In Reply to: I don't understand the debate-SACD sounds way better than CD to me posted by Wegman on December 2, 2006 at 07:39:16:
I still believe this is the case. The best recorded SA-CD beats the best recorded RB-CD. In the beginning I assume we were all somewhat in awe of the new medium. Fairly simple and cheap SACD players easily showed off the format's capabilities. SA-CD also sparked a sudden increase in quality of regular CD-player's.But then the SA-CD novelty-factor wore off. The medium matured further. Faults and disappointments became apparent. And I have no doubt that many of us witnessed a socalled 'the emperor has no clothes' effect. Some SA-CD are truly not Super-anything. OTOH, well recorded SA-CD's have opened our eyes to what can be possible. The industry and audiophiles alike actually have a lot to thank SA-CD for.
The inherent qualities of SA-CD have pointed me towards an appreciation for vinyl. I would say that vinyl is a truly hi-rez format and it takes a LOT to better it. I am not yet experienced enough to definitively state that vinyl is better than SA-CD, but I am leaning towards this conclusion. I think I can support the conclusion that it is cheaper, relatively speaking, to achieve true reference quality audio playback with vinyl than with digital. For a few thousand dollars a reference quality vinyl system can be built. It takes multple tens of thousands of dollars to achieve the same with digital.
Jw
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Follow Ups
- Best SA-CD beats Best RB-CD - Joel_Waterman 22:39:56 12/02/06 (7)
- Re: Best SA-CD beats Best RB-CD - edta 17:20:26 12/05/06 (0)
- One man's meat... - sgb 16:48:16 12/04/06 (0)
- Re: Best SA-CD beats Best RB-CD - vahe@flash.net 08:35:21 12/03/06 (2)
- Pleasantly surprised by the lack of it... - Joel_Waterman 20:50:33 12/03/06 (0)
- Re: Vinyl surface noise vs. the noise floor - Dave Garretson 09:44:45 12/03/06 (0)
- A relative statement - Dave Garretson 08:21:04 12/03/06 (1)
- The biggest 'surprise' has indeed been RB-CD... - Joel_Waterman 10:45:08 12/03/06 (0)