In Reply to: RE: Here's a reply from Robert Von Bahr of BIS... posted by Disbeliever on June 16, 2012 at 01:25:52:
No, Mr. Disbeliever, I don't find it at all interesting. I find it sad.
Sad that you accuse me of barefaced lying - our recording engineer has NOT tampered with the dynamics, basta! Your repeating it doesn't make it any more truthful, but it does put eggs on your face.
Sad that you cannot follow simple logic on a level of a 10-year old. Last time (I am a born optimist):
If there is a difference in dynamics and therefore the average level, and all other things being equal, and we have NOT tampered with the dynamics, then follows that the others have. QED.
Mind you, I am not making statements about the quality of our recordings vs any other labels'. I am not saying that my view re dynamics objectively is better, and there may very well be some substance to some complaints (especially from someone that has to broadcast on an analogue net). But I AM saying that we want to present the truth, and we DO present the truth, and nothing but, as far as dynamics are concerned. If you don't like it, stay clear.
I would expect to get criticism from people that try to listen to a cheap boombox while showering, or from people who regard classical music as nice background, but in THIS Forum, where people are audiophiles and presumably interested in the correct sound and true dynamics, that feels really odd, and that's putting it mildly. Very mildly. Why do you buy SACD:s, if you don't want the full Monty? mp3 would suit you admirably (we can provide them as well...)
Robert von Bahr
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Follow Ups
- RE: Here's a reply from Robert Von Bahr of BIS... - bissie 03:09:17 06/16/12 (6)
- RE: Here's a reply from Robert Von Bahr of BIS... - Disbeliever 03:27:29 06/16/12 (5)
- RE: Here's a reply from Robert Von Bahr of BIS... - HumanMedia 04:00:27 06/30/12 (4)
- RE: Here's a reply from Robert Von Bahr of BIS... - Disbeliever 04:12:39 06/30/12 (3)
- RE: Here's a reply from Robert Von Bahr of BIS... - Disbeliever 06:35:54 07/03/12 (2)
- RE: Here's a reply from Robert Von Bahr of BIS... - flyingdutchman 12:51:30 07/03/12 (1)
- RE: Here's a reply from Robert Von Bahr of BIS... - flyingdutchman 12:53:18 07/03/12 (0)