![]() ![]() |
Audio Asylum Thread Printer Get a view of an entire thread on one page |
For Sale Ads |
Looking in particular for great versions, but in particular, those which take the second movement at a slow expansive tempo and treat it as very somber, almost funereal, not as a faster adagietto as some conductors have a tendency to do. I have the great Kleiber recording of the 5th and 7th, and great as it is, it is a bit fast for my taste.
Follow Ups:
They play it as a proper allegretto.
.
Looks like Amazon has a used copy for sale.
I rather like the recording with Ernest Ansermet and the SRO, which I have on a London STS LP. Very fine sound, too.I am not at home so I can't check out the tempos, but I rather like Leibowitz, Royal Philharmonic Orchestra, which has been reissued by Chesky, coupled with a smashing 4th, too. Ansermet did a fine 4th, too.
____________________________________________________________
"Nature loves to hide."
---Heraclitus of Ephesus (trans. Wheelwright)
Just guessing from their reps and some other stuff I've heard. Have not heard their versions of this, though.A favorite of mine is the Reiner recently reissued in XRDCD. I suspect the tempo may be too brisk for you. Comparison would be to the Furtwangler on EMI. Have to round them up.
Any source on the web give timings for the movements of recordings? That would be one way to check, altho not the quality, obviously.
b
It was launched as Mono because in those days there were no stereo LPs, but later, when they went to their archives, to make a CD, they discovered it had been recorded stereo!Excellent version, and pretty good sound, too.
Regards
BF
For a slow-paced, funereal 2nd Movement, try Solti/London. For once, his laborious tempo meshes with the music. Solti's 2nd movement of the 7th is an anthem of resignation and despair.
Although I'm no fan of a lethargic second movement.You might also seek out the classic Cantelli.
clark
Are you guys talking about the earlier recording with the Vienna (on Decca classics) or the later one with the Chicago (also on Decca, i think)? Thanks.
I picked up on it when I saw "Immortal Beloved" (about Beethoven's mystery romance); had to see who did that 2nd movement for the soundtrack...it was Solti/London but Solti did the entire 7th with Chicago.
It was recorded in the 70s, and I have always enjoyed it enormously. It has been released in CD, in a budget series, some time ago.Regards
BF
For modern sound, I recommend Kurt Masur's Leipzig Gewandhaus recording for Philips (currently available as a Philips Duo set).
I'll second the Furtwangler -- he is always special in Beethoven. If you're looking for something in more modern sound, I'll recommend a sleeper. One of Ashkenazy's early successes as a conductor was his recording of the Beethoven 5th and 7th with the Philharmonia Orchestra. Unlike Furtwangler, who generally reads Beethoven in a highly Romantic fashion, Ashkenazy's approach is firmly rooted in Classicism...his readings are very "Haydnesque". Powerful, but neatly controlled and leisurely. His reading of the Allegretto in the 7th Symphony is particularly pastoral (NOT somber or funereal). Beyond the Hadynesque squareness (which to me is both appealling and fascinating), you actually hear a very direct relationship between this movement and the preceding 6th Symphony, which is somewhat unusual. Here's a link to a used copy of the CD. This combination is also available as part of a slightly cheezier "Penguin Classics" series.
As John Ardoin states in 'The Furtwangler Record'...there's evidence that Beethoven was of two minds about the tempo of the movement, vacillating between the published allegretto and a slower andante...Furtwangler adopts the later...there are several versions available and rather than bore you with specifics, recommend you get the one on EMI from 1950 with the Vienna since it's readily available...and if you respond to that you can seek out the Berlin performance from 1943...
msk
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors: