![]() ![]() |
Audio Asylum Thread Printer Get a view of an entire thread on one page |
For Sale Ads |
In Reply to: I'll second that DUI you need your hearing checked, anyone even non-audiophile's can hear the drastic difference between posted by Teresa on October 05, 2003 at 05:08:12:
SACD is a big improvement over CD, yupper. It's got a lot to do with DSD processing, because even the Cd hybrid layers sound much, much better on a standard CD player.
![]()
Follow Ups:
You have disproven your own theory. That means that DSD can be used to make a redbook that is as good, or nearly as good as the SACD. That means it IS NOT SACD that is the big improvement, in your experience, but DSD mastering. That makes my point.
![]()
....but he'll backtrack and say that although the CD layer is much, much better it's still ugly and distorted...
Best Regards,
Chris redmond.
![]()
He's a conman who is confused - get it? He's come to the right place.I agree with DUI. The DSD mastering process is a big leap forward, when used on a CD - in a truly hi-rez CD syatem - it's outstanding, and unless the DSD-CD has been sonically compromised, there's little to choose from the DSD CD and SA-CD. IMO, the DSD method accounts for more than the SA-CD format.
![]()
Robert H. nailed it. DSD shows great potential as a CD mastering medium. I could not figure out why I sometimes preferred the DSD mastered Redbook layer to the SACD layer of the same disc. This does not seem to make sense. SACD has better organic flow and better harmonic interludes, but there is something "thick" about the sound, (not in the good high resolution sense), that can bother my ears and make them ring. I do not have especially good high frequency hearing either. I have trouble listening to a SACD piece all the way through, but I can forget the equipment and listen to the music better with a DSD mastered redbook cut.
![]()
wouldn't DSD be superior in it's native format SACD rather than being compromised by being downsampled to CD?
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors: