In Reply to: Field coil vs permanent magnet -Fundamental differences besides the obvious? posted by mac55 on July 19, 2009 at 15:38:20:
There is no essential difference between any given field coil speaker and a permanent magnet speaker beyond the motor/magnet. Any field coil design can be made as a permanent magnet, or vice versa. A field coil motor in itself is no guarantee that a speaker will sound good. It is true, however, that many of the early, high efficiency drivers which used a field coil electromagnet out of necessity sound superb. While many attempts to do field coil speakers today miss the mark- probably because the knowledge, craft, art, or however you wish to call it for making such speakers has largely been lost through more than a half century of neglect.
I'm typing this while listening to modern field coil drivers on horns (Cogent) and the sound is indeed remarkable.
Jonathan
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Follow Ups
- RE: Field coil vs permanent magnet -Fundamental differences besides the obvious? - jweiss 19:24:00 07/19/09 (33)
- RE: Field coil vs permanent magnet -Fundamental differences besides the obvious? - edonmusic 13:51:27 09/09/09 (0)
- RE: Field coil vs permanent magnet -Fundamental differences besides the obvious? - John Sheerin 18:19:39 07/20/09 (31)
- RE: Field coil vs permanent magnet -Fundamental differences besides the obvious? - jweiss 19:05:22 07/20/09 (30)
- RE: Field coil vs permanent magnet -Fundamental differences besides the obvious? - John Sheerin 19:15:59 07/20/09 (29)
- RE: Field coil vs permanent magnet -Fundamental differences besides the obvious? - jweiss 19:38:22 07/20/09 (28)
- RE: Field coil vs permanent magnet -Fundamental differences besides the obvious? - Jmmlc 08:13:13 10/04/12 (0)
- RE: Field coil vs permanent magnet -Fundamental differences besides the obvious? - John Sheerin 19:48:12 07/20/09 (26)
- RE: Field coil vs permanent magnet -Fundamental differences besides the obvious? - jweiss 20:19:19 07/20/09 (25)
- RE: Field coil vs permanent magnet -Fundamental differences besides the obvious? - John Sheerin 10:29:35 07/21/09 (22)
- RE: Field coil vs permanent magnet -Fundamental differences besides the obvious? - jweiss 12:41:51 07/21/09 (21)
- RE: Field coil vs permanent magnet -Fundamental differences besides the obvious? - John Sheerin 06:18:22 07/23/09 (10)
- RE: Field coil vs permanent magnet -Fundamental differences besides the obvious? - Paul Eizik 10:31:39 07/23/09 (2)
- RE: Field coil vs permanent magnet -Fundamental differences besides the obvious? - John Sheerin 14:12:30 07/24/09 (0)
- RE: Alright, that's me in the picture! - Paul Eizik 09:10:09 07/24/09 (0)
- RE: Field coil vs permanent magnet -Fundamental differences besides the obvious? - jweiss 08:56:59 07/23/09 (6)
- DATA - John Sheerin 14:07:00 07/24/09 (5)
- RE:OK, ya get your old job back.... - Paul Eizik 20:11:01 07/28/09 (0)
- RE: DATA - jweiss 15:41:22 07/25/09 (2)
- Thanks John - Mr. Lowther 06:34:08 07/25/09 (0)
- Weiss Guy - Tom Brennan 07:55:53 07/22/09 (0)
- RE: Field coil vs permanent magnet -Fundamental differences besides the obvious? - John Sheerin 17:04:29 07/21/09 (8)
- RE: Keeping the world safe for horns. - Paul Eizik 13:52:24 07/22/09 (7)
- RE: Keeping the world safe for horns. - mac55 16:46:29 07/22/09 (6)
- RE: Keeping the world safe for horns. - Paul Eizik 19:25:31 07/22/09 (5)
- RE: Keeping the world safe for horns. - mac55 20:29:23 07/22/09 (4)
- RE: Keeping the world safe for horns. - Paul Eizik 10:58:49 07/23/09 (3)
- RE: Keeping the world safe for horns. - mac55 13:07:57 07/23/09 (2)
- RE: Keeping the world safe for field coils. - Paul Eizik 07:09:11 07/24/09 (1)
- RE: Keeping the world safe for field coils. - mac55 23:03:51 07/24/09 (0)
- RE: Field coil vs permanent magnet -Fundamental differences besides the obvious? - PakProtector 03:29:35 07/21/09 (1)
- RE: Field coil vs permanent magnet -Fundamental differences besides the obvious? - John Sheerin 10:36:24 07/21/09 (0)