In Reply to: RE: Question posted by frogman on April 20, 2014 at 17:26:44:
True - there's no question that artistic license is involved. I guess it's up to individual listeners and musicians to decide whether such doublings are excessive - perhaps on a case by case basis.
The story I always like is that in one of the Vaughan Williams symphonies, one of the wind parts is buried by the strings in one section. One conductor (Boult?) was worried about this and asked RVW what should be done so that the wind part could be heard. Vaughan Williams replied that he didn't WANT the wind player to be heard in that place - he only wrote that part in so that the player could "warm up" a bit before his solo a few measures later! ;-)
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Follow Ups
- RE: Question - Chris from Lafayette 00:00:19 04/21/14 (4)
- RE:"he only wrote that part in so that the player could "warm up" a bit before his solo a few measures later." - Ivan303 08:32:58 04/22/14 (0)
- RE: Question - frogman 05:48:33 04/21/14 (2)
- You too could have gotten OJ off! Nice, informative exchange, the both of yas. nt - tinear 08:18:45 04/22/14 (1)
- RE: You too could have gotten OJ off! Nice, informative exchange, the both of yas. nt - frogman 05:07:26 04/23/14 (0)