|
Critic's Corner Discuss a review. Provide constructive feedback. Talk to the industry. |
|
|
|
Critic's Corner Discuss a review. Provide constructive feedback. Talk to the industry. |
|
In Reply to: Does anybody regularly trash Julian Hirsch now? posted by Rob Doorack on February 12, 2007 at 12:22:45:
'cause that be the only reason for your not knowing this. People here regularly trash a man who has probably brought more people to audio than Stereophile and TAS combined.Before anybody flames that, Walmart sells a whole lot more clothes than Neiman Marcus. Many of us here may have started with Walmart (Stereo Review) only to have have graduated to Neiman's (the cool guy rags), but most of us more than likely are not trust fund babies or .com millionaires.
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Follow Ups Full ThreadTopic - Any examples of a critic criticizing another critic for publishing questionable theories or advice? - Richard BassNut Greene 07:14:57 02/08/07 (98)
- Here's a whopper I pointed out a few years back. - TAFKA Steve 16:18:32 02/09/07 (3)
- You couldn't have picked a worse example - Rob Doorack 07:04:52 02/10/07 (2)
- Precisely why I brought it up. - TAFKA Steve 19:17:40 02/10/07 (1)
- Precisely ! - Bruce from DC 06:17:00 02/12/07 (0)
- JA has sort of "criticized" Mike Fremer. - Enophile 11:23:48 02/09/07 (1)
- At this point it appears that audio magazines supported by advertising don't expect their critics to criticize anything! - Richard BassNut Greene 09:38:53 02/09/07 (14)
- [Sigh] I guess I get different versions of the magazines - Bruce Kendall 16:32:36 02/09/07 (2)
- Or maybe you're *just too stupid* to discern Mr. Nut's delightful, insightful observations? nt - clarkjohnsen 10:45:41 02/10/07 (1)
- Is bjh related to you? - Richard BassNut Greene 08:16:16 02/12/07 (0)
- Yet again you've done a marvelous job convincing your audience, i.e. - bjh 10:13:38 02/09/07 (10)
- Once again the Canuck ankle biter comes to the rescue. - Ozzie 01:05:05 02/10/07 (9)
- You are way to generous. nt - Dan Banquer 11:20:27 02/10/07 (6)
- Hey Dan, ... - bjh 11:37:20 02/10/07 (5)
- Hey Ho - Dan Banquer 12:16:27 02/10/07 (4)
- Hey Dan, would you say it was the Aczel/TAC review that started - bjh 12:51:16 02/10/07 (3)
- Hey Ho revisted - Dan Banquer 13:08:55 02/10/07 (2)
- "without that review the business would never have gotten off the ground" Go On! - bjh 14:36:44 02/10/07 (1)
- Iraqi marketing - E-Stat 09:47:00 02/11/07 (0)
- Yaaaaaaan. nt - bjh 10:47:41 02/10/07 (0)
- Holy Cow bjh is a Canuck ! - Richard BassNut Greene 09:08:33 02/10/07 (0)
- Why, just a few days ago: "A critic castigates the critics." - clarkjohnsen 14:24:49 02/08/07 (15)
- Includes one sentence: Unamed manufacturer's rep complained about an unamed reviewer to author who uses a moniker! - Richard BassNut Greene 08:50:54 02/09/07 (3)
- Re: Includes one sentence: Unamed manufacturer's rep complained about an unamed reviewer to author who uses a moniker! - andy19191 15:05:05 02/09/07 (2)
- Re: Oh, the irony, the irony - Dr. S 16:30:24 02/14/07 (0)
- "So who is going to pay to produce it?" ... - bjh 10:50:43 02/10/07 (0)
- That's only your not very accurate take on it. - Pat D 20:31:13 02/08/07 (5)
- Wasn't me! Maybe you should try reading it?... nt - clarkjohnsen 12:32:10 02/09/07 (4)
- "It" was the article itself. It wasn't "about" critics, so you were wrong about "it", - Pat D 10:39:42 02/10/07 (3)
