Critic's Corner Discuss a review. Provide constructive feedback. Talk to the industry. |
|
In Reply to: RE: Julian Hirsch acolyte posted by Daverz on October 18, 2019 at 12:54:14:
I learned it was an utterly useless metric when I was a teenager. Information that conveys no knowledge.
I learn far more from those who understand music and its subtleties. To each his own.
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Follow Ups Full ThreadTopic - Audio Science Review - merid 18:00:01 10/17/19 (136)
- You'll get very 'short shrift' indeed at ASR - Feanor 11:37:38 12/22/20 (1)
- Agreed. ASR has a toxic atmosphere unless you're an absolute objectivist.[nt] - Steve Cortez 16:18:28 12/28/20 (0)
- RE: Audio Science Review - Davey 10:17:40 10/21/19 (3)
- RE: Audio Science Review - Rod M 18:30:37 10/24/19 (0)
- RE: Audio Science Review - Dave VH 10:33:54 10/21/19 (1)
- RE: Audio Science Review - Davey 12:02:25 10/21/19 (0)
- Numerical masturbation - Dave_K 08:27:17 10/21/19 (41)
- Finally someone wants to try and verify some of the numbers, many of the manufacturers are quoting... - Ugly 15:59:53 10/21/19 (20)
- It would be nicer if he understood more about what he was measuring. - richardl 11:22:38 10/28/19 (1)
- RE: It would be nicer if he understood more about what he was measuring. - Ugly 22:35:59 10/28/19 (0)
- RE: Finally someone wants to try and verify some of the numbers, many of the manufacturers are quoting... - Dave_K 14:08:19 10/22/19 (3)
- RE: Finally someone wants to try and verify some of the numbers, many of the manufacturers are quoting... - Ugly 21:45:23 10/22/19 (2)
- RE: Finally someone wants to try and verify some of the numbers, many of the manufacturers are quoting... - Dave_K 12:55:51 10/24/19 (1)
- RE: Finally someone wants to try and verify some of the numbers, many of the manufacturers are quoting... - Ugly 11:58:34 10/26/19 (0)
- Yet he never can seem to measure the width of the case - Sordidman 16:19:46 10/21/19 (13)
- RE: Yet he never can seem to measure the width of the case - Ugly 17:04:33 10/21/19 (12)
- RE: Yet he never can seem to measure the width of the case - Sordidman 10:48:50 10/24/19 (3)
- RE: Yet he never can seem to measure the width of the case - Ugly 13:45:03 10/27/19 (2)
- For the consumer, there is NOTHING of value - Sordidman 10:04:24 10/28/19 (1)
- RE: For the consumer, there is NOTHING of value - Ugly 20:00:26 10/28/19 (0)
- RE: Yet he never can seem to measure the width of the case - Cuckoo And Delusional 17:12:02 10/21/19 (7)
- RE: Yet he never can seem to measure the width of the case - Ugly 17:41:08 10/21/19 (5)
- RE: Yet he never can seem to measure the width of the case - Cuckoo And Delusional 18:03:16 10/21/19 (4)
- RE: Yet he never can seem to measure the width of the case - Ugly 20:44:03 10/21/19 (0)
- RE: Yet he never can seem to measure the width of the case - Dave VH 18:24:28 10/21/19 (2)
- RE: Yet he never can seem to measure the width of the case - srjit 18:51:43 10/21/19 (1)
- RE: Yet he never can seem to measure the width of the case - Dave VH 18:57:11 10/21/19 (0)
