In Reply to: All other things being equal, GPA 604 vs. Tannoy Gold 15" posted by gortnipper on July 10, 2008 at 18:16:00:
Hello All,
I had occasion to listen to, and test the Tannoy Westminster Royal.
I found it had a warm sound in the bass-not boomy, and crisp clean bass transients. When the bass is this clear, you think there is no bass sometimes. The Tannoy goes flat to 50Hz.
Here are some of the tests I made in the gentleman's living room.
The ripples are less in the bass at the mouth of the horn. I will post them if you like.
if anyone has curves of a new 604 type driver, i would very much like to see them. I have seen the ones in the Altec 1971 monitor catalog on Lansing heritage. I scaled my curves a bit more coarse than the Altec page
I found the voice perfectly integrated, a trace of edginess- but not annoying. It is quite a nice speaker.
This fellow had the ultrasonic tweeters, which are past the limits of the mic used in this test.
I have 604's the last alnico units made with NOS cones, and I like the Tannoys better. You got to have the big basshorn though.
The Tannoy also has a time delay passive network..rare these days
The HF horn in 604's ( Mantaray included) is an unsolved solution. The Tannoys did a better job.
Best ......Bill ( that should be degrees, sigh)
Tannoy Westminster Royal
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Follow Ups
- Tannoy Westminster Royal - RCA-fan 16:23:55 07/11/08 (29)
- pictures - RCA-fan 07:21:18 07/12/08 (16)
- I don't want to tread on anyone's toes. - RCA-fan 14:34:44 07/12/08 (10)
- RE: I don't want to tread on anyone's toes. - freddyi 15:36:55 07/12/08 (9)
- Subjective... - hollowboy 04:50:42 07/15/08 (4)
- RE: Subjective... - freddyi 11:24:39 07/15/08 (3)
- RE: Subjective... - hollowboy 08:14:11 07/16/08 (2)
- RE: Subjective... - freddyi 11:08:05 07/16/08 (1)
- RE: Subjective... - hollowboy 17:49:46 07/20/08 (0)
- No...... P-Audio tests - RCA-fan 16:26:42 07/12/08 (3)
- RE: No...... P-Audio tests - freddyi 17:15:15 07/12/08 (2)
- are those decent? - RCA-fan 07:36:26 07/13/08 (1)
- RE: are those decent? - freddyi 16:51:27 07/13/08 (0)
- "Poor integration"? I don't think so.... - Salectric 12:45:03 07/12/08 (0)
- Wytech is the name of the amp. (nt) - SomeJoe 10:55:32 07/12/08 (2)
- Yes! Wytech ........... - RCA-fan 11:08:19 07/12/08 (1)
- more........ Wytech ........... - RCA-fan 11:14:44 07/12/08 (0)
- comparison - RCA-fan 07:45:04 07/12/08 (0)
- Says it better than I can............. - RCA-fan 16:42:25 07/11/08 (11)
- RE: Says it better than I can............. - Tom Brennan 16:47:16 07/11/08 (10)
- RE: Says it better than I can............. - drlowmu 19:27:46 07/11/08 (9)
- Are the Monitor Gold's that different from what is in the Westminster? - castironandtubes 21:39:09 07/11/08 (8)
- Different, yes. - gortnipper 01:16:24 07/12/08 (7)
- But what is the difference? - castironandtubes 23:29:45 07/12/08 (6)
- Here is a good read - gortnipper 03:14:32 07/13/08 (5)
- Thanks - castironandtubes 17:35:29 07/13/08 (3)
- I am not so sure about that... - gortnipper 20:03:27 07/13/08 (2)
- All Theory and Conjecture for me - gortnipper 12:10:11 07/14/08 (0)
- Sounds like the logical progression of a product - castironandtubes 09:20:29 07/14/08 (0)
- RE: Here is a good read - drlowmu 08:06:20 07/13/08 (0)