- And where did I "misinterpret" it? Or even interpret it? Put up or shut up, if you can. nt - clarkjohnsen 10:42:34 02/10/07 (2)
- It was in your title line--you used the plural "critics," and the article says very little about them. - Pat D 14:29:43 02/10/07 (1)
- Critics *inter alia*. Geez Luiz, that's a "misinterpretation"? nt - clarkjohnsen 12:18:17 02/11/07 (0)
- Clark, did you put Mr. Nut up to this so you could repost? (nt) - mkuller 18:43:45 02/08/07 (4)
- You should include (nt) with ALL your posts .... - Richard BassNut Greene 08:56:46 02/09/07 (3)
- "Bellowing Bertha Big Butt Bitch" ? Hmmmm....? You know - bjh 09:05:58 02/09/07 (2)
- Sorry I insulted your wife - Richard BassNut Greene 09:32:38 02/09/07 (0)
- Maybe the misogyny isn't pretend...(nt) - mkuller 09:29:46 02/09/07 (0)
- I'll bite - Jim Austin 13:37:26 02/08/07 (17)
- Your critical article on the Intelligent Chip was good & Clark's articulate but incompetent response was priceless! - Richard BassNut Greene 08:16:23 02/09/07 (13)
- You mean, the one published in Stereophile? The one Jim Austin, PhD, blatantly lied about here? He, whom... - clarkjohnsen 10:40:02 02/10/07 (11)
- Re: You mean, the one published in Stereophile? The one Jim Austin, PhD, blatantly lied about here? He, whom... - Ozzie 10:29:56 02/12/07 (2)
- Any chapter and verse on that? I mean, besides here on AA... nt - clarkjohnsen 12:00:46 02/12/07 (1)
- Sorry, but I have a life outside of audio. - Ozzie 12:18:58 02/13/07 (0)
- Sorry I assumed he listened before writing a review -- I stand corrected - Richard BassNut Greene 08:28:30 02/12/07 (5)
- Re: Sorry I assumed he listened before writing a review -- I stand corrected - regmac 15:13:28 02/13/07 (3)
- I think you must have standards for reviews ... and listening to the product is the lowest common denominator standard - Richard BassNut Greene 08:40:56 02/14/07 (0)
- Re: Sorry I assumed he listened before writing a review -- I stand corrected - john curl 00:49:15 02/14/07 (1)
- Re: Sorry I assumed he listened before writing a review -- I stand corrected - regmac 07:45:35 02/14/07 (0)
- "That's just not Kosher." Indeed not. nt - clarkjohnsen 12:02:07 02/12/07 (0)
- Yip yip! - Jim Austin 13:45:24 02/10/07 (1)
- A proven liar, yet no manful apology or retraction. Talk about self-demeaning... nt - clarkjohnsen 12:16:00 02/11/07 (0)
- ... and later there could be a Reality TV show where critics hang out in an - bjh 09:12:10 02/09/07 (1)
- And if his $83 speaker cables are - Bruce Kendall 16:55:37 02/08/07 (0)
- I have heard this effect... - mkuller 16:43:21 02/08/07 (0)
- It occurred to me after I wrote this... - Jim Austin 14:14:27 02/08/07 (0)
- Only the audio 'tabloids'... - mkuller 13:01:12 02/08/07 (16)
- Do Aczel, Hardesty and Salvato criticize and accept advertising too? - Richard BassNut Greene 08:23:34 02/09/07 (15)
- and does anyone pay retail? - jdouglas51 13:28:14 02/09/07 (0)
- That's why you are The...oh pardon...Mr. Nut... - mkuller 09:27:28 02/09/07 (13)
- "EVERY review I have read is critical" -- Really? Name one product whose review said it was average or below average - Richard BassNut Greene 09:06:42 02/10/07 (11)
- You may be the only one who wants to read reviews of below average audio products... - mkuller 14:26:00 02/12/07 (1)
- Mikey, I know your not that much of a snob. - Ozzie 12:46:45 02/13/07 (1)
