative ions, allow more freely available electrons to be 'around' ?? - unclestu 13:08:33 05/23/11 (7)
- Houston, we have a problem. - geoffkait 15:33:26 05/23/11 (6)
- RE: Houston, we have a problem. Geoff evades actual issue in post, red herrings his way to nowhereland - Elizabeth 06:39:44 05/25/11 (5)
- By the - unclestu 11:58:05 05/25/11 (3)
- RE: By the way - unclestu 16:55:05 05/25/11 (1)
- But - geoffkait 16:59:47 05/25/11 (0)
- The mind is a terrible thing to lose. You've apparently lost yours. LOL - geoffkait 12:12:21 05/25/11 (0)
- RE: Houston, we have a problem. Geoff evades actual issue in post, red herrings his way to nowhereland - geoffkait 08:27:39 05/25/11 (0)
- RE: Ahh woundn't the negative ions, allow more freely available electrons to be 'around' ?? - geoffkait 03:28:53 05/20/11 (0)