|
Audio Asylum Thread Printer Get a view of an entire thread on one page |
For Sale Ads |
107.77.194.156
In Reply to: RE: Capacitor distortion is difficult to measure. posted by sser2 on May 08, 2017 at 14:27:11
...You mention DA as a possible source of "capacitor distortion". I've wondered about this because the theoretical model of DA is relatively simple and should be very easy to simulate in spice or maybe even wire up and measure...at least at a high level. And yet, at this point I've never seen this done WRT audio apps. DA is a known issue with certain analog circuits like S&H and integrators but I'm not sure what's known transfers well to audio.
FWIW, the non-electrolytic caps that exhibit the greatest DA using my somewhat crude technique are the Russian K40s, esp after exposure to temperatures of say 150F. For this reason I've been reluctant to use them.
Follow Ups:
I think the simple part is dielectric constant ε, which is somewhat related to dielectric absorption. ε is a coefficient indicating how many times capacitance is increased by a given material compared to vacuum. Materials with high dielectric absorption usually have high ε.
Dielectric absorption and permitivity may not be easily susceptible to modeling. In the idealized situation, the relaxation time parameter is used, which is time needed for elemental dipoles of dielectric to re-orient upon instantaneous change of electric field. The assumptions are linear, homogeneous, isotropic materials with uniform response to changes in electric field. Real situation is far from these assumptions. Dielectric memory, as capacitor shorting experiment shows, persists for a very long time (seconds), indicating that relaxation times in real materials may have wide spread. Plastic films are highly anisotropic. How linear and uniform dipole response to applied electric field is, only God knows. Modeling has been successfully used to predict such gross phenomena as losses or capacitance changes with frequency (BTW, another source of capacitor non-linearity), but I doubt its usefulness in calculating distortion.
...I guess that's my point; lots of doubt and speculation regarding DA effects in audio but no actual testing or even modeling. The fact that high DA electrolytics have been (relatively) successfully employed in audio causes one to doubt its importance but doubt there is.
The high level model of DA I've seen is a network of series RC networks paralleled across the ideal C. The time constants of the networks are a range of many seconds to many tens of seconds. Even if not an entirely accurate model, it ought to useful in determining whether or not DA is indeed something of audible concern. If nothing else, it should be easy to model and examine for gross high level effects.
Perhaps the difference in capacitors is in fact measurable, but not represented as frequency response, THD or RMS intermodulation. Transient distortion in amplifiers is a neglected subject, and I am highly suspicious that it accounts for much of what we hear that is otherwise impossible to explain.
--------------------------
Buy Chinese. Bury freedom.
Alexander Pushkin, "Mozart and Salieri". One of my favorite audiophile citations.
Dielectric absorption is only one source of capacitor distortion. There are several others. One is capacitance change with frequency, and one more is capacitance change with voltage. Distortion due to capacitance change may be quite serious - any change in capacitance causes changes of voltage across the capacitor. Yet one more is capacitors acting as mechanotransducers, which I posted on a while ago. This was about capacitors acting as low quality electrostatic speakers and low quality condenser microphones at the same time.
Maybe capacitor distortion has been studied, and we just don't know? However, it seems more like there is no interest to this subject in the field of electronic engineering. We'll have to do it ourselves if we want to know. But even if we find that capacitor distortion is low, who is going to be convinced? I know from experience that some capacitors sound better than other, and avoiding capacitors in the signal path is a good practice. People whose judgment I trust preferred the sound of transformer- or direct-coupled amplifiers to that of capacitor-coupled amplifiers.
"it seems more like there is no interest to this subject in the field of electronic engineering."
I posted here on this exact subject earlier this year. We (at my day job) had just discovered that the capacitance of modern multi-layer capacitors changes markedly with voltage. So much so that the capacitors - for bypassing purposes - virtually disappear. Only a few manufacturers of these components are publishing the relevant data.
--------------------------
Buy Chinese. Bury freedom.
FAQ |
Post a Message! |
Forgot Password? |
|
||||||||||||||
|
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors: