Classical Court From Perotin to Prokofiev (and beyond), performed by Caruso to Khatia, it's all here. |
|
In Reply to: I couldn't tell one from the other posted by Analog Scott on September 6, 2021 at 19:26:40:
I told people not to post on AA disclosing which was which, and won't disclose that until a later time..... Unless you personally would want to know right now.
I know about 15 people who sampled the tracks, split about half choosing the correct tracks and half unable to notice the difference..... And only one chose the incorrect tracks.
Just out of curiosity, you stated that both tracks "sounded like crap".... What exactly did you find objectionable? (I often don't hear things that others hear, the learning experience goes both ways. The YouTube transcription of a studio recording of course lost some resolution, but I otherwise didn't notice anything objectionable, aside from the Auto-Tune on one of the tracks.) I would also be curious if you thought one track sounded better than the other..... (None of the roughly 15 individuals made any comments to me about the tracks' sound quality.)
This issue isn't whether or not an individual notices the Auto-Tune on a given track..... The issue is that some people do notice it, and this should not be discounted by recording engineers and producers.
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Follow Ups
- Fair Enough..... - Todd Krieger 21:54:57 09/06/21 (25)
- I will give it another go - Analog Scott 09:55:44 09/07/21 (24)
- RE: I will give it another go - Todd Krieger 15:38:22 09/07/21 (23)
- Oh dear, Todd - I was hoping you had moved on from. . . - Chris from Lafayette 11:30:11 09/10/21 (7)
- RE: Oh dear, Todd - I was hoping you had moved on from. . . - Todd Krieger 02:57:43 09/12/21 (6)
- I am truly baffled by your suspicions regarding the Simon Bolivar Orchestra - Analog Scott 07:13:03 09/12/21 (5)
- RE: I am truly baffled by your suspicions regarding the Simon Bolivar Orchestra - Todd Krieger 19:56:07 09/13/21 (1)
- No, just two - Analog Scott 02:16:45 09/14/21 (0)
- Must be a Deeeeeeeep Fake! - Sibelius 10:00:00 09/12/21 (2)
- New depths of deep fake - Analog Scott 11:07:21 09/12/21 (1)
- RE: New depths of deep fake - Sibelius 11:20:31 09/12/21 (0)
- one other thing.That link... - Analog Scott 19:24:18 09/07/21 (1)
- RE: one other thing.That link... - Todd Krieger 22:44:08 09/07/21 (0)
- yes I was refering to that one. You are kidding I hope? - Analog Scott 19:09:33 09/07/21 (12)
- Listening to Rach Concerto Three......... - Todd Krieger 14:47:20 09/09/21 (8)
- Here is what Stephan told me by email - Analog Scott 16:52:32 09/09/21 (7)
- RE: Here is what Stephan told me by email - Todd Krieger 20:28:53 09/09/21 (6)
- I don't know why you brought up "pitch" in the first place, in reference to this particular album - Analog Scott 23:33:46 09/09/21 (5)
- RE: I don't know why you brought up "pitch" in the first place, in reference to this particular album - Todd Krieger 00:23:29 09/10/21 (4)
- RE: I don't know why you brought up "pitch" in the first place, in reference to this particular album - Analog Scott 05:17:51 09/10/21 (3)
- RE: I don't know why you brought up "pitch" in the first place, in reference to this particular album - Todd Krieger 06:17:57 09/10/21 (2)
- no real close ties to The Simon Bolivar Orchestra - Analog Scott 09:14:05 09/10/21 (1)
- Got It...... - Todd Krieger 01:25:43 09/12/21 (0)
- RE: yes I was refering to that one. You are kidding I hope? - Todd Krieger 22:40:06 09/07/21 (2)
- RE: yes I was refering to that one. You are kidding I hope? - Todd Krieger 23:30:44 09/07/21 (1)
- RE: yes I was refering to that one. You are kidding I hope? - Todd Krieger 22:26:24 09/08/21 (0)