If one is saying that HIP "ruined" Classical Music, should one's claims be accurate across the board?

Follow Ups Full Thread

Topic - Recommendations wanted: Haydn Violin Concerto in C Major - jec01 08:01:22 01/26/17 (38)

btw sorry jec, for ruining your post, my first reply was suppose to be a passing joke. Nt - jdaniel@jps.net 12:04:26 01/27/17 (1)

It's my own fault - jec01 12:26:38 01/27/17 (0)

Chris recommended this one to me - jdaniel@jps.net 08:27:29 01/26/17 (35)

But for my REAL recommendation (and something more up to date). . . - Chris from Lafayette 09:52:28 01/26/17 (34)

Zukerman/Haydn - Doktor Brahms 08:31:06 01/27/17 (9)

Yeah - I remember that Fanfare interview, but. . . - Chris from Lafayette 10:27:16 01/27/17 (0)

What did Zuckerman say that was/is accurate in every case? Nt - jdaniel@jps.net 09:16:04 01/27/17 (7)

Geez - it's as if you're taking his comments as personal insults [nt] ;-) - Chris from Lafayette 10:17:47 01/27/17 (6)

Really? I guess I need to do happy faces more, just passing time . You're welcome to answer the question t - jdaniel@jps.net 10:47:52 01/27/17 (5)

Really? What did ANYONE say that was/is accurate in every case? - Chris from Lafayette 11:01:34 01/27/17 (4)

If one is saying that HIP "ruined" Classical Music, should one's claims be accurate across the board? - jdaniel@jps.net 11:18:07 01/27/17 (3)

But he's right! HIP HAS ruined classical music! ;-) - Chris from Lafayette 15:19:52 01/27/17 (1)

Be nice, I can't guarantee that I'll maintain a firm grip on my 64oz Slurpee at Davies in May.... - jdaniel@jps.net 15:53:20 01/27/17 (0)

I'm with you on this one, except for the viagra. - rbolaw 13:18:37 01/27/17 (0)

And how many of Zuckerman's lps are $$collectable? (I'd want to blame someone else for ruining CM to!) : ) - jdaniel@jps.net 10:09:06 01/26/17 (19)

Gee - I'm beginning to admire my own restraint - here's more from Zukerman - Chris from Lafayette 10:40:54 01/26/17 (0)

Dunno, jdaniel - I see one place is selling his Haydn album for $74 - Chris from Lafayette 10:30:51 01/26/17 (17)

Zuckeman doesn't have a cult following and I think it's bothering him? Ruining Classical music? Ridiculous! Nt - jdaniel@jps.net 10:48:23 01/26/17 (13)

I like his other comment better - Chris from Lafayette 11:05:52 01/26/17 (12)

And if only Society knew better, Zuckerman would be a superstar, right? And not Ethel Merrz to Stern's Fred. - jdaniel@jps.net 12:02:20 01/26/17 (11)

Ooh! So was Stern a big proponent of HIP? I never knew! - Chris from Lafayette 12:14:43 01/26/17 (10)

No, he's a fellow has-been but I've got to give him credit for not blaming HIPsters for stealing the spotlight - jdaniel@jps.net 12:29:41 01/26/17 (9)

Jeez - Zukerman's had a career for 50 years - we should all be so lucky! ;-) - Chris from Lafayette 14:51:00 01/26/17 (8)

No doubt, I'm a never-was. But still: he sounds like he's ready to designate HIP as "En-TART-tet Musik," - jdaniel@jps.net 19:02:39 01/26/17 (6)

Take a look at Zukerman's discography - rbolaw 06:28:46 01/27/17 (5)

Thanks, I grew up on modern-peformance Baroque. Found a massive 20 lp set of Marriner's Philips Vivaldi once. - jdaniel@jps.net 07:18:02 01/27/17 (4)

RE: Thanks, I grew up on modern-peformance Baroque. Found a massive 20 lp set of Marriner's Philips Vivaldi once. - Old Listener 09:25:21 01/27/17 (2)

"Chris's periodic rants: He needs a new speech" - Chris from Lafayette 10:22:16 01/27/17 (1)

" ... such as babe pianists and babe violinists" - rbolaw 12:51:42 01/27/17 (0)

RE: Thanks, I grew up on modern-peformance Baroque. Found a massive 20 lp set of Marriner's Philips Vivaldi once. - rbolaw 09:23:38 01/27/17 (0)

BTW, if Zukerman LPs sold for high prices - rbolaw 15:13:43 01/26/17 (0)

RE: Dunno, jdaniel - I see one place is selling his Haydn album for $74 - jec01 10:47:52 01/26/17 (2)

The one Chris mentioned is factory sealed; the others run $3.99. Nt - jdaniel@jps.net 12:06:53 01/26/17 (1)

Bummer - jec01 12:30:39 01/26/17 (0)

Love the comment about digital - TGR 09:59:49 01/26/17 (3)

I took his comment to mean that digital IMPROVED the HIP sound compared to live [nt] - Chris from Lafayette 10:05:24 01/26/17 (2)

Are they using 'Auto-Tune'' when they digitally record? - Ivan303 18:52:41 01/26/17 (1)

I never thought of that, but now that you mention it. . . [nt] ;-) - Chris from Lafayette 19:32:31 01/26/17 (0)

Follow Ups

If one is saying that HIP "ruined" Classical Music, should one's claims be accurate across the board? - jdaniel@jps.net 11:18:07 01/27/17 (3)

But he's right! HIP HAS ruined classical music! ;-) - Chris from Lafayette 15:19:52 01/27/17 (1)

Be nice, I can't guarantee that I'll maintain a firm grip on my 64oz Slurpee at Davies in May.... - jdaniel@jps.net 15:53:20 01/27/17 (0)

I'm with you on this one, except for the viagra. - rbolaw 13:18:37 01/27/17 (0)

Post a Message!