- Few reviews are critical any more. - Ozzie 10:18:02 02/12/07 (2)
- Does anybody regularly trash Julian Hirsch now? - Rob Doorack 12:22:45 02/12/07 (1)
- Rob, tell me you didn't just get here? - Ozzie 12:29:25 02/13/07 (0)
- Two come to my mind immediately - kerr 12:12:53 02/10/07 (2)
- Re: Two come to my mind immediately - Rob Doorack 06:44:46 02/12/07 (1)
- Yep - kerr 09:12:55 02/12/07 (0)
- Mr. Nut Rating... 0 Stars. - bjh 11:15:56 02/10/07 (2)
- I'll debate audio while you respond with your stale childish character attacks - Richard BassNut Greene 08:34:12 02/12/07 (1)
- Here's a review that had no criticism. - TAFKA Steve 16:14:09 02/09/07 (0)
- Re: Any examples of a critic criticizing another critic for publishing questionable theories or advice? - kerr 10:22:30 02/08/07 (12)
- Not if you use an audiophile horseblanket ... and I happen to have some you may be interested in. - Richard BassNut Greene 08:27:49 02/09/07 (11)
- Sure...but first a question. - kerr 10:04:34 02/09/07 (10)
- "Not one of them that I listened to could have been bettered by a $100 speaker with good wire." Hmm... - clarkjohnsen 10:51:22 02/10/07 (9)
- Re: "Not one of them that I listened to could have been bettered by a $100 speaker with good wire." Hmm... - kerr 12:15:15 02/10/07 (8)
- And what was that "better wire"? nt - clarkjohnsen 12:20:58 02/10/07 (7)
- The Cardas Neutral Reference from my main rig - kerr 17:21:34 02/10/07 (6)
- Ah! Perhaps not the sort of *revealing* cable the writer had intended... nt - clarkjohnsen 12:20:19 02/11/07 (5)
- Which makes his claim using a less revealing cable all the more unbelievable (nt) - kerr 15:16:37 02/11/07 (4)
- I'd expect he'd have had a *better* cable. nt - clarkjohnsen 11:57:17 02/12/07 (3)
- But he was talking about Mapleshade so I guess not! (nt) - kerr 13:07:22 02/12/07 (2)
- I must be confused... nt - clarkjohnsen 10:29:00 02/13/07 (1)
- No more than usual (nt) - Richard BassNut Greene 14:27:15 02/16/07 (0)
- Oh, and don't forget Aczel, pre or post Fourrier - Bob Rex 10:05:39 02/08/07 (3)
- Aczel slammed some Mobile Fidelity electronics in an issue that contained a MF ad for them - Atexanathome 09:38:39 02/10/07 (2)
- Re: Aczel slammed some Mobile Fidelity electronics in an issue that contained a MF ad for them - theaudiohobby 11:22:32 02/10/07 (0)
- "He was pretty upset because of turn-on-off transients that blew up his sub" - bjh 11:20:34 02/10/07 (0)
- TAS used to.... - Bob Rex 10:02:03 02/08/07 (1)
- Re: TAS used to.... - TomLarson 11:24:50 02/08/07 (0)
- Re: Any examples of a critic criticizing another critic for publishing questionable theories or advice? - bjh 08:16:33 02/08/07 (4)
- Pierre Sprey offers lots of "audio advice" in his catalog - Richard BassNut Greene 08:44:12 02/08/07 (3)
- Really? - E-Stat 13:47:34 02/08/07 (1)
- I'm right behind you! - kerr 12:18:20 02/10/07 (0)
- Richard my boy, are we to expect the "critics" to start - bjh 12:22:12 02/08/07 (0)
- Re: Any examples of a critic criticizing another critic for publishing questionable theories or advice? - regmac 07:48:22 02/08/07 (2)
- "Why do you ask?" - Richard BassNut Greene 08:15:11 02/08/07 (1)
- Re: "Why do you ask?" - TomLarson 11:31:13 02/08/07 (0)
Follow Ups
- Rob, tell me you didn't just get here? - Ozzie 12:29:25 02/13/07 (0)
Top of Page ]
[ Contact Us ]
[ Support/Wish List ]
[ Copyright © 2024, Audio Asylum, all rights reserved ]
