In Reply to: Beethoven: 9 Symphonies Best Box Set posted by PhillyB on April 7, 2007 at 11:13:00:
I have been listening a lot lately to the Vienna Philharmonica/Leonard Bernstein set, and find an awful lot to like (it also can be had quite cheaply)
Klemperer remains a big favorite (not to everyone's tastes) and some performances of Gunter Wand are superb (in the same sense as Klemperer, and I guess not as "stodgy" ).
I listen a lot to Schuricht, although my set is on vinyl, and I am not sure there is a CD set available.
Bruno Walter is wonderful for the even numbered symphonies, but I feel he falls on 3,5, and 9. Since many who would buy a box set really want good peformances of these, its hard to recommend him.
Szell is excellent, and one I rate very highly.
I've not forgotten Furtwangler, and have many individual performances that I love, but its not an everyday set for me. I have to be in the right mood.
I haven't heard most of the recent sets and original instrument influenced recordings so I can't comment. I have gotten one of Vanska's latest, which I like, but that is a cycle still in progress. I confess to a major prejudice against Harnoncourt, and if you did get Harnoncourt, get something else as well.
If I was constrained to choose one or two, I would opt for Szell, then Bernstein. I would hate to relinquish some of my other favorites though.
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Follow Ups
- Re: Beethoven: 9 Symphonies Best Box Set - John N 13:43:05 04/07/07 (6)
- I like above opinions, but tell us more clearly why... - docw 08:53:02 04/08/07 (5)
- Why I like Lenny and not Nick... - John N 08:44:45 04/09/07 (4)
- Re: Why I like Lenny and not Nick... - Brian Cheney 14:58:30 04/09/07 (0)
- Very understandable to me - docw 09:47:31 04/09/07 (2)
- Beethoven's third is the hardest one for me... - John N 09:58:23 04/09/07 (1)
- my response on Eroica was incomplete - docw 10:10:21 04/09/07 (0)