|
DVD-Audiobahn: Re: The technical discussion is contained in the papers. .. by Plush New DVD-Audio music releases and talk about the latest players. |
For Sale Ads |
12.249.171.69
In Reply to: Yep, maybe he's one of those...he certainly seems to have forgotten the spirit... posted by Methos on February 24, 2003 at 13:03:57:
and Vanderkooy and Lipshitz are unrefuted. Besides the fact that the Reefman paper comes from Philips itself and IS NOT from the developers but instead from the public relations dept. After the third paper by Vanderkooy and Lipshitz, Dr. Vanderkooy was hired by Philips to sort out the mess with their DSD stream. Did you know that? Why would they hire your "know-nothing" if he didn't have a clue? Please be fluent with the technical language before you repeat a press release from Philips in your attempt to discredit criticism of 1 bit encoding. DSD is dead in the water in recording circles and this explains why releases of *NEW* material are slow.
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Topic - Warner considering 192/24 stereo-only releases? This and more in exciting Home Theater Mag article - DVDAphile 16:30:55 02/22/03 ( 68)
- Curtis Mayfield's 'Superfly' 24/192 stereo only? - Frank 04:49:14 02/23/03 ( 0)
Re: Warner considering 192/24 stereo-only releases? This and more in exciting Home Theater Mag artic - Chris Garrett 20:06:59 02/22/03 ( 66)
- Chris, you're a dick - Plush 11:40:24 02/24/03 ( 0)
Re: Warner considering 192/24 stereo-only releases? This and more in exciting Home Theater Mag artic - fmak 09:44:53 02/23/03 ( 0)
Re: Warner considering 192/24 stereo-only releases? This and more in exciting Home Theater Mag artic - John Kotches 21:27:40 02/22/03 ( 63)
- I don't know........... - Chris Garrett 22:10:54 02/22/03 ( 62)
- Re: I don't know........... - John Kotches 09:22:10 02/23/03 ( 1)
- John is 100% right. When stereo only is desired, this is appropriate. (nt) - Maven 10:29:04 02/24/03 ( 0)
- Re: I don't know........... - gw 00:54:21 02/23/03 ( 56)
- Hmmmm.... - Chris Garrett 09:41:22 02/23/03 ( 55)
- Chris, Sony is overcharging you for 5.1 Mch SACDs. Your DVD-A pricing argument is incredibly weak... - ZS KEKL 00:26:06 02/24/03 ( 6)
- Is everybody deaf here? - Chris Garrett 06:28:29 02/24/03 ( 5)
- Nope, - Frank 06:50:00 02/24/03 ( 3)
- Frank, what titles can you pick up at those prices? - Eric LeRouge 13:37:15 02/24/03 ( 2)
- I meant... - Frank 00:38:04 02/25/03 ( 1)
- Makes sense (nt) - Eric LeRouge 02:15:41 02/25/03 ( 0)
- Re: Apparently you are. - John Kotches 06:34:42 02/24/03 ( 0)
- Re: Hmmmm.... - John Kotches 15:32:25 02/23/03 ( 43)
- Re artists wishes etc - groovenoter 07:56:14 02/24/03 ( 2)
- Sir, smoking opiates is not allowed on the Audiobahn. Your license, please. n/t - DVDAphile 14:06:11 02/24/03 ( 0)
- Re: Re artists wishes etc - John Kotches 10:04:17 02/24/03 ( 0)
quite a diatribe... - tunenut 17:59:59 02/23/03 ( 0)
"it is shown to be horribly flawed by two of the leading experts on digital audio on the planet." - Methos 17:31:12 02/23/03 ( 28)
- Methos, you have absolutely no idea - Plush 11:48:39 02/24/03 ( 10)
- What sort of 'scientist' are you, sir?? Your rant is totally lacking for scientific reasoning. - Methos 12:37:12 02/24/03 ( 9)
- Never heard of so called 'mad scientists'... - Frank 12:51:29 02/24/03 ( 8)
- Methos, did you get a chance - Eric LeRouge 14:24:23 02/24/03 ( 2)
- You're right, I was thinking of trying Richard Kern's latest mods... - Methos 14:31:57 02/24/03 ( 1)
