In Reply to: MQA posted by slartybardfast on June 2, 2017 at 23:51:17:
The fundamental premise of MQA is to reduce the file size of a high-res file. To date the very best *lossless* way to do this was developed by Michael Gerzon in the 1990s, and his predictive algorithms forms the basis for all lossless compression schemes (eg, FLAC, ALAC, Dolby True-HD, MLP, Shorten, et cetera). Of these FLAC is the most commonly used and is considered the best overall optimization of these. None of them have a distinct advantage in terms of the overall file size after compression.
MQA reduces the files size by using lossy techniques. Specifically the least significant bits in the audio band of a PCM file are replaced by a compressed version of the ultrasonic audio data, resulting in a trade-off between bandwidth and resolution (no free lunch).
When starting with a 24-bit container, this may make sense in some circumstances. For example an original 96/24 file can be "folded" into a 48/24 container. Undecoded playback is at 48/17, while decoded playback is "unfolded" as a 96/17 file. It is up to the customer to decide if this is a step forward or a step backward.
However Redbook CD is limited to 16-bit containers. My understanding is that a decoded MQA CD would yield 88/13 playback, and undecoded would yield 44/13 playback. Again, it is up to the customer to decide if this is a step forward or a step backward.
As always, my posts reflect my personal opinions and not necessarily those of my employer or friends.
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Topic - MQA - slartybardfast 23:51:17 06/02/17 (13)
- There's no free lunch - Charles Hansen 11:16:06 06/03/17 (4)
- RE: There's no free lunch - slartybardfast 16:33:51 06/03/17 (3)
- RE: MQA - knewton 08:00:32 06/03/17 (0)
- RE: MQA - PAR 02:51:29 06/03/17 (5)
- RE: MQA - ahendler 09:33:19 06/03/17 (0)
- I read somewhere that an MQA Dac is needed to play the MQA/CD. nt - oldmkvi 03:58:00 06/03/17 (1)
- RE: I read somewhere that an MQA Dac is needed to play the MQA/CD. nt - ahendler 09:34:18 06/03/17 (0)
- RE: MQA - slartybardfast 03:27:23 06/03/17 (1)
- RE: MQA - PAR 08:01:14 06/03/17 (0)
- RE: MQA - Todd Krieger 01:52:53 06/03/17 (0)