 
|
Music Lane: RE: Sibelius Symphonies by msk58 It's all about the music, dude! Sit down, relax and listen to some tunes. |
For Sale Ads |
|
|
Music Lane: RE: Sibelius Symphonies by msk58 It's all about the music, dude! Sit down, relax and listen to some tunes. |
For Sale Ads |
76.68.82.105
In Reply to: Sibelius Symphonies posted by merlinus on December 10, 2008 at 13:05:52:
i must be a bit of a dissenter here and say that i prefer the segerstam/ondine for his organic/introspective approach over the vanska who seems to be aiming more for affect. but keep in mind these pieces have been favorites of mine for going on 30 years and my views might be different as a new(ish) listener. another recent contender and maybe better overall than either is the recent cycle by colin davis on lso live although here the sound suffers a bit because of the live barbican hall acoustics. and as someone who loves these pieces let me also add that the barbirolli cycle from the 60's on emi is a treasure...
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Topic - Sibelius Symphonies - merlinus 13:05:52 12/10/08 ( 37)
- RE: Sibelius Symphonies - msk58 12/26/08 09:38:06 12/26/08 ( 0)
Surprised I'm alone in mentioning Maazel/Vienna. Haven't heard the set on cd, but..... - Rick W 09:51:19 12/11/08 ( 22)
- Still love the VPO Maazel 4 - gd 09:05:49 12/13/08 ( 12)
- "I only wish that Szell had recorded more." - TGR 13:02:12 12/14/08 ( 6)
- FYI: There are live recordings of the 4th, 7th and En Saga w/szell - Thornhill 07:32:35 12/22/08 ( 0)
- Amen II..... - Todd Krieger 21:17:37 12/15/08 ( 4)
- I have an SACD of this - TGR 10:27:22 12/16/08 ( 3)
- how did you... - docw 12:48:38 12/17/08 ( 2)
- RE: how did you... - Todd Krieger 21:34:26 12/17/08 ( 1)
- Racozky - docw 11:58:37 12/18/08 ( 0)
RE: Still love the VPO Maazel 4 - Todd Krieger 11:07:54 12/13/08 ( 4)
- do you mean Danny Majeske, the late concertmaster? - docw 14:56:03 12/15/08 ( 1)
- RE: do you mean Danny Majeske, the late concertmaster? - Todd Krieger 21:10:13 12/15/08 ( 0)
I should have been more specific - gd 18:51:59 12/13/08 ( 1)
- He Must Have Really Mellowed....... - Todd Krieger 21:55:17 12/13/08 ( 0)
Disagree On This One...... - Todd Krieger 19:10:13 12/11/08 ( 5)
- Yeah, we sure do disagree. - Rick W 19:53:09 12/11/08 ( 4)
- RE: Yeah, we sure do disagree. - Todd Krieger 20:41:47 12/11/08 ( 3)
- RE: Yeah, we sure do disagree. - garrod 14:25:54 12/12/08 ( 1)
- RE: Yeah, we sure do disagree. - Todd Krieger 22:50:36 12/12/08 ( 0)
- I have LP's of Maazel/Cleve. playing Debussy's ..... - Rick W 21:08:07 12/11/08 ( 0)
I have it on RTR tape - TGR 13:37:29 12/11/08 ( 0)
I learned the symphonies with this set - srl1 12:14:38 12/11/08 ( 0)
The Maazel VPO set is excellent. - Pat D 12:07:26 12/11/08 ( 0)
I've heard many but not all. - jdaniel@jps.net 08:19:13 12/11/08 ( 0)
RE: Sibelius Symphonies - Logan 22:00:35 12/10/08 ( 0)
Vanska or Davis/BSO for me! (nt) - Russell 21:41:53 12/10/08 ( 0)
Segerstam (Ondine) - Thornhill 20:48:57 12/10/08 ( 0)
RE: Sibelius Symphonies - learsfool 19:15:08 12/10/08 ( 0)
There was a superb survey in Fanfare.................... - Kal Rubinson 18:47:44 12/10/08 ( 2)
- RE: There was a superb survey in Fanfare.................... - merlinus 20:19:51 12/10/08 ( 1)
- Sorry. - Kal Rubinson 06:41:31 12/11/08 ( 0)
Sir John Barbirolli - Todd Krieger 18:23:10 12/10/08 ( 0)
Both sets you mention are excellent - csofan 17:03:57 12/10/08 ( 0)
I like Vanska too. . . - Chris from Lafayette 16:58:52 12/10/08 ( 0)
I don't think anyone has topped... - M. Lucky 15:40:42 12/10/08 ( 0)
As sets go, Vanska's is hard to beat...... - Chuck Y 13:42:53 12/10/08 ( 0)
[Top of Page ] [ Contact Us ] [ Support/Wish List ] [ Copyright © 2024, Audio Asylum, all rights reserved ]
[ General ] [ Speakers ] [ Tubes ] [ Vinyl ] [ Digital ] [ Hi-Rez ] [ Video Asylum ] [ Cables ] [ Tweaks/DIY ] [ Music ] [ Films ]
