I pick up $3 cd's from one of the LA shops monthly and then browse their LP's.
Last week, I got a copy of the Schumann 3rd symphony with LA Phil and Giulini, coupled w Manfred. I grew up on Szell and Karajan. What other performances do you like?
I liked the LA Phil performance except for a few parts where Carlo slurred passages and phrasings intentionally.
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Topic - Schumann Rhenish - docw 13:06:54 09/16/11 (37)
- RE: Schumann Rhenish - Hi-Fidelity 18:35:51 09/21/11 (1)
- RE: Schumann Rhenish - docw 10:48:51 09/22/11 (0)
- RE: Schumann Rhenish - Pat D 13:28:13 09/19/11 (0)
- RE: Schumann Rhenish - Todd Krieger 19:44:36 09/17/11 (3)
- Schumann difficult - layman 07:38:19 09/19/11 (2)
- Just ordered the Beermann set - Chris from Lafayette 18:37:52 09/19/11 (1)
- RE: Just ordered the Beermann set - layman 18:51:21 09/19/11 (0)
- RE: Schumann Rhenish - Cherrell 07:51:19 09/17/11 (2)
- RE: Schumann Rhenish - learsfool 21:26:00 09/18/11 (0)
- Konzertstück for 4 Horns - Yes, such a great piece! [nt] - Chris from Lafayette 15:37:24 09/17/11 (0)
- RE: Schumann Rhenish: Sawallisch - garf 07:21:24 09/17/11 (1)
- RE: Schumann Rhenish: Sawallisch - jazz1 07:40:26 09/18/11 (0)
- Barenboim, believe it or not - Paul_A 16:29:36 09/16/11 (19)
- RE: Barenboim, believe it or not - docw 17:36:14 09/16/11 (18)
- Haven't heard Barenboim. . . - Chris from Lafayette 20:50:22 09/16/11 (16)
- HCP - srl1 07:30:13 09/17/11 (1)
- LOL! - Yes, I know. It's a slippery slope! [nt] ;-) - Chris from Lafayette 15:30:56 09/17/11 (0)
- Giulini, Philharmonia, as arranged by Mahler - vinyl phanatic 22:24:43 09/16/11 (7)
- I think he refers to the later release with LA Phil... - kuma 23:24:25 09/16/11 (6)
- RE: I think he refers to the later release with LA Phil... - Chris from Lafayette 15:44:17 09/17/11 (2)
- My bad, I was referring to the original poster.(nt) - kuma 16:09:53 09/17/11 (1)
- Oops! Maybe it's MY bad - I misunderstood [nt] - Chris from Lafayette 19:26:03 09/17/11 (0)
- more info - vinyl phanatic 10:07:13 09/17/11 (2)
- Yes. My Angel reissue reocrd is a Mahler version... - kuma 11:37:48 09/17/11 (1)
- question - vinyl phanatic 06:13:02 09/19/11 (0)
- I think I would have warmed up to Mahler's hubris when it came to scores. - Paul_A 21:17:56 09/16/11 (5)
- You know, it's funny. . . - Chris from Lafayette 21:42:48 09/16/11 (4)
- RE: You know, it's funny. . . - ahendler 09:11:15 09/17/11 (2)
- Earl Wild's "A Walk on the Wild Side" - Chris from Lafayette 15:28:08 09/17/11 (1)
- RE: Earl Wild's "A Walk on the Wild Side" - ahendler 17:15:09 09/17/11 (0)
- Well I'm generally with you on Barenboim. - Paul_A 04:49:26 09/17/11 (0)
- If you have to ask... - Paul_A 17:47:19 09/16/11 (0)
- RE: Schumann Rhenish - suretyguy 15:10:20 09/16/11 (0)
- RE: Schumann Rhenish - Chuck Y 13:31:40 09/16/11 (3)
- RE: Schumann Rhenish - Daverz 14:42:50 09/16/11 (2)
- RE: Schumann Rhenish - Chuck Y 16:48:38 09/16/11 (1)
- "His Schumann emphasizes rhythm and gives it a toe tapping effect." Yep, ditto for his NYP Schumann. nt - Rick W 22:20:56 09/16/11 (0)