- RE: Yet he never can seem to measure the width of the case - Dave VH 17:25:29 10/21/19 (0)
- RE: Numerical masturbation - Daverz 15:05:00 10/21/19 (1)
- I agree on that point - Dave_K 07:55:05 10/22/19 (0)
- +1 Plus an over-abundant appeal to authority - Sordidman 12:58:35 10/21/19 (0)
- RE: Numerical masturbation - Dave VH 10:53:14 10/21/19 (14)
- RE: Numerical masturbation - Cuckoo And Delusional 11:20:08 10/21/19 (13)
- RE: Numerical masturbation - srjit 14:18:10 10/21/19 (3)
- RE: Numerical masturbation - Cuckoo And Delusional 14:41:41 10/21/19 (0)
- RE: Numerical masturbation - srjit 14:20:07 10/21/19 (1)
- RE: Numerical masturbation - Cuckoo And Delusional 14:40:02 10/21/19 (0)
- RE: Numerical masturbation - Dave VH 12:02:54 10/21/19 (8)
- RE: Numerical masturbation - srjit 18:15:20 10/21/19 (1)
- RE: Andre Marc's other sockpuppet handle here - srjit - Dave VH 18:39:25 10/21/19 (0)
- RE: Numerical masturbation - Cuckoo And Delusional 13:40:02 10/21/19 (4)
- RE: Numerical masturbation - Dave VH 14:59:08 10/21/19 (3)
- RE: Numerical masturbation - Cuckoo And Delusional 15:14:33 10/21/19 (2)
- RE: Hello, Andre Marc... - Dave VH 16:05:29 10/21/19 (1)
- RE: Hello, Andre Marc... - Cuckoo And Delusional 16:10:41 10/21/19 (0)
- RE: Numerical masturbation - Cuckoo And Delusional 13:37:45 10/21/19 (0)
- Excellent Post----NT - lancelot 09:14:11 10/21/19 (0)
- RE: Numerical masturbation - CG 08:48:11 10/21/19 (0)
- Here's a good (recent) example of the way ASR operates - mhardy6647 06:50:17 10/21/19 (2)
- RE: Here's an even better (recent) example of the way ASR operates - Dave VH 11:54:19 10/21/19 (1)
- That is a shining example of what ASR gets wrong - Dave_K 12:04:37 10/24/19 (0)
- From a brief look - mind. - Timbo in Oz 22:28:49 10/18/19 (0)
- RE: Audio Science Review - hahax@verizon.net 20:36:12 10/18/19 (1)
- concur 100% (FWIW) nt - mhardy6647 14:56:16 10/21/19 (0)
- as I like to say about them - mhardy6647 17:51:31 10/18/19 (3)
- Absolutely - Lots of commitment to DBT's, but SFA mention of Alpha and Beta. - Timbo in Oz 02:16:38 10/20/19 (0)
- +1 -nt - E-Stat 08:33:32 10/19/19 (0)
- RE: as I like to say about them - CG 18:30:57 10/18/19 (0)
- RE: Audio Science Review - Cuckoo And Delusional 22:16:49 10/17/19 (20)
- RE: Audio Science Review - Ugly 12:45:15 10/21/19 (0)
- Oh, a typical audiophile then. nt - viridian 18:12:33 10/18/19 (1)
- RE: Oh, a typical audiophile then. nt - Cuckoo And Delusional 18:13:37 10/18/19 (0)
- That's why I like it...! nt - oldmkvi 08:38:12 10/18/19 (0)
- RE: Audio Science Review - merid 06:50:00 10/18/19 (1)
- RE: Audio Science Review - Cuckoo And Delusional 07:53:19 10/18/19 (0)
- RE: Audio Science Review - CG 04:54:44 10/18/19 (13)
- RE: Audio Science Review - Cuckoo And Delusional 07:52:44 10/18/19 (12)
- well -- he knows how to push the 'start test' button on it :) (nt) - mhardy6647 17:55:04 10/18/19 (0)
- RE: Audio Science Review - CG 13:33:41 10/18/19 (10)
- RE: Audio Science Review - E-Stat 16:53:57 10/18/19 (9)
