In Reply to: Who is your favorite audio reviewer? posted by Bud on November 10, 2004 at 17:34:27:
For me it isRichard Heddesy of Audio perfectionist Journal
Martin DeWolf of Bound for Sound
Arthur Salvatore is for me the equivelent of the ABC's ( Australian Broadcasting Corp) Mediawatch program for the audio press he's job is to keep "The barstards Honest"
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Follow Ups Full ThreadTopic - Who is your favorite audio reviewer? - Bud 17:34:27 11/10/04 (152)
- Don Keele - Atexanathome 08:59:36 11/24/04 (0)
- David Ranada - Norm Strong 19:09:03 11/17/04 (0)
- John Atkinson, without a doubt - EddieT 06:02:03 11/15/04 (2)
- Re: John Atkinson, without a doubt - John Atkinson 16:27:29 11/15/04 (0)
- I agree - kerameikos 07:47:18 11/15/04 (0)
- Re: Who is your favorite audio reviewer? - greginsydneyau 17:25:36 11/13/04 (0)
- Re: Martin Colloms - patrickU 06:52:57 11/13/04 (9)
- Re: Martin Colloms - Julien43 02:55:57 11/15/04 (1)
- Re: Re: Martin Colloms - patrickU 04:03:20 11/15/04 (0)
- hasn't Martin Colloms had health problems recently? - kerameikos 15:41:04 11/14/04 (6)
- I hope not , but I haven't read anything from him in some time. - Julien43 15:54:56 11/14/04 (5)
- Re: I hope not , but I haven't read anything from him in some time. - patrickU 00:23:14 11/15/04 (4)
- I sincerely hope so - kerameikos 03:22:52 11/15/04 (3)
- Re: I love your nickname! nt - patrickU 03:51:13 11/15/04 (2)
- it's just a pun ... - kerameikos 04:18:40 11/15/04 (1)
- Re: it's just a pun ... - patrickU 04:27:24 11/15/04 (0)
- Marlon Feld, Dick Olsher, Jeff Day - CraigS. 13:42:29 11/12/04 (0)
- I don't really have a favorite. - bwkendall 12:40:11 11/12/04 (0)
- Re: Who is your favorite audio reviewer? - regmac 09:50:43 11/12/04 (0)
- Hey! Everything is all messed up in this thread now! - Big Dave 08:57:04 11/12/04 (0)
- Hey, why did my John Marks "vote" disappear... - TeddiJackEddie 08:38:51 11/12/04 (1)
- Re: Who is your favorite audio reviewer? - ferlez007 07:32:49 11/12/04 (0)
- Julian Hirsch... - Neil49 06:56:32 11/12/04 (2)
- Hirsch died Nov. 24, 2003, at age 81. - Pat D 11:29:04 11/12/04 (0)
- That's because he's dead. I liked the man.(nt) - samtellig 11:28:05 11/12/04 (0)
- Peter Aczel of the Audio critic - MusicLover 06:33:55 11/12/04 (20)
- Re: Peter Aczel of the Audio critic - srl1 13:26:29 11/14/04 (1)
- Re: Peter Aczel of the Audio critic - MusicLover 06:57:00 11/21/04 (0)
- Peter Aczel of The Audio Critic... - mkuller 21:17:07 11/12/04 (6)
- Could you tell me where to look for his history? - MusicLover 04:55:20 11/13/04 (5)
- The Audio Critic - In a nut shell... - mkuller 10:51:58 11/13/04 (4)
- Re: The Audio Critic - In a nut shell... - mp72 13:29:39 12/05/04 (0)
- Re: The Audio Critic - In a nut shell... - MusicLover 07:00:56 11/21/04 (2)
- The Audio Critic - mkuller 17:49:34 11/21/04 (1)
- Re: The Audio Critic - MusicLover 05:26:34 11/24/04 (0)
- Re: Peter Aczel of the Audio critic - nycman 17:37:15 11/12/04 (0)
- Would you call his Fourier review "very honest"? (nt) - Rob Doorack 07:03:08 11/12/04 (9)
- Re: Would you call his Fourier review "very honest"? (nt) - MusicLover 14:08:24 11/12/04 (6)
- Re: Would you call his Fourier review "very honest"? (nt) - Rob Doorack 16:14:11 11/12/04 (5)
- Re: Would you call his Fourier review "very honest"? (nt) - mp72 14:07:31 12/05/04 (0)
- Re: Would you call his Fourier review "very honest"? (nt) - nycman 17:48:48 11/12/04 (3)
- Whoa...I love to hear conspiracy theories... - mkuller 11:20:43 11/13/04 (0)
- Re: Would you call his Fourier review "very honest"? (nt) - Rob Doorack 21:44:48 11/12/04 (1)
- In defence of Peter Aczel - MusicLover 04:50:17 11/13/04 (0)
