Amp/Preamp Asylum Looking for a new Amp or Preamp? If you're after tubes, post over here. |
|
In Reply to: Not sure I made my point clear... posted by E-Stat on May 15, 2011 at 12:49:56:
E-Stat,
I realize, now, that you are serious about getting more 'warmth' from your (main?) system, in particular. I'm very sure your VTL 450 is absolutely capable in that regard - so that's not a problem. I wonder, though, if with the SoundLabs 8' out from the wall, whether the lower-mids are sufficiently reinforced. I'm not sure, another inmate, Duke LeJuene of AudioKinesis, is a SoundLab fan and (former?) user - let's hope he sees this and jumps in to advise you.
But from where I sit, and from what you've said, I'd be more inclined to take a serious look at that SP9. I know some ARC fans think the SP9 is not amongst the best of ARC pre-amps. And you 've mentioned: "I originally bought the unit as a MKII and had the factory update it to MKIII specs. That change itself improved the lower midrange output and removed a touch of thinness with the MKII flavor. I don't perceive any change of tonal balance when the preamp is bypassed and replaced by attenuators."
Regarding the SP9's 'thinness' you cited, I wonder if ALL of it was removed. I know no such thinness existed in (others around that era) the SP8, SP10, SP11, or LS3. The LS1 & LS2 are not highly rated, as I recall, and those were derived from (you guessed it) the SP9, I believe. Perhaps this could be where your issue lies.
Another of our inmates, Bambi, is expert on ALL things ARC, she owns SP8, LS3, and SP10, among others (amps included). She knows all about every pre-amp ARC has ever made (and perhaps some W.Z. Johnson hasn't thought of as yet, LOL) Let's hope she also sees this and jumps in to advise you on the SP9.
Bye the way, as far as tubes go, all ARC's tend towards the 'neutral' (some more than others). If it turns out that the SP9 is the actual cause for your concern then, in seeking an alternative, I'd look at the Conrad-Johnson line - notorious for bringing extra 'warmth' to a 'cool' system.
Oh, and regarding the 2nd system, I know the Threshold was totally awesome in most respects - not sure it was renown for its performance at the lower-mids, though, certainly not to the level of your VTL, I'm sure.
Best of luck with the SP9.
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Follow Ups
- RE: Not sure I made my point clear... - waj4all 16:39:27 05/15/11 (13)
- Actually... - E-Stat 19:51:19 05/15/11 (12)
- RE: Actually... - waj4all 10:28:55 05/16/11 (7)
- Nope - E-Stat 10:59:38 05/16/11 (6)
- RE: Nope - waj4all 12:28:57 05/16/11 (5)
- Any more edits? - E-Stat 12:56:02 05/16/11 (2)
- RE: Any more edits? - waj4all 13:46:24 05/16/11 (1)
- Put the bong down... - DAVID 15:19:42 05/16/11 (0)
- Good bye. - AbeCollins 12:33:14 05/16/11 (1)
- RE: Good bye. - waj4all 13:06:43 05/16/11 (0)
- RE: Actually... - waj4all 23:21:22 05/15/11 (3)
- Confused about what? - E-Stat 06:13:36 05/16/11 (2)
- Ignore him. He's just trolling for attention... - AbeCollins 06:51:08 05/16/11 (1)
- He sure has a strange preoccupation - E-Stat 07:07:34 05/16/11 (0)