- so -- the thing about "Amir" -- s/n seems to be the only thing he thinks is REALLY important - mhardy6647 17:59:13 10/18/19 (0)
- RE: Audio Science Review - CG 17:29:51 10/18/19 (7)
- RE: Audio Science Review - E-Stat 06:07:20 10/19/19 (6)
- RE: Audio Science Review - CG 06:23:29 10/19/19 (5)
- RE: Audio Science Review - E-Stat 06:29:16 10/19/19 (4)
- RE: Audio Science Review - CG 06:59:56 10/19/19 (3)
- RE: Audio Science Review - E-Stat 07:06:14 10/19/19 (2)
- RE: Audio Science Review - CG 08:00:48 10/19/19 (1)
- It appears we agree on the topic - E-Stat 08:09:41 10/19/19 (0)
- RE: Audio Science Review - Ivan303 18:08:12 10/17/19 (56)
- Or, very likely, that ... - 13th Duke of Wymbourne 17:55:55 10/18/19 (2)
- Or, more likely, you are measuring something... - Ivan303 17:50:46 10/19/19 (1)
- RE: Or, more likely, you are measuring something... - 13th Duke of Wymbourne 11:51:41 10/21/19 (0)
- Julian Hirsch acolyte - E-Stat 08:30:28 10/18/19 (52)
- RE: Julian Hirsch acolyte - Daverz 12:54:14 10/18/19 (6)
- :) (nt) - mhardy6647 17:56:29 10/18/19 (0)
- You find THD useful? - E-Stat 14:13:10 10/18/19 (3)
- IMD is more worrisome. - Daverz 18:55:15 10/18/19 (1)
- RE: IMD is more worrisome. - Dave_K 06:41:08 10/21/19 (0)
- it's easy to measure and, with NFB, easy to minimize... - mhardy6647 18:02:37 10/18/19 (0)
- Vogon poetry...that's funny and apropos... - Steve O 13:18:53 10/18/19 (0)
- RE: Julian Hirsch acolyte - Cuckoo And Delusional 12:19:10 10/18/19 (44)
- RE: Julian Hirsch acolyte - E-Stat 12:51:32 10/18/19 (43)
- RE: Julian Hirsch acolyte - Cuckoo And Delusional 15:57:18 10/18/19 (42)
- Understood - E-Stat 16:39:50 10/18/19 (41)
- RE: Understood - Cuckoo And Delusional 17:34:28 10/18/19 (40)
- I am not sure he has such an agenda, I just think he's short on savvy (nt) - mhardy6647 18:08:08 10/18/19 (39)
- RE: I am not sure he has such an agenda, I just think he's short on savvy (nt) - Cuckoo And Delusional 18:12:34 10/18/19 (38)
- so -- does the person responsible for, say, Microsoft "Bob" have a website, too? :) - mhardy6647 05:00:15 10/19/19 (0)
- what is/was the "WBF site"? - mhardy6647 19:32:57 10/18/19 (1)
- RE: what is/was the "WBF site"? - Cuckoo And Delusional 19:42:08 10/18/19 (0)
- Was it not "Bill" Gaetz' job not to be surprised by Apple?... - John Marks 19:03:53 10/18/19 (34)
- RE: Was it not "Bill" Gaetz' job not to be surprised by Apple?... - CG 07:02:02 10/19/19 (0)
- RE: Was it not "Bill" Gaetz' job not to be surprised by Apple?... - Cuckoo And Delusional 19:46:39 10/18/19 (32)
- RE: Was it not "Bill" Gaetz' job not to be surprised by Apple?... - Daverz 13:52:26 10/19/19 (31)
- RE: Was it not "Bill" Gaetz' job not to be surprised by Apple?... - Cuckoo And Delusional 14:06:26 10/19/19 (30)
- RE: Was it not "Bill" Gaetz' job not to be surprised by Apple?... - dkt88 17:11:47 10/19/19 (3)
- RE: Was it not "Bill" Gaetz' job not to be surprised by Apple?... - Cuckoo And Delusional 17:30:46 10/19/19 (2)
- RE: Was it not "Bill" Gaetz' job not to be surprised by Apple?... - dkt88 17:54:37 10/19/19 (1)
