|
Classical Court: RE: A bit like J-Fi? by Todd Krieger From Perotin to Prokofiev (and beyond), performed by Caruso to Khatia, it's all here. |
For Sale Ads |
192.145.119.64
In Reply to: A bit like J-Fi? posted by Chris from Lafayette on January 23, 2022 at 12:04:11:
"However, the only trouble with those overdubbed performances (in general) is that the possibility for spontaneity is greatly reduced, as whatever part was recorded second is in a bit of a "musical straightjacket" since it must conform to whatever interpretive decisions were made in the part which was recorded first."
I'd be shocked if she did the violin first..... It's much easier to play the solo to the accompaniment than the accompaniment to the solo.....
You do have a point with the "spontaneity"..... It's hard to guess how the violinist would attack the solo, even if it's the same person that's playing the piano..... She may have had to go through it several times to get the timing to her liking.
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Topic - Samira Spiegel, unusual talent - rkw 01:56:36 01/23/22 ( 8)
- A Heifetz pep talk - John Marks 04:43:46 01/24/22 ( 2)
- to quote Rocca DeLuca - Analog Scott 12:28:38 01/24/22 ( 0)
- "Honey, quick,! can you bring me a damp towel, I just spat juice all over the keyboard and screen!" nt - tinear 06:31:16 01/24/22 ( 0)
Jeez....... - Todd Krieger 20:32:08 01/23/22 ( 0)
A bit like J-Fi? - Chris from Lafayette 12:04:11 01/23/22 ( 3)
- RE: A bit like J-Fi? - Todd Krieger 01/23/22 20:38:34 01/23/22 ( 0)
Heifetz? - John Marks 18:17:45 01/23/22 ( 1)
- Yes - I think you're right that it was Heifetz - Chris from Lafayette 00:54:05 01/24/22 ( 0)