In Reply to: RE: Here's a reply from Robert Von Bahr of BIS... posted by Disbeliever on June 15, 2012 at 23:56:05:
Yes, I am saying that, all other things being equal, if we have the same repertoire, the artists play equally loudly, and there is a difference in the average level, yes, Mr. Disbeliever, they have tampered with the dynamics. If there is a difference in dynamics, and since I KNOW that we haven't changed anything, they must have. Basic logic 1 A. And, since, without naming names, I happen to know that quite a lot of labels do do that, I feel even more justified is stating this - obvious - fact.
I am not putting any real value opinion into this. I can understand that, if an SACD contains one huge crash and the rest is "normal", the temptation is there to diminish the crash, so that the rest will appear to be louder in comparison with it. It is just that I am an absolute, and I have forbidden that practice. However understandable, it is a lie.
If you have this problem with BIS and not with the others, then either they compress, or our Artists play more wildly. There are no other answers.
Robert von Bahr
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Follow Ups
- RE: Here's a reply from Robert Von Bahr of BIS... - bissie 01:02:20 06/16/12 (8)
- RE: Here's a reply from Robert Von Bahr of BIS... - Disbeliever 01:25:52 06/16/12 (7)
- RE: Here's a reply from Robert Von Bahr of BIS... - bissie 03:09:17 06/16/12 (6)
- RE: Here's a reply from Robert Von Bahr of BIS... - Disbeliever 03:27:29 06/16/12 (5)
- RE: Here's a reply from Robert Von Bahr of BIS... - HumanMedia 04:00:27 06/30/12 (4)
- RE: Here's a reply from Robert Von Bahr of BIS... - Disbeliever 04:12:39 06/30/12 (3)
- RE: Here's a reply from Robert Von Bahr of BIS... - Disbeliever 06:35:54 07/03/12 (2)
- RE: Here's a reply from Robert Von Bahr of BIS... - flyingdutchman 12:51:30 07/03/12 (1)
- RE: Here's a reply from Robert Von Bahr of BIS... - flyingdutchman 12:53:18 07/03/12 (0)