- OK, I think we can wait a few more days (nt :) - Eric LeRouge 15:00:20 02/24/03 ( 0)
- Yep, maybe he's one of those...he certainly seems to have forgotten the spirit... - Methos 13:03:57 02/24/03 ( 4)
- Re: The technical discussion is contained in the papers. .. - Plush 02/25/03 09:39:56 02/25/03 ( 3)
- I never described Vanderkooy as a 'know-nothing', where did I do so? - Methos 14:47:33 02/26/03 ( 2)
- hit the nail on the head... - tunenut 15:22:46 02/26/03 ( 1)
- Thanks for the article, tunenut...I'll either read it tonight, or do the Diana Krall redbook/SACD.. - Methos 19:21:55 02/26/03 ( 0)
Re: "it is shown to be horribly flawed by two of the leading experts on digital audio on the planet. - John Kotches 19:11:46 02/23/03 ( 16)
- Then may I refer you to the paper by Derk Reefman & Peter Nuijten... - Methos 19:39:56 02/23/03 ( 14)
- Re: Guess you missed Preprint #5620 from the 112th convention - John Kotches 06:57:04 02/24/03 ( 7)
- not greatly relevant - tunenut 10:26:45 02/24/03 ( 0)
- If you read the paper I mentioned, you know that Sony/Philips doesn't rely on self-dithering or... - Methos 08:19:36 02/24/03 ( 5)
- Re: If you read the paper I mentioned, you know that Sony/Philips doesn't rely on self-dithering or. - John Kotches 10:26:03 02/24/03 ( 4)
- nitpicking maybe... - tunenut 10:46:32 02/24/03 ( 3)
- Re: nitpicking maybe... - Frank 12:00:39 02/24/03 ( 2)
- Re: you have absolutely no idea what you're talking about - Plush 12:10:46 02/24/03 ( 1)
- thank you, Plush, on this one I agree with you (NT) - tunenut 12:47:07 02/24/03 ( 0)
Carrefully constructed sentence... - Frank 06:01:29 02/24/03 ( 3)
- Re: Carrefully constructed sentence... - tunenut 10:32:08 02/24/03 ( 2)
- Re: Carrefully constructed sentence... - Frank 11:49:57 02/24/03 ( 0)
- Re: Carrefully constructed sentence... - Frank 11:28:38 02/24/03 ( 0)
Re: Then may I refer you to the paper by Derk Reefman & Peter Nuijten... - John Kotches 21:32:01 02/23/03 ( 1)
- Your "leading experts" did, all through their paper. That was their main claim, that 1-bit systems - Methos 08:38:07 02/24/03 ( 0)
See my post directly below. nt - Methos 19:15:32 02/23/03 ( 0)
"Ignore the fundamental flaws in 1-bit encoding"... - Methos 17:22:21 02/23/03 ( 6)
- Re: "Ignore the fundamental flaws in 1-bit encoding"... - John Kotches 19:19:02 02/23/03 ( 5)
- ...and your boys, Vanderkooy and Lipshitz (!) are convinced the 1-bit variety are the naughty bits. - Methos 21:08:04 02/23/03 ( 4)
- I'm glad I bookmarked this site: - HiFi Connasewer 21:19:54 02/23/03 ( 3)
- Nice try, sewer guy! - Methos 08:41:50 02/24/03 ( 2)
- Re: Nice try, sewer guy! - John Kotches 10:28:45 02/24/03 ( 1)
- 80/20. : ) nt - Methos 10:45:09 02/24/03 ( 0)
I don't know John...... - Chris Garrett 16:20:58 02/23/03 ( 2)
- Re: Koopman & "fold-downs" . . . - Martin says 04:59:24 02/24/03 ( 0)
Re: I don't know John...... - John Kotches 19:17:38 02/23/03 ( 0)
Re: Hmmmm.... - gw 11:35:00 02/23/03 ( 3)
- How many DVDAs do you have? - Chris Garrett 12:06:20 02/23/03 ( 2)
- Re: I think right around 20 - gw 13:30:32 02/23/03 ( 1)
- Re: I think right around 20 - Chris Garrett 14:27:34 02/23/03 ( 0)
Dvda's unpredictability is what makes it FUN! "Foolish consistency is the hobgoblin of little minds" - HiFi Connasewer 23:22:47 02/22/03 ( 2)
- the quote originally comes from RW Emerson (NT) - tunenut 17:55:31 02/23/03 ( 1)
- I didn't know Babs was into stuff like that! - HiFi Connasewer 21:24:43 02/23/03 ( 0)