In Reply to: Re: Why such negative vibes on B&W's posted by ariaslives on July 23, 2002 at 11:07:21:
The criteria, with which we evaluate loudspeakers, is not as subjective as it might seem. A great speaker sounds like...music. If you can close your eyes and be transported...to symphony hall, to a rock concert...these are the hallmarks of a great speaker. I don't think that B&W have any "great" models right now. Looking objectively...they are voicing for what sells...a very flashy, hi-fi sound. Furthermore, gimmicks really sell (nautilus tweeters, kevlar cones, flowports etc.) so B&W incorporate as many as possible into their designs. This market driven emphasis is a classic sign that a company that has grown too large. A speaker company this large and sophisticated could voice for musical realism if they wanted to. B&W needs to get back to the basics and concentrate on putting out a quality product. If they spent as much time perfecting off-axis response and smooth power response as on-axis response, B&W would have a better product. I greatly respect B&W, but success can be deadly to a companies health.
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Follow Ups
- Disagree - layman 13:05:01 07/23/02 (23)
- Agreed - Nightfly! 15:02:18 07/23/02 (1)
- Your right nightfly.... - tunz 03:09:46 07/25/02 (0)
- Re: Disagree - ariaslives 13:26:15 07/23/02 (0)
- Re: Disagree - JeffMO 13:19:35 07/23/02 (13)
- Re: Disagree - musicluver 14:54:44 07/23/02 (2)
- Re: Disagree - JeffMO 15:55:34 07/23/02 (1)
- Re: Disagree - musicluver 14:09:10 07/24/02 (0)
- Identity Crisis - layman 14:46:40 07/23/02 (5)
- Off-axis response - grblgrbl 06:58:22 07/24/02 (4)
- Re: Off-axis response - layman 13:58:01 07/24/02 (3)
- Re: Off-axis response - grblgrbl 09:18:45 07/25/02 (2)
- Re: Off-axis response - layman 13:02:43 07/25/02 (1)
- You are a marvelous wonder among lesser beings - grblgrbl 07:09:43 07/29/02 (0)
- The reason the off-axis response matters... - Duke 14:44:52 07/23/02 (3)
- Re: The reason the off-axis response matters... - musicluver 15:02:24 07/23/02 (2)
- Musicluver - - Duke 15:54:55 07/23/02 (1)
- Re: Musicluver - - musicluver 17:15:55 07/23/02 (0)
- How is that not subjective - grblgrbl 13:13:56 07/23/02 (5)
- Pointless - layman 14:11:16 07/23/02 (4)
- It's not an objective standard though - grblgrbl 14:25:33 07/23/02 (3)
- Re: It's not an objective standard though - fredgarvin 17:13:51 07/23/02 (1)
- Re: It's not an objective standard though - grblgrbl 05:26:38 07/24/02 (0)
- I could not disagree more - layman 14:49:36 07/23/02 (0)