General Asylum: "Tableau", is that what you hear when you hear live acoustic music in a concert hall. by viridian

General Asylum: "Tableau", is that what you hear when you hear live acoustic music in a concert hall. by viridian

General audio topics that don't fit into specific categories.

FAQ / News / Events

"Tableau", is that what you hear when you hear live acoustic music in a concert hall.

24.20.10.236

In Reply to: assinine - Yes posted by Ferrous Oxide on November 30, 2021 at 19:28:44:

All this imaging and soundstaging mumbo jumbo is an amusical parlor trick unrelated to the concert hall experience of music. It's just like going to the Louvre and commenting on the wallpaper.

This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:

Signature Sound

[ Signature Sound Lounge ]

Topic - Youtube speaker reviews are assinine - Mike K 09:40:10 11/30/21 ( 51)

I think most of them are smart enough to understand that - Goober58 08:17:02 12/3/21 ( 0)
"Aren't YT reviewers smart enough to understand this? " - LtMandella 11:19:08 12/2/21 ( 0)
they could do everyone a big favor - Story 03:23:42 12/2/21 ( 0)
This topic has come up before - E-Stat 15:23:56 12/1/21 ( 4)
- Agree. They could be of some use, but they're not an audition. - Dave_K 08:23:54 12/2/21 ( 3)
  - RE: Agree. They could be of some use, but they're not an audition. - E-Stat 08:53:41 12/2/21 ( 2)
    - RE: Agree. They could be of some use, but they're not an audition. - audio_d 16:36:38 12/2/21 ( 1)
      - Yep - E-Stat 05:55:25 12/3/21 ( 0)
Any yet people buy based on mere written words (nt) - Dave_K 04:09:35 12/1/21 ( 7)
- RE: Any yet people buy based on mere written words (nt) - hahax@verizon.net 19:45:51 12/2/21 ( 1)
  - RE: Any yet people buy based on mere written words (nt) - RV817 21:46:42 12/2/21 ( 0)
- RE: Any yet people buy based on mere written words (nt) - hahax@verizon.net 19:45:37 12/2/21 ( 0)
- RE: Any yet people buy based on mere written words (nt) - hahax@verizon.net 19:45:25 12/2/21 ( 0)
- Those who glide on the most ethereal planes of dorkitude... - peppy m. 09:09:08 12/1/21 ( 2)
  - Hey - count me in! [nt] ;-) - Chris from Lafayette 12:04:55 12/1/21 ( 1)
    - OK, if you insist. (nt - peppy m. 15:59:11 12/1/21 ( 0)
assinine - Yes - Ferrous Oxide 19:28:44 11/30/21 ( 18)
- Generation and Exposure to Live Music/Great Recordings.......... - Todd Krieger 03:03:34 12/1/21 ( 0)
- "Tableau", is that what you hear when you hear live acoustic music in a concert hall. - viridian 11/30/21 20:13:49 11/30/21 ( 16)
  - IMO that is a very interesting topic - Analog Scott 17:55:47 12/2/21 ( 2)
    - RE: IMO that is a very interesting topic - Cpwill 10:03:56 12/3/21 ( 1)
      - I would go so far as to say - Analog Scott 17:01:26 12/3/21 ( 0)
  - RE: "Tableau", is that what you hear when you hear live acoustic music in a concert hall. - dee eye why 08:27:04 12/2/21 ( 0)
  - *Rolling eyes* - Jack G 05:24:02 12/1/21 ( 4)
    - Why "live music" is not a reference - Analog Scott 07:38:45 12/3/21 ( 3)
      - RE: Why "live music" is not a reference - Tre' 07:51:49 12/3/21 ( 2)
        
        Great sounding record - Analog Scott 16:40:47 12/3/21 ( 1)
        
        RE: Great sounding record - Tre' 18:02:39 12/5/21 ( 0)
  - RE: "Tableau", is that what you hear when you hear live acoustic music in a concert hall. - Todd Krieger 02:46:29 12/1/21 ( 4)
    - RE: "Tableau", is that what you hear when you hear live acoustic music in a concert hall. - Cpwill 09:27:41 12/3/21 ( 2)
      - RE: "Tableau", is that what you hear when you hear live acoustic music in a concert hall. - Todd Krieger 10:50:24 12/3/21 ( 1)
        
        RE: "Tableau", is that what you hear when you hear live acoustic music in a concert hall. - Cpwill 10:53:03 12/3/21 ( 0)
    - "The objective to "soundstage" is to create the illusion of "seventh row center" in the concert hall...." - Analog Scott 18:00:13 12/2/21 ( 0)
  - RE: "Tableau", is that what you hear when you hear live acoustic music in a concert hall. - Story 02:31:27 12/1/21 ( 0)
  - RE: "Tableau", is that what you hear when you hear live acoustic music in a concert hall. - RGA 23:06:55 11/30/21 ( 0)
RE: Youtube speaker reviews are assinine - hahax@verizon.net 19:27:26 11/30/21 ( 0)
Yup, better to read a written review and decide that way. nt - viridian 17:17:24 11/30/21 ( 1)
- RE: Yup, better to read a written review and decide that way. nt - Amos Burton 17:33:56 11/30/21 ( 0)
Not just speaker reviews... - audio_d 14:22:45 11/30/21 ( 0)
Due to Demise of brick & mortar Audio stores - Jon L 12:49:51 11/30/21 ( 3)
- RE: Due to Demise of brick & mortar Audio stores - Cpwill 10:15:33 12/3/21 ( 0)
- I auditioned everything I bought off Audiogon - ArdRi 06:00:47 12/1/21 ( 0)
- RE: Due to Demise of brick & mortar Audio stores - Todd Krieger 13:34:29 11/30/21 ( 0)
RE: Youtube speaker reviews are assinine - Todd Krieger 12:26:43 11/30/21 ( 0)
A useful comparison can be made - Craiger56 12:25:20 11/30/21 ( 2)
- I prefer the Martin Logan speakers in the comparison - Goober58 08:45:09 12/3/21 ( 0)
- TOTAL agreement. - David S. 09:33:04 12/1/21 ( 0)
RE: Youtube speaker reviews are assinine - AbeCollins 11:14:21 11/30/21 ( 1)
- RE: Youtube speaker reviews are assinine - dbphd 12:35:53 11/30/21 ( 0)
RE: Youtube speaker reviews are assinine - neolith 09:44:27 11/30/21 ( 1)
- True enough * - Mike K 10:13:35 11/30/21 ( 0)