But if the "secret meanings" are whispered in a forest, and no one is around to hear them....

Follow Ups Full Thread

Topic - Okay, who was the greater composer, Prokofiev or Shostakovich? - Mali 18:14:30 05/02/21 (52)

RE: Okay, who was the greater composer, Prokofiev or Shostakovich? - peppy m. 08:38:26 05/05/21 (4)

Does that mean that Shostakovich is like Evander Holyfield? [nt] - Chris from Lafayette 10:57:07 05/05/21 (3)

Mike Tyson bit Evander Holyfield, not the other way around... - peppy m. 14:33:13 05/05/21 (2)

Indeed he did - was I suggesting that it was Holyfield. . . - Chris from Lafayette 14:47:01 05/05/21 (1)

OK, thanks. (nt - peppy m. 10:42:08 05/06/21 (0)

Greatness is determined by the parameters set by those discussing it - Analog Scott 16:22:00 05/03/21 (4)

My top five faves - Chris from Lafayette 00:32:41 05/05/21 (0)

Indeed, we can probably all agree this isn't a very great thread... - musetap 13:10:53 05/04/21 (1)

As of this posting, 43 responses - that's pretty darn great in my book! ;-) - Chris from Lafayette 00:35:15 05/05/21 (0)

Agreed. Are either, "great?" "Better" may be an easier, more accurate - tinear 10:52:41 05/04/21 (0)

To the original poster..What sort of conversation did you hope to encourage with your post? - John N 15:36:34 05/03/21 (3)

RE: To the original poster..What sort of conversation did you hope to encourage with your post? - Mali 08:34:40 05/04/21 (0)

For the record... - Ivan303 16:25:11 05/03/21 (0)

RE: To the original poster..What sort of conversation did you hope to encourage with your post? - rivervalley817 15:55:46 05/03/21 (0)

Not a question I lose sleep over. - Jim Treanor 14:36:47 05/03/21 (2)

What? You don't like the "happy ending" of Prokofiev's Seventh? - Chris from Lafayette 16:31:11 05/03/21 (1)

RE: What? You don't like the "happy ending" of Prokofiev's Seventh? - Jim Treanor 17:13:40 05/04/21 (0)

What makes for a great composer? If it's mastery of all genres, (Symphony, Opera, Chamber, Song, - jdaniel@jps.net 07:00:53 05/03/21 (8)

You have come to a wise conclusion, my son! - Chris from Lafayette 10:02:57 05/03/21 (7)

Jack of all trades, master of none - jimbill 12:08:38 05/03/21 (4)

and supposing otherwise - DrChaos 14:23:05 05/03/21 (0)

"What he [Chopin] did write has stood the test of time" - Chris from Lafayette 14:12:07 05/03/21 (2)

Inertia? - jimbill 15:02:42 05/03/21 (1)

You know. . . Inertia! - Chris from Lafayette 01:03:28 05/05/21 (0)

Thank you, Grandfather. : ) nt - jdaniel@jps.net 11:06:52 05/03/21 (1)

Hey! I said "son" - not "grandson" [nt] ;-) - Chris from Lafayette 14:13:27 05/03/21 (0)

Not sure I'm comfortable participating in this discussion... - Ivan303 06:03:25 05/03/21 (4)

Even so, you could have mentioned the "Leningrad" Symphony. . . - Chris from Lafayette 10:12:18 05/03/21 (3)

I was thinking more along the lines of... - Ivan303 13:14:38 05/03/21 (2)

Hmm... - Jim Treanor 14:41:13 05/03/21 (0)

Man - that's harsh! [nt] - Chris from Lafayette 14:07:00 05/03/21 (0)

Prokofiev - what is wrong with you people! ;-) - Chris from Lafayette 00:32:56 05/03/21 (17)

RE: Prokofiev - what is wrong with you people! ;-) - Dr. Fuse 18:07:25 06/05/21 (0)

RE Rach 2d, Prok 6th, &c: Not Sure I Understand Your Distinctions - goldenthal 17:13:20 05/07/21 (0)

Agreed, I can live without Shostakovich - Jay Buridan 05:43:40 05/04/21 (5)

RE: Agreed, I can live without Shostakovich - Mali 09:07:36 05/04/21 (0)

Even "The Nose??" : ) I prefer Prokofiev but certainly still enjoy much of Shosty's output - jdaniel@jps.net 07:35:18 05/04/21 (3)

Was being a little facetious - Jay Buridan 11:34:08 05/05/21 (0)

I love the 14th by Rostropovich/Ensemble Of Soloists Of The Moscow Philharmonic. Unusally good Melodiya LP. nt - Rick W 11:13:23 05/04/21 (0)

RE: Even "The Nose??" : ) I prefer Prokofiev but certainly still enjoy much of Shosty's output - Mali 08:40:38 05/04/21 (0)

Agreed... (nt) - TWB 07:23:45 05/03/21 (0)

Just listened to the Shostokovich 4th sym. again last night - Mali 07:14:09 05/03/21 (1)

Will be downloading Nelsons' BSO 4th soon. Still like Jarvi's best, but we'll see. nt - jdaniel@jps.net 08:07:28 05/04/21 (0)

But if the "secret meanings" are whispered in a forest, and no one is around to hear them.... - jdaniel@jps.net 06:53:52 05/03/21 (0)

When Johnny Comes Marching Home (arr. Shostakovich) - pbarach 05:49:06 05/03/21 (3)

OMG! That was new to me! - Well that certainly raises Shostakovich in my estimation! [nt] ;-) - Chris from Lafayette 09:55:39 05/03/21 (2)

As should his take on Vincent Youmans... - Jim Treanor 15:09:31 05/03/21 (1)

THAT one I had heard before! ;-) - Chris from Lafayette 16:24:57 05/03/21 (0)

supposed to vs is - DrChaos 00:58:19 05/03/21 (0)

RE: Okay, who was the greater composer, Prokofiev or Shostakovich? - Todd Krieger 23:35:00 05/02/21 (0)

Shostakovich for symphonies and quartets... - SE 19:10:05 05/02/21 (0)

For me, Shostakovich, for the same reasons that you give for you. nt. - MWE 19:09:27 05/02/21 (0)

Follow Ups

But if the "secret meanings" are whispered in a forest, and no one is around to hear them.... - jdaniel@jps.net 06:53:52 05/03/21 (0)

Post a Message!