In Reply to: Re: Strong conclusions posted by Mijostyn on June 21, 2002 at 17:00:21:
>> There is somthing fundamentally wrong with the high frequency performance of DSD. The better sounding SACDs
seem to be the Analog and PCM transfers and the Discs with less relative high freq energy such as symphonic music. <<I suppose the fact that you've convinced yourself of the latter is a good indication of the grains of salt we should take with the former.
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Follow Ups Full ThreadTopic - SAD/DAD far superior to CD. Is SACD better again? - audioNeil 10:30:09 06/21/02 (67)
- I couldn't have generated more replies if I'd written a deliberate troll - audioNeil 20:51:31 06/23/02 (2)
- No plug&play digital out anytime soon - Stephen 21:12:58 06/23/02 (1)
- stereo is nice, but out of a good DAC - audioNeil 13:47:13 06/24/02 (0)
- Let your ears be the judge.... - oscar 20:56:38 06/21/02 (0)
- Re: SAD/DAD far superior to CD. Is SACD better again? - Mijostyn 13:23:46 06/21/02 (50)
- check your headphone amp - Michael Bishop 06:03:22 06/22/02 (0)
- A rather novel critique... - Jim Treanor 19:02:58 06/21/02 (0)
- High frequency edginess - Stephen 17:14:35 06/21/02 (0)
- Strong conclusions - Ted Smith 15:52:30 06/21/02 (37)
- Re: Strong conclusions - Mijostyn 17:00:21 06/21/02 (2)
- Ahh, I thought that you were using the headphone jack on the player..., sorry <nt> - Ted Smith 17:16:32 06/21/02 (0)
- Re: Strong conclusions - Jazz Inmate 17:07:57 06/21/02 (0)
- Re: Strong conclusions - Jazz Inmate 16:19:10 06/21/02 (33)
- TacT that explains his silly conclusions, as he hasn't heard DSD as it is being converted to PCM. - Teresa 16:30:31 06/21/02 (32)
- Re: TacT that explains his silly conclusions, as he hasn't heard DSD as it is being converted to PCM - Mijostyn 16:51:05 06/21/02 (31)
- So I can't explain why you hear different than EVERYONE ELSE???? DSD/SACD is way smoother in the - Teresa 18:06:19 06/21/02 (0)
- Re: TacT that explains his silly conclusions, as he hasn't heard DSD as it is being converted to PCM - Jazz Inmate 17:13:31 06/21/02 (29)
- Jazz , As usual , you were wrong again . That's to be expected , considering your ... - ZS KEKL 19:01:14 06/21/02 (26)
- alles grau in grau malen - Jazz Inmate 21:09:28 06/21/02 (25)
- Jazz , When YOU are wrong , YOU are the loser . You have proven yourself to be a real loser . LOL.nt - ZS KEKL 21:32:35 06/21/02 (24)
- yeah, yeah. *yawn* - Jazz Inmate 22:39:00 06/21/02 (23)
- disgraceful - tunenut 23:14:28 06/21/02 (22)
- Jazz Inmate is an idiot. - Maven 02:33:45 06/22/02 (0)
- Mr. Robert Stuart would not post to this board as we would expose his LIES for what they are. He is - Teresa 02:10:07 06/22/02 (20)
- What "lies"? {n.t.} - Martin says 02:53:11 06/22/02 (19)
- The LIES about DSD, just read ANY of his twisted logic in any Stereo magazine, and you will see (nt) - Teresa 04:36:03 06/22/02 (18)
- Pretty strong comments there.. - 1162 12:15:25 06/22/02 (17)
- Both Sony and Phillips have refuted every LIE Mr. Stuart has ever told. All I suggest is you - Teresa 12:45:02 06/22/02 (16)
- Re: Both Sony and Phillips have refuted every LIE Mr. Stuart has ever told. All I suggest is you - Maven 13:58:03 06/22/02 (15)
- Sorry I collect both SACD and DVD-Audio, it's just SACD is WAY BETTER. And Mr. Stuart makes me ill! - Teresa 19:50:30 06/22/02 (13)