- Rob, I was going to vote for you, too... - TeddiJackEddie 08:41:30 11/12/04 (1)
- "#1 in musical taste"? Even I'd argue with that! - Rob Doorack 09:10:08 11/12/04 (0)
- harry pearson - hifitommy 19:03:08 11/10/04 (2)
- I second your choice. (nt) - mkuller 10:24:43 11/11/04 (0)
- With decided bias on my part, I agree - E-Stat 15:00:27 11/11/04 (0)
- Martin DeWulf - Okie 20:54:05 11/10/04 (0)
- Art (who else?) - 4season 21:08:49 11/10/04 (5)
- Ya beat me to it. - Steve Eddy 21:42:58 11/10/04 (1)
- Re: Ya beat me to it. - setlow 10:33:18 11/11/04 (0)
- Pardon My Ignorance, But... - Todd Krieger 11:04:27 11/11/04 (1)
- Re: Pardon My Ignorance, But... - 4season 11:53:43 11/11/04 (0)
- The audio critic you'd most like to hang out with. - edta 19:43:36 11/11/04 (0)
- Srajan Ebaen - rat_sass 21:37:03 11/10/04 (0)
- Me. - Tromatic 21:47:21 11/10/04 (1)
- Exactly. nt - Tom 06:07:02 11/11/04 (0)
- Re: Roy Gregory, HiFi+ - #11 00:13:03 11/11/04 (0)
- Joe Rosen; who used to post over at Vintage - grinagog 00:52:51 11/11/04 (2)
- Re: Joe Rosen; who used to post over at Vintage - Jank 08:07:08 11/11/04 (1)
- 3rd that! What happened to him? - Marc Bratton 16:13:31 11/11/04 (0)
- The late, great, Harvey "Gizmo" Rosenberg. (nt) - chickenlogic 01:45:11 11/11/04 (10)
- Re: Another vote for Harvey "Gizmo" Rosenberg. (nt) - Presto 19:52:41 11/12/04 (0)
- I Quadruple THAT nomination! - N.B.C. 01:56:25 11/11/04 (0)
- ABSOLUTELY, POSITIVELY AGREE... - TeddiJackEddie 04:32:01 11/11/04 (0)
- Hear! Hear! (nt) - Jim Dowdy 05:54:09 11/11/04 (0)
- Thats spot on - GG 05:56:47 11/11/04 (0)
- I get all teary eyed when I think of him - Kloss 06:24:11 11/11/04 (0)
- He was Music!! (nt) - nycman 10:41:25 11/11/04 (0)
- I disliked reading his articles, headware... - howard 11:52:30 11/11/04 (0)
- NYAL had the most unconventional owner's manuals - 4season 12:05:05 11/11/04 (0)
- Another vote for the "Gizmo" (nt) - Ivan303 18:10:55 11/11/04 (0)
- Re: KR -NT - Aroc 03:49:27 11/11/04 (1)
- I'm with you on this!! (nt) - perose 07:15:17 11/11/04 (0)
- Corey Greenberg from Stereophile years ago... - jefe 06:19:19 11/11/04 (6)
- Corry G - - definately missed - Larry S 14:14:43 11/13/04 (0)
- Re: Corey Greenberg from Stereophile years ago... - perose 07:17:58 11/11/04 (3)
- Re: Corey Greenberg from Stereophile years ago... - theguelpher 07:52:53 11/11/04 (1)
- Re: Corey Greenberg from Stereophile years ago... - nycman 10:39:42 11/11/04 (0)
- Re: Corey Greenberg from Stereophile years ago... - Andrew Chasin 13:40:41 11/11/04 (0)
- CG & AD - Corndog71 10:15:56 11/11/04 (0)
- Re: Who is your favorite audio reviewer? - rico 07:14:23 11/11/04 (0)
- I used to like Rob Doorak - dvb 07:57:38 11/11/04 (0)
- Albert Porter & David Robinson - tnelson 07:58:44 11/11/04 (0)
- John Potis @ 6moons - samac 08:14:29 11/11/04 (0)
- Without a doubt JM and KR... - Steve Cortez 08:18:38 11/11/04 (1)
- Re: Without a doubt JM and KR . . . D I T T O ! - Mike Mount 16:53:03 11/11/04 (0)
- Anthony Cordesman - Alex F. 08:21:14 11/11/04 (15)
- Re: Anthony Cordesman - Neil49 07:02:14 11/12/04 (0)
- Think I'll have to second - kavakidd 08:40:51 11/11/04 (2)
- And Third..... - Todd Krieger 11:00:03 11/11/04 (1)
- Re: And Third..... - tubelover@aol.com 19:39:58 11/11/04 (0)
- He likes to review the big is better type of equipment - Norm 11:14:36 11/11/04 (6)
- He often explores the state of the art - Alex F. 13:16:46 11/11/04 (3)
- Re: He often explores the state of the art - Mike Mount 17:16:17 11/11/04 (2)
- Yes, I use horns and SET - Norm 20:44:37 11/11/04 (1)
- Re: Yes, I use horns and SET - Mike Mount 22:23:26 11/11/04 (0)
- AHC's Current Equipment - Metralla 21:30:20 11/11/04 (1)
