In Reply to: RE: "the less a transducer travels generating waveforms the 'faster' it is" posted by Bill Fitzmaurice on November 24, 2020 at 19:17:32:
The usual explanation for why some speakers sound "faster" than others is a good one, that a speaker with a lower Q will sound faster because the bass rolls off more than a higher Q woofer. Thus, the lower Q woofer is reproducing more treble, which of course is of higher frequency and will naturally sound "faster" than the high Q woofer which is reproducing more bass.
Now try something like this. I ran a 100 hz sine wave from a frequency generator through a high Q (0.9 if I remember correctly), aluminum cone subwoofer cone and the same 100 hz signal through a Lowther DX4. The 100 hz frequency is below the breakup modes of both the Lowther and that aluminum cone woofer, and certainly should be well within the frequency range that is reproducible by the subwoofer cone. But the 100 hz sinewave signal through the Lowther sounded a lot clearer than it did through the aluminum cone subwoofer. This experiment is not hard to do. If you don't have a Lowther, than any low Q midrange driver would work.
This difference is real, but what engineering principal would you call this? I don't know what to call it, but I think that this is what people label fast versus slow.
Retsel
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Follow Ups
- RE: "the less a transducer travels generating waveforms the 'faster' it is" - Retsel 07:05:10 11/27/20 (14)
- RE: "the less a transducer travels generating waveforms the 'faster' it is" - Bill Fitzmaurice 07:58:12 11/27/20 (13)
- RE: "the less a transducer travels generating waveforms the 'faster' it is" - Retsel 13:23:34 11/27/20 (12)
- RE: "the less a transducer travels generating waveforms the 'faster' it is" - Bill Fitzmaurice 15:19:55 11/27/20 (11)
- RE: "the less a transducer travels generating waveforms the 'faster' it is" - Retsel 18:29:29 11/28/20 (10)
- RE: "the less a transducer travels generating waveforms the 'faster' it is" - rivervalley817 18:59:12 11/28/20 (9)
- RE: "the less a transducer travels generating waveforms the 'faster' it is" - Bill Fitzmaurice 13:44:37 11/29/20 (8)
- RE: "the less a transducer travels generating waveforms the 'faster' it is" - rivervalley817 13:57:29 11/29/20 (7)
- RE: "the less a transducer travels generating waveforms the 'faster' it is" - Don Reid 08:57:14 12/05/20 (6)
- RE: "the less a transducer travels generating waveforms the 'faster' it is" - Retsel 07:23:27 12/11/20 (1)
- Re: Front horns are bells... - Bill Fitzmaurice 08:29:25 12/11/20 (0)
- RE: "the less a transducer travels generating waveforms the 'faster' it is" - rivervalley817 10:42:09 12/05/20 (0)
- RE: "the less a transducer travels generating waveforms the 'faster' it is" - Bill Fitzmaurice 09:33:50 12/05/20 (2)
- RE: "the less a transducer travels generating waveforms the 'faster' it is" - Tre' 08:14:24 12/18/20 (1)
- RE: "the less a transducer travels generating waveforms the 'faster' it is" - Bill Fitzmaurice 09:02:36 12/18/20 (0)