- Re: Sorry I collect both SACD and DVD-Audio, it's just SACD is WAY BETTER. And Mr. Stuart makes me - vulcanman 21:14:24 06/22/02 (12)
- My DVPS-9000ES has never been harsh except with some older Columbia Recordings which are harsh in - Teresa 02:25:56 06/23/02 (8)
- Coloration . . . - Martin says 09:33:18 06/23/02 (6)
- This so called Coloration increased the REALISM and improved the IMAGING, I think there is a - Teresa 14:48:08 06/23/02 (5)
- Re: This so called Coloration increased the REALISM and improved the IMAGING, I think there is a - Martin says 02:23:18 06/24/02 (4)
- Lay off, you're not doing too well yourself... - Ted Smith 07:03:52 06/24/02 (3)
- Re: Lay off, you're not doing too well yourself... - Martin says 07:34:21 06/24/02 (2)
- I only called Mr. Stuart EVIL because he SCARES me to death, I have no problem with PCM but Bob - Teresa 21:40:38 06/24/02 (1)
- You never know -- you might find him attractive (opposites sometimes attract!) {n.t.} - Martin says 03:36:15 06/25/02 (0)
- Re: My DVPS-9000ES has never been harsh except with some older Columbia Recordings which are harsh i - vulcanman 06:22:48 06/23/02 (0)
- Harsh? - Ted Smith 01:12:11 06/23/02 (2)
- Re: Harsh? - vulcanman 08:17:55 06/23/02 (1)
- Re: Harsh? - Ted Smith 12:55:09 06/23/02 (0)
- Re: Both Sony and Phillips have refuted every LIE Mr. Stuart has ever told. All I suggest is you - Jazz Inmate 16:02:26 06/22/02 (0)
- Thanks Jazz, I assumed he had it connected between the players and the headphone pre-amp (nt) - Teresa 18:12:43 06/21/02 (1)
- Me too - Jazz Inmate 20:48:59 06/21/02 (0)
- Re: SAD/DAD far superior to CD. Is SACD better again? - Rich 14:24:19 06/21/02 (1)
- Rich I agree, he does have it backwards. - Teresa 16:37:42 06/21/02 (0)
- Re: SAD/DAD far superior to CD. Is SACD better again? - audioNeil 13:55:09 06/21/02 (6)
- Uh, I think you're wrong about the Bel Canto and DSD. - Maven 02:38:04 06/22/02 (1)
- likely so - audioNeil 20:41:10 06/23/02 (0)
- He's on drugs (nt) - Rich 14:27:16 06/21/02 (3)
- Re: He's on drugs (nt) - Mijostyn 17:03:43 06/21/02 (2)
- Re: He's on drugs (nt) - Rich 21:20:49 06/21/02 (1)
- OK............. - Chris Garrett 22:15:23 06/21/02 (0)
- I'd say so... - Jack Gilvey 11:47:37 06/21/02 (0)
- Re: SAD/DAD far superior to CD. Is SACD better again? - WILD2 11:33:17 06/21/02 (0)
- Re: SAD/DAD far superior to CD. Is SACD better again? - sam9 11:22:22 06/21/02 (1)
- Re: SAD/DAD far superior to CD. Is SACD better again? - audioNeil 11:39:39 06/21/02 (0)
- The one DAD/SACD comparison I've done-- - Jim Treanor 11:13:35 06/21/02 (0)
- I enjoy both 24/96 SAD/DAD and SACD. And SACD is even better, more LIVE and RELAXED sounding - Teresa 10:51:01 06/21/02 (6)
- PS: here is my post comparing a 24/96 DAD to SACD version - Teresa 11:00:52 06/21/02 (5)
- Re: PS: here is my post comparing a 24/96 DAD to SACD version - chris.redmond2@bushinternet.com 03:38:19 06/22/02 (4)
- Re: PS: here is my post comparing a 24/96 DAD to SACD version - vulcanman 08:25:48 06/23/02 (1)
- Re: PS: here is my post comparing a 24/96 DAD to SACD version - chris.redmond2@bushinternet.com 12:13:25 06/23/02 (0)
- Chris my DVP-S9000ES is Sony's Statement DVD Player and the only ES player, the Video is FANTASTIC - Teresa 04:48:25 06/22/02 (1)
- Re: Chris my DVP-S9000ES is Sony's Statement DVD Player and the only ES player, the Video is FANTAST - chris.redmond2@bushinternet.com 08:26:45 06/22/02 (0)
Follow Ups
- Re: Strong conclusions - Jazz Inmate 17:07:57 06/21/02 (0)