- Re: AHC's Current Equipment .... SWEET! (nt) - Mike Mount 22:28:23 11/11/04 (0)
- Re: Anthony Cordesman - middleground 18:13:34 11/11/04 (1)
- matters of defence! - hifitommy 18:36:22 11/11/04 (0)
- he was good enough to be found in - hifitommy 18:45:06 11/11/04 (0)
- Indeed, in the top rung of reviewers. nt. - edta 19:30:40 11/11/04 (0)
- Howard Ferstler... - nycman 10:43:27 11/11/04 (6)
- Howard Ferstler... - mkuller 21:22:49 11/12/04 (3)
- Re: Howard Ferstler's - cdb 09:42:23 11/13/04 (2)
- That's exactly what I mean... - mkuller 10:54:38 11/13/04 (1)
- Re: That's exactly what I mean... - steve 01:41:52 12/04/04 (0)
- My Dad subscribes to Sensible Sound... - Sean 22:02:56 11/11/04 (1)
- I agree, and Howard Ferstler ... - Dave Pogue 04:33:51 11/12/04 (0)
- Holt, Crabbe, Greene, Salvatore (nt) - goldenthal 11:12:27 11/11/04 (0)
- Sam Tellig was my man when he was THE AUDIO CHEAPSKATE - jimmyjames 11:27:14 11/11/04 (3)
- Sam (the audio anarchist) Tellig and Fremer all the way! - rod@rodclark.com 15:01:02 11/12/04 (0)
- Ditto: before he joined the more money than brains set - Bob Wortman 18:49:28 11/11/04 (0)
- Tellig is a big disappointment to me. One of the reasons I dropped Stereophile. - edta 19:25:01 11/11/04 (0)
- me... - some young guy 11:52:36 11/11/04 (0)
- AC, DO and RH. - howard 11:53:58 11/11/04 (1)
- I'm honored! - Andrew Chasin 22:33:08 11/11/04 (0)
- Re: Who is your favorite audio reviewer? - mejames 12:42:43 11/11/04 (0)
- HP... - Andrew Chasin 13:45:02 11/11/04 (3)
- eloquent and elegant - hifitommy 18:32:10 11/11/04 (0)
- Re: HP... - Todd Krieger 18:41:02 11/11/04 (1)
- Re: HP... - Andrew Chasin 19:11:24 11/11/04 (0)
- Roy Gregory and Art Dudley. nt - jond 14:20:22 11/11/04 (0)
- J-10 in his Stereophile days... - David Aiken 15:56:44 11/11/04 (1)
- Hear, hear - BillH 04:03:58 11/12/04 (0)
- Romy the Cat, who used to post in these hallowed.... - Marc Bratton 16:17:34 11/11/04 (8)
- Romy the Cat has a website - edta 17:51:57 11/20/04 (1)
- Re: Romy the Cat has a website - Atexanathome 09:02:27 11/24/04 (0)
- Yup, R t C is missed:-( (nt) - Ivan303 18:05:37 11/11/04 (2)
- NOT! dont' encourage that wanker to show up again. n/t - Ed Sawyer 18:11:18 11/11/04 (1)
- Wankers? They are as common as dirt on here, if you haven't noticed. As are corporate sucks. - edta 19:21:50 11/11/04 (0)
- A character, I miss him too. - edta 19:17:50 11/11/04 (0)
- Romy The Cat Was Great - Jwm 21:29:56 11/11/04 (0)
- Romys are a dime a dozen, give me Nigel and his wit anyday!(NT) - Ozzy 01:08:40 11/12/04 (0)
- Kalman Rubinson! - Mike Mount 16:34:48 11/11/04 (1)
- Kal is more honest than most and.... - Sean 21:58:19 11/11/04 (0)
- Kalman Rubinson! - Mike Mount 16:40:55 11/11/04 (0)
- Art Dudly - david hull 17:13:36 11/11/04 (1)
- Miss Listener a lot. - edta 19:16:12 11/11/04 (0)
- All reviewers are irrelavent. Their time has come and is long gone. - Ed Sawyer 18:18:49 11/11/04 (2)
- sorry ed, not true - hifitommy 18:56:59 11/11/04 (0)
- It is VERY hard to be 100% objective...... - Audio Pharaoh 05:52:49 11/12/04 (0)
- I second John Marks... (nt) - TeddiJackEddie 18:42:29 11/11/04 (0)
- Richard BassNut Greene - andy_c 19:07:44 11/11/04 (0)
- Brian Damkroger, John Marks, Kalman Rubinson and ... - Mike K 20:13:28 11/11/04 (1)
- Re: Hear - Hear, Kalman Rubinson and his reviews ... - Mike Mount 21:33:40 11/11/04 (0)
- ME! I'm always right. NT - RGA 20:31:44 11/11/04 (0)
- Jack English Anyone remember Soundslike Great Magazine - Jwm 21:33:08 11/11/04 (0)
- Interesting... - Andrew Chasin 22:37:21 11/11/04 (0)
Follow Ups
- Re: Who is your favorite audio reviewer? - greginsydneyau 17:25:36 11/13/04 (0)