- RE: Was it not "Bill" Gaetz' job not to be surprised by Apple?... - Cuckoo And Delusional 18:02:52 10/19/19 (0)
- RE: Was it not "Bill" Gaetz' job not to be surprised by Apple?... - Daverz 17:08:28 10/19/19 (12)
- RE: Was it not "Bill" Gaetz' job not to be surprised by Apple?... - Garyk 13:54:44 01/01/20 (0)
- RE: Was it not "Bill" Gaetz' job not to be surprised by Apple?... - Dave VH 18:08:43 10/19/19 (9)
- RE: Was it not "Bill" Gaetz' job not to be surprised by Apple?... - srjit 21:06:35 10/20/19 (5)
- RE: Was it not "Bill" Gaetz' job not to be surprised by Apple?... - srjit 21:18:53 10/20/19 (4)
- RE: Was it not "Bill" Gaetz' job not to be surprised by Apple?... - Dave VH 09:49:26 10/21/19 (3)
- RE: Was it not "Bill" Gaetz' job not to be surprised by Apple?... - Cuckoo And Delusional 10:04:36 10/21/19 (2)
- RE: Countering anti-ASR b.s. - Dave VH 10:25:23 10/21/19 (1)
- Right - E-Stat 15:44:38 10/22/19 (0)
- RE: Was it not "Bill" Gaetz' job not to be surprised by Apple?... - Cuckoo And Delusional 18:13:23 10/19/19 (2)
- RE: Was it not "Bill" Gaetz' job not to be surprised by Apple?... - Dave VH 18:23:43 10/19/19 (1)
- RE: Was it not "Bill" Gaetz' job not to be surprised by Apple?... - Cuckoo And Delusional 18:25:24 10/19/19 (0)
- RE: Was it not "Bill" Gaetz' job not to be surprised by Apple?... - Cuckoo And Delusional 17:28:12 10/19/19 (0)
- RE: Was it not "Bill" Gaetz' job not to be surprised by Apple?... - Dave VH 15:59:44 10/19/19 (12)
- RE: Was it not "Bill" Gaetz' job not to be surprised by Apple?... - Cuckoo And Delusional 16:32:57 10/19/19 (11)
- RE: Was it not "Bill" Gaetz' job not to be surprised by Apple?... - Dave VH 17:31:16 10/19/19 (10)
- RE: Was it not "Bill" Gaetz' job not to be surprised by Apple?... - Cuckoo And Delusional 17:37:22 10/19/19 (9)
- RE: Was it not "Bill" Gaetz' job not to be surprised by Apple?... - Dave VH 19:04:45 10/19/19 (8)
- RE: Was it not "Bill" Gaetz' job not to be surprised by Apple?... - Cuckoo And Delusional 19:15:25 10/19/19 (7)
- RE: Was it not "Bill" Gaetz' job not to be surprised by Apple?... - Dave VH 20:32:53 10/19/19 (6)
- RE: Was it not "Bill" Gaetz' job not to be surprised by Apple?... - Cuckoo And Delusional 08:50:34 10/20/19 (5)
- RE: Was it not "Bill" Gaetz' job not to be surprised by Apple?... - Dave VH 09:44:04 10/20/19 (4)
- RE: Was it not "Bill" Gaetz' job not to be surprised by Apple?... - Cuckoo And Delusional 10:10:07 10/20/19 (3)
- RE: Was it not "Bill" Gaetz' job not to be surprised by Apple?... - Dave VH 17:17:54 10/20/19 (2)
- RE: Was it not "Bill" Gaetz' job not to be surprised by Apple?... - Cuckoo And Delusional 17:29:30 10/20/19 (1)
- RE: Was it not "Bill" Gaetz' job not to be surprised by Apple?... - Dave VH 19:47:34 10/20/19 (0)
Follow Ups
- You find THD useful? - E-Stat 14:13:10 10/18/19 (3)
- IMD is more worrisome. - Daverz 18:55:15 10/18/19 (1)
- RE: IMD is more worrisome. - Dave_K 06:41:08 10/21/19 (0)
- it's easy to measure and, with NFB, easy to minimize... - mhardy6647 18:02:37 10/18/19 (0)