|
Audio Asylum Thread Printer Get a view of an entire thread on one page |
For Sale Ads |
132.177.236.65
In Reply to: RE: That Was A Mistake! posted by danlaudionut on February 15, 2016 at 15:26:27
Good bit of fluff/BS in that page. Particularly about WE284 vs. RCA 845, etc. It's not like consumers used these, and the folks that did (theaters) were more concerned with lifetime and cost than anything to do with the sound per se. Not only that, but of course WE didn't sell tubes or gear to anyone, it was always leased, and only to commercial clients (e.g. theaters, broadcasters, etc.) - thus no one was really tuberolling 845s back in the 1930s and the WE 284 never "set the new standard".
there's no real "replica" going on here. they are most similar to the GE-845 internal construction more than anything else. The tipped bulb looks cool but is only for looks, not function (there's a reason they stopped making tipped bulbs for these tubes in the 1930s or so.)
I will agree that WE 284s are certainly rare (though I do have a few) but the biggest differences with the early 845s and later ones were the metal plates (and limited dissipation) vs. the later graphite plates. Even WE switched to graphite plates for some of their 284s (and other similar tubes.)
-Ed
Follow Ups:
Hey Ed,
Good info and I can't agree more that the Psvane WE845 resemble the structure of GE845 tubes more than anything internally. Interesting that they sound so different and better IMO.
I'd wish you could hear them because most here would value your opinion.
Naz
hi Naz -
Thanks, I will get some one of these days and compare to what I have on hand. It would be interesting to hear the differences, I am sure. Thanks for the kind words,
-Ed
Post a Followup:
FAQ |
Post a Message! |
Forgot Password? |
|
||||||||||||||
|
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors: