So you'd also say there should be no such thing as an all-Asian orchestra either? Or all-Indonesian? - clarkjohnsen

Follow Ups Full Thread

Topic - Music and Ideology,Philosophy and or Politics - ArdRi 17:42:06 01/17/07 (54)

Intentions and Analysis - MylesJ 17:34:05 01/22/07 (0)

Let me see if I've got this rightâ€¦ - David Aiken 21:25:41 01/21/07 (10)

If you really want to get it right - ArdRi 22:18:11 01/21/07 (9)

Re: If you really want to get it right - David Aiken 12:39:07 01/22/07 (0)

Don't bother replying to that SE fellow (below). Clearly - bjh 08:34:11 01/22/07 (6)

Thanks,It should be clear enough - ArdRi 11:37:04 01/22/07 (3)

Yes, it is a "perspective of the observer"... - SE 14:10:27 01/22/07 (2)

I was just wondering if anyone else ever - ArdRi 14:29:14 01/22/07 (1)

Understood. Learning is a good thing... - SE 15:08:58 01/22/07 (0)

So...you attack me... - SE 10:02:19 01/22/07 (0)

Comprehend this.... - SE 09:20:12 01/22/07 (0)

Just don't start taking the "moral high ground" ArdRi... - SE 05:18:53 01/22/07 (0)

Separation of Church, State, and Music...... - Todd Krieger 15:55:39 01/21/07 (0)

I guess that Charles Manson record is out of the question - tunenut 06:51:36 01/20/07 (0)

Have you considered paying a visit to a decent shrink? That might open you to life, and itÂ´s worth the pains... (nt) - orejones 02:47:05 01/20/07 (1)

I would be more concerned for my sanity if - ArdRi 10:17:31 01/20/07 (0)

Where Music Comes from is Not Where it is. - Bob Neill 15:59:37 01/19/07 (0)

but could one be indoctrinated by Brainin via his playing of a Beethoven String Quartet? - jdaniel 08:42:13 01/19/07 (1)

Yes -- indoctrinated into good taste, tho' with perhaps a touch too much vibrato. nt - clarkjohnsen 10:00:10 01/20/07 (0)

Only with Karajan. - sjb 19:00:41 01/18/07 (0)

Yes, I was there. - edta 18:05:33 01/18/07 (0)

One thing that springs to mind - kavakidd 14:24:18 01/18/07 (5)

Well Wagner lived in the period after - bjh 18:00:38 01/18/07 (2)

It has been said The Nazi's embraced his work - ArdRi 19:07:58 01/18/07 (1)

Re: It has been said The Nazi's embraced his work - bjh 20:55:06 01/18/07 (0)

It's also like Jews boycotting all Mel Gibson films. nt - clarkjohnsen 15:56:18 01/18/07 (1)

-or the country music folks boycotting the Dixie Chicks [nt] - Chris from Lafayette 17:29:57 01/19/07 (0)

The past is past, but the present .... - Amphissa 13:28:07 01/18/07 (8)

So you'd also say there should be no such thing as an all-Asian orchestra either? Or all-Indonesian? - clarkjohnsen 13:39:56 01/18/07 (7)

Huh? - Amphissa 14:33:59 01/18/07 (6)

Hey, you were talking orchestras -- and the gamelan is a real type. - clarkjohnsen 14:40:46 01/18/07 (5)

Re: Hey, you were talking orchestras -- and the gamelan is a real type. - Amphissa 16:12:09 01/18/07 (4)

"So, you are of the opinion that the music hall should turn away women and non-whites?" You miss the drift. - clarkjohnsen 16:32:30 01/18/07 (3)

differences - Amphissa 08:12:47 01/19/07 (0)

"step in and break up the club"... - SE 07:08:39 01/19/07 (0)

The issue was whether the alleged immorality of an artist should - tinear 04:58:38 01/19/07 (0)

That's the trouble with this kind of thinking... - M. Lucky 11:07:22 01/18/07 (1)

I agree with you - Bob Smith 15:11:11 01/18/07 (0)

I don't have to be a Lutheran to love a Bach Cantata! nt - risabet 09:57:02 01/18/07 (0)

You could let that kind of thing get in the way of the art... - SE 04:10:15 01/18/07 (2)

Re: You could let that kind of thing get in the way of the art... - ArdRi 07:57:48 01/18/07 (1)

That's different. Just don't listen to the ones you don't like... - SE 08:01:04 01/18/07 (0)

"I learned Norbert Brainin seems to have considered Lyndon LaRouche a close friend." Quelle horreur! - clarkjohnsen 00:36:18 01/18/07 (8)

I sincerely endeavored to not be pejorative - ArdRi 08:11:51 01/18/07 (6)

Oh. Coulda fooled me! In fact, you did. - clarkjohnsen 11:13:06 01/18/07 (5)

The thing that got me about the Amadeus - ArdRi 13:50:51 01/18/07 (4)

More: "Fight for the 'Low Tuning'" - clarkjohnsen 16:37:41 01/18/07 (3)

Whatever "extraordinary success " means. This low tuning is used widely today? n/t - SE 05:24:38 01/20/07 (2)

In Italy, if you use "high pitch", you go to jail, - tunenut 06:48:38 01/20/07 (1)

Well...they're a little high strung about low pitch (if you ask me):-) n/t - SE 05:38:25 01/21/07 (0)

Or, you can try this thoroughly repugnant meditation on "the oligarchical model", reason enough to reject the Amadeus. - clarkjohnsen 01:13:36 01/18/07 (0)

Those multiplying knowledge are multiplying sorrow, said Ecclesiast. - sser2 18:58:39 01/17/07 (2)

Voltaire who did not believe in God. - Penguin 19:15:39 01/19/07 (0)

Oh, that's good! Several errors, but in the spirit of things. nt - clarkjohnsen 00:11:39 01/18/07 (0)

Follow Ups

So you'd also say there should be no such thing as an all-Asian orchestra either? Or all-Indonesian? - clarkjohnsen 13:39:56 01/18/07 (7)

Huh? - Amphissa 14:33:59 01/18/07 (6)

Hey, you were talking orchestras -- and the gamelan is a real type. - clarkjohnsen 14:40:46 01/18/07 (5)

Re: Hey, you were talking orchestras -- and the gamelan is a real type. - Amphissa 16:12:09 01/18/07 (4)

"So, you are of the opinion that the music hall should turn away women and non-whites?" You miss the drift. - clarkjohnsen 16:32:30 01/18/07 (3)

differences - Amphissa 08:12:47 01/19/07 (0)

"step in and break up the club"... - SE 07:08:39 01/19/07 (0)

The issue was whether the alleged immorality of an artist should - tinear 04:58:38 01